News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ten Days of Silence by savage_platypus on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:13AM (#9677456)
This sounds like more feel-good pseudoscientific hogwash.

Is there any evidence that "not talking" can actually lead to an improved life, or is this yet another fad that makes people feel good about themselves?

Re:Ten Days of Silence by littletimmy on Monday June 08, 2015 @04:00AM (#9677754)
What exactly do you mean by pseudoscientific? The article was not really presenting a scientific claim. What we saw was a story about a person who did thing X, experienced thing Y, and is now describing his experience while thinking about what it might mean for someone else. Where does science come into the picture?

You sound like one of those annoying fellows who would dismiss the works of Dostoyevsky as pseudoscientific, or the music of Beethoven as hogwash. Get out of your limited perspective every once in a while and see that there exists a whole world out that that does not require classification in mathematical models to appreciate.

Re:Ten Days of Silence by dnewms on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:27AM (#9677496)
It's more than not talking, though. It's extreme meditation. If you didn't have to worry about anything in your life for ten days, where to sleep, what to eat next, the next project, proposal, email, significant or insignificant others, where would your mind wander?

I don't think it's feel-good anything, and not claiming to be scientific. I think it's stressing the mind in a way that it's typically never stressed, resulting in outcomes that others have never experienced. And because of that, they want to share it -- as is human nature.

Re:Ten Days of Silence by mtinkerhess on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:34AM (#9677515)
People have been meditating for at least 3,500 years, I wouldn't call it a fad.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_meditation

Re:Ten Days of Silence by sb057 on Monday June 08, 2015 @03:37AM (#9677671)
People have been practicing tribal medicine for just as long. Not a fad either.
Re:Ten Days of Silence by rosser on Monday June 08, 2015 @03:40AM (#9677683)
And, it turns out, some of those things even work. I know, right?
Re:Ten Days of Silence by palmer_eldritch on Monday June 08, 2015 @09:38AM (#9678933)
I guess with enough trial and error, you can find solutions to many problems, no matter how flawed your understanding of the problem is.
Re:Ten Days of Silence by pav7en on Monday June 08, 2015 @04:54PM (#9682323)
It's always a good thing to question. Unless of course you belong to the camp who choose to be wilfully ignorant and closed in light of overwhelming evidence.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9679537

Re:Ten Days of Silence by rosser on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:33AM (#9677514)
I know a number of people who've done Vipassana retreats, and there do appear to be material changes in their lives after. How long those benefits last seems to correlate pretty strongly with whether they continue to meditate upon returning home.

So, yes. Anecdotally, anyway. Leaving entirely aside, you know, all the research on the benefits of meditation, ever.

Re:Ten Days of Silence by SalmoShalazar on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:23AM (#9677488)
From what I recall, meditation has proven physiological effects on the body, so there's that. I would not be surprised if 10 days of the lifestyle described in the article would change the way you think about things, at least for a little while. Whether or not this is related to an improved life, who knows, I imagine your mileage will vary.
Re:Ten Days of Silence by willyyr on Monday June 08, 2015 @03:53AM (#9677720)
The "not talking" part is basically just there to help you stick to the code of discipline [1] which is:

1. to abstain from killing any being; 2. to abstain from stealing; 3. to abstain from all sexual activity; 4. to abstain from telling lies; 5. to abstain from all intoxicants.

With "not talking" you automatically follow number 4 :)

[1] https://www.dhamma.org/en/about/code

Re:Ten Days of Silence by ma2rten on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:23AM (#9677483)
Re:Ten Days of Silence by savage_platypus on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:48AM (#9677553)
The report concluded, "Scientific research on meditation practices does not appear to have a common theoretical perspective and is characterized by poor methodological quality. Firm conclusions on the effects of meditation practices in healthcare cannot be drawn based on the available evidence. Future research on meditation practices must be more rigorous in the design and execution of studies and in the analysis and reporting of results." (p. 6) It noted that there is no theoretical explanation of health effects from meditation common to all meditation techniques.
Re:Ten Days of Silence by ctolsen on Monday June 08, 2015 @06:16AM (#9678120)
You're citing from one meta study out of plenty. Also, it's ten years old. Many things have happened since then, especially things to address those weaknesses – MBSR (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mindfulness-based_stress_reduct...) has been developed further, and is a method of meditation that is in part designed so that you can do science on it.

Looking at a 2013 report (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23796855), results are quite different. Or this interview (http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/inspired-life/wp/2015/05/...) showing potential physical changes in the brain.

Furthermore, meditation isn't about objective health gains to many people. It's about living in a different way, in a different state.

Re:Ten Days of Silence by pcrh on Monday June 08, 2015 @06:15AM (#9678116)
Scientific research has shown that modification of behaviour and perceptions can be achieved without surgical or pharmaceutical intervention. This goes by the name of psychotherapy. In particular, cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) has been shown to work in randomized controlled trials [1].

As such therapies involve only guiding and helping people to think differently, it demonstrates that such guidance has have scientifically measurable effects on the mind and body.

It follows from the above that the likelihood that practices such as meditation could have non-zero effects is high. Whether Vipassana itself does so could therefore be tested in the same manner as CBT was, and perhaps that is what should be done...

[1]https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=randomized+contro...

Re:Ten Days of Silence by pizza234 on Monday June 08, 2015 @03:34AM (#9677661)
Meditation is not rocket science.

The western lifestyle, simply put, is messy, and you get pulled in many directions, with the most important side effect of losing attention to yourself.

Meditation simply restores (quite forcefully, in this case) at least part of that attention.

If you find hard to grasp the concept, you can imagine it as being the analogue of being "in the zone" when programming (or anything else).

I don't think it would actually be too far-fetched to think "the zone" as a form of meditation.

Re:Ten Days of Silence by devnonymous on Monday June 08, 2015 @03:17AM (#9677629)
Umm, it is pseudoscience inasmuch no real study has been conducted (it isn't 'exciting' enough ...yet). So, yeah this is anecdotal but that doesn't make it false. A number of people I know have been through the vipasanna course and express the same sentiment. I wonder why it is popular now to expect ^someone^ to do the research and present ^evidence^ before they can even begin to become curious about something.

Does scientific curiosity these days hinge on someone else having done the tests ?

Does it automatically qualify as hogwash because there isn't and evidence yet ? or because we have a tendency to doubt things not deeply rooted in numbers and double blind tests, /even if/ the reason for that is a simple -- nobody has bothered to do this yet.

Re:Ten Days of Silence by bencollier49 on Monday June 08, 2015 @07:06AM (#9678222)
Blame the homeopaths and chiropractors.

I think this is in a different class though, it's subjective, so the tests aren't necessarily necessary.