News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by cies on Saturday June 06, 2015 @08:40AM (#9670557)
> undermines democracy

Sorry which democracy? If these talks and their outcomes are already a secret (without discussing matters of national security), then this is one more reason for me not to consider the EU nor the US a democracy. The people have just a tiny fraction of power compared to the corps.

Let's just be fair and teach the next generations that our countries have been hijacked by corps+lobbyists, and that democracy is just a word used to make people accept their totalitarian power.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by MarcusVorenus on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:43AM (#9670951)
Sound like sour grapes and No True Scotsman to me. The president, who is leading negotiations, was elected democratically, and Congress, who decides whether this treaty becomes law or not, was also elected democratically. If the people dislike how the government is doing things they have only themselves to blame for electing these representatives.

To be honest I don't believe anybody really cares about the ideals of democracy. If the same secrecy was being used to push legislation you supported you wouldn't be whining at all, you would probably be defending it instead because you would rationalize that passing the law is more important than the method used to pass it.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by calibraxis on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:51AM (#9670975)
That's not democracy. That's doublespeak. The US's "Founding Fathers" hated democracy and stressed it was a republic. Those slaveowners wanted to protect minorities against majority rule — the wealthy minority. (Obviously they didn't mean African Americans and women.)

Later politicians coopted the term "democracy", as marketing. One source to learn more is Graeber's "The Democracy Project". (http://lareviewofbooks.org/review/democracy-what-is-it-good-...)

Pushing a button every few years for your new corporate-sponsored king isn't meaningful democratic participation.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by rhino369 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:34PM (#9671543)
Hating democracy is a massive overstatement. It was designed as a democratically elected representative republic. They didn't want a mob ruling, but at the base, the people select the representatives. That is how virtually every democracy runs itself.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by MarcusVorenus on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:37AM (#9671116)
Obama is a union-sponsored king actually, so it's all good I guess.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by lumberjack on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:47AM (#9671152)
Neither Obama nor Clinton are sponsored by unions. Their major sponsors are Wall St, universities, SV and Hollywood, i.e. typical wealthy democrats.

http://www.opensecrets.org/PRES08/contrib.php?cid=N00009638

Maybe you were thinking about Bernie Sanders?

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by MarcusVorenus on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:08PM (#9671252)
Unions don't donate directly, they make independent campaign expenditures through Super PACs. Look in the Independent Expenditures tab in the page you gave me.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by mikeash on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:59AM (#9671004)
Most of those elections, at least in the US, are arranged to be a choice between two bad candidates with relatively small (even if sometimes important) differences. That's not a real choice and the fact that one of them won shouldn't be construed as approval.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by MarcusVorenus on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:18AM (#9671063)
There are primaries and third parties, you know? That the final choice comes down to two mediocre individuals says more about the intelligence of the average voter than any sort of corporate conspiracy.

I'll give you though that the first-past-the-post system is terrible and you would be better off with a proportional system.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by task_queue on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:46PM (#9671765)
Until third parties get the funding and backing by powerful people that already run the nation, they aren't able to produce a truly viable candidate.

They won't get the exposure. They'll be pigeonholed as the joke candidate by the well-funded machines that have interest in making sure you don't consider leaving the two-party system that's worked well for them.

Needing excessive funding and backing by elites to really be considered a candidate implies that only those who promise to uphold their interests will be portrayed as being a legitimate choice.

The option for a third party is in the specification, but we've purposely implemented it in such a way that power remains in the hands of the few.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by mikeash on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:20AM (#9671070)
Third parties do nothing useful. Primaries could be useful, but in practice aren't.

And sure, maybe it's voter intelligence or apathy rather than some conspiracy. Doesn't matter. I'm just saying the result isn't representative and shouldn't be framed as the will of the people. I'm not saying anything about the root cause.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by MarcusVorenus on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:53AM (#9671189)
> I'm just saying the result isn't representative and shouldn't be framed as the will of the people.

Fine, but then you can't really frame anything as being or not the will of the people as there's no point of reference. You can't say that TTIP and TPP and TISA are not the will of the people just because Reddit and a bunch of news sites like to hate on them, for instance.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by mikeash on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:06PM (#9671456)
Sure you can. You can go see what people actually want and see how it lines up with the actions of their elected officials.

Often the two do line up. Sometimes they don't. The fact that these officials were elected doesn't automatically indicate either way.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by Veratyr on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:35PM (#9671553)
First past the post is actually an inherently two party system [0]. It would take a monumental amount of effort to overcome that bias and an intelligent voter knows that they can't beat the system and have to work with it. Thus, the final choice for all voters is still two mediocre individuals.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by thaumaturgy on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:18PM (#9672104)
Yep. Those of us who voted for Kucinich in the primaries were impressed by his fair treatment of the televised debate system and the amount of support he was able to garner from the Democratic party. I'm very grateful that we have a political system in this country in which money isn't at all a factor, because I don't know how I could handle living in a country in which wealth was directed towards those candidates that would be most likely to serve the interests of that wealth.

I bet a country like that would fall victim to a two-party system virtually over night. I wouldn't even be surprised if it ended up being a single-party system where the two parties were only superficially different.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by task_queue on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:12PM (#9671673)
Elections don't make a democracy. They had elections in Your Favorite Totalitarian State, too.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by squeeze on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:34PM (#9671550)
I believe in democracy.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by cies on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:24PM (#9671701)
Me too! That's why I lament the fact that it is not (maybe even quite opposite).

I think we should try it, like trias-politica and all, by trying to keep our legislative leg free from non-democratic influences. Like those mehhhh lobby organisations.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by crdoconnor on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:47AM (#9670780)
>Let's just be fair and teach the next generations that our countries have been hijacked by corps+lobbyists, and that democracy is just a word used to make people accept their totalitarian power.

You can fight them, you know.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by DyslexicAtheist on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:37AM (#9670932)
I have been wondering why all this madness hasn't resulted in more violent uprisings by ideologically radicalised groups or individuals. History in Europe has seen lesser triggers to call for (or act out) the expulsion of similar individuals like Karel de Gucht.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Army_Faction

If anything, the high unemployment in the EU over the past decade would have been a fertile breeding ground for such ideas. I'd say we're doing pretty well so far as a society by not engaging in more drastic measures given how much our rights are trampled on.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by task_queue on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:18PM (#9671684)
Lack of solidarity, co-opted fronts, infiltration and neutralization of non co-opted organizations by economic interests and easy fractures among the economic class based on ethnicity/religion/arbitrary differences have historically been great ways at keeping a population from gaining a consciousness about their situation as a whole.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by notahacker on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:47PM (#9671767)
As has the historic tendency for the average citizen in countries run by plutocrats to enjoy substantially better standards of living, as well as a good deal more peace, than countries run by "class conscious" revolutionaries...
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by task_queue on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:42PM (#9672590)
You're railing against a point I didn't make.

You can have a "class consciousness" without pulling out the hyperbole and Stalin card.

This consciousness is what afforded us civil rights, granted us a safe work place, an eight hour work day, labor rights and bought us social programs that keep people from dying in the streets.

Somehow these "class conscious" revolutionaries didn't let society devolve into chaos.

It's this consciousness that we need to remind ourselves and those with power of our worth. Otherwise, we'll continue to get fucked over. No one will offer to make us concessions that we never had the power to ask for.

The majority of the third world and anyone who wasn't born into the right religion/race/family in the first world would like to have a word with your first point, though.

I guess we shouldn't realize nor negotiate from our position in society since being run by plutocrats isn't so bad because you say so.

Good plutocrats try to make sure their population has "just enough" that they don't rally in the streets with guns. Relying on the goodwill of these people is an absurd expectation.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by crdoconnor on Sunday June 07, 2015 @05:09AM (#9673931)
>As has the historic tendency for the average citizen in countries run by plutocrats to enjoy substantially better standards of living

This isn't true at all.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by cies on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:28PM (#9671717)
Wise words. I second every bit of what you just caused my browser to render on screen.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by adventured on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:03PM (#9671230)
The reason you're not seeing that kind of revolution, is the modern central bank system in place enables the use of fiat to placate the population for a dramatically longer amount of time than was possible in eg 1920 or 1940.

The EU is doing that right now, debasing the Euro to reduce the overall massive debt load and fake growth to placate the population and pretend to show things improving. Being able to abuse the currency makes it easy to continue to meet social obligations, but in actuality they're defaulting on those obligations through currency devaluation (ie the net result being citizens of the EU will suffer a lower standard of living, while most people won't realize what's happening until years later).

If Japan couldn't abuse the Yen to fill the huge hole in their budget that their debt is causing, what would happen to their government? It would have already collapsed, unable to pay its bills. It's only the fiat system that enables them to continue. Japanese savers used to pay for the debt accumulation, then their savings rate collapsed; so now the Japanese government is taking wealth from their citizens via currency devaluation instead to keep covering the debt costs.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by qubex on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:03PM (#9671637)
Central banks' reserved ("high power money") is only a tiny proportion of monetary supply (endogenous money).
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by crdoconnor on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:53AM (#9670979)
The far right and the far left are both growing in Europe.

We aren't as violent as we used to be in the 1970s-80s (violent crime has dropped precipitously, for instance). Perhaps because we don't use leaded petrol any more.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by lumberjack on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:54AM (#9671192)
>The far right and the far left are both growing in Europe.

The far-right consists of anti-immigration people. That's not far-right. That was a normal centre-right opinion just a few decades ago. It's definitely not Fascism despite the implication.

The far-left consists of people wanting to protect their government pension funds, green activists and people who do not like meddling by the likes of the IMF and WB. That's not far-left either. They definitely aren't communists.

It's ridiculous how the media portrays these mostly sane political opinions as extremes held only by extremists.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by anon1385 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:21PM (#9671292)
Jobbik[1] are now the third biggest party in Hungary. Their candidates are openly anti-semitic[2]. They want to return Hungary's borders to those of the pre-WWI Kingdom of Hungary. They put up statues to military commanders who were allies of Hitler. It would be a big mistake to call Jobbik just an anti-immigration movement.

I agree that there are very few far left parties in Europe with any number of elected politicians.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jobbik

[2] >In a newsletter published by a group calling itself "The trade union of Hungarian police officers prepared for action", the following was allegedly printed: "Given our current situation, anti-Semitism is not just our right, but it is the duty of every Hungarian homeland lover, and we must prepare for armed battle against the Jews." The editor of the union, Judit Szima, was a Jobbik candidate in the upcoming election for the European Union parliament. Haaretz alleged Szima "didn't see anything wrong with the content of the article."

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by crdoconnor on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:23AM (#9673743)
>The far-right consists of anti-immigration people. That's not far-right. That was a normal centre-right opinion just a few decades ago. It's definitely not Fascism despite the implication.

I think Golden Dawn waving Swastikas around counts as fascism, even if some of the other right-wing parties in Europe are more tiptoeing around it.

I honestly doubt real fascism will make any great gains until the financial elites feel their masters of the universe positions threatened, at which point some of them will throw their lot (and considerable wealth) in with the far right and ramp up the rhetoric and the violence. That's when things are going to get scary real fast.

We're not there yet, but the potential is growing very quickly. The fusion of a lot of cash, a paranoid elite and a bunch of terminally unemployed very pissed off young people is explosive.

>The far-left consists of people wanting to protect their government pension funds, green activists and people who do not like meddling by the likes of the IMF and WB. That's not far-left either. They definitely aren't communists.

There are communists in Europe, but yes, what is designated far left by the media these days is pathetically middle of the road by historical standards. Syriza's a mildly lefty damp squib.

>It's ridiculous how the media portrays these mostly sane political opinions as extremes held only by extremists.

Of course.

That said, left/right/far left/far right are all relative terms.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by qubex on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:58PM (#9671622)
I upvoted you because of the interesting historical context, but I'm not sure it is sensible to imply that anti-immigration stances are not reprehensible.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by timthorn on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:42PM (#9671752)
If anti-immigration is as a result of racism, that's one thing - but politics is a broad spectrum and I don't think it is sensible to close down the underlying debate on the topic by stigmatising those who believe immigration is an issue.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by rorykoehler on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:14PM (#9672502)
The only people I have met who are anti-immigration are also hardcore racists. I doubt it's a coincidence.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by task_queue on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:21PM (#9671693)
They may be reprehensible, but they aren't your hard line Fascists either.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by enlightenedfool on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:59AM (#9670817)
Inherent to democracy is the fact that the fighting "you" is minority and it keeps shrinking. Minority loses. But all good. Hopefully in a few centuries humanity will see bloody revolutions
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by crdoconnor on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:14AM (#9670869)
There are fewer lobbyists than people. They rely upon the masses being divided and unwilling to recognize their own power.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by joeyspn on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:40AM (#9670940)
Exactly, we live in a de facto Corporatocracy, and this treaty is the biggest proof that democracy was pushed into the background long time ago.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporatocracy

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by javert on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:08AM (#9671029)
No, we really don't. We live in a mixed economy, which means freedom mixed with government controls, which always means there are government-chosen winners and losers. It's what the people want, though. It's what we're taught is good in school; it's what we believe in.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by wyago on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:43PM (#9671571)
That's not really relevant to joeyspn's statement at all. He's not talking about an economic system, he's talking about a political system. While political systems influence economic systems, they don't have a one to one relationship. In the case of the US, we have a corporatocracy which maintains the current mixed economy.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by javert on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:56PM (#9671792)
"Corporatocracy" cannot be an appropriate name for a system where most corporations are the victim of a few corporations that have governmental powers.

So, "corporatocracy" is not a valid word.

It would be like calling a dictatorship a "manocracy."

On the subject of political vs. economic systems: a specific political system implies a specific economic system, and vice versa, so there isn't the distinction here that you think.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by x5n1 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:43AM (#9671141)
> hijacked by corps+lobbyists

corps+lobbyists+owners of capital(wealthy)

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by cies on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:25PM (#9671709)
I stand corrected :)
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by javert on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:05AM (#9671024)
Well, the US is not supposed to be a democracy, it's supposed to be a constitutional republic.

Neither the people nor corporations are supposed to have any power. "Power," here, means the ability to weild force against others.

The founding ideal of the US was that nobody could do that; in other words, it was supposed to be a system of freedom, as opposed to coercion.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by cies on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:32PM (#9671731)
I know for a fact that schools teach children, both in the US and in the EU, that they live in a democracy and should be happy with that.

I was not trying to hint on what it is supposed to be.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by javert on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:59PM (#9671809)
Yes, they do. Which serves to illustrate that we need separation of education and state, for the same reasons that we need separation of church and state.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by bad_user on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:08AM (#9670650)
I'm sure you have a point, but I just don't see it.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:23AM (#9670707)
I see the parent's point as being we need to stop referring to [plutocratic] oligarchies as democracies.

If you allow the rich to establish treaties that prevent nations from exercising sovereign power to bring those same rich people in to line, and you do it in private preventing the citizens/subjects from even knowing the details of the regime you intend to impose then you're operating well outside anything that can be described as democratic. TTIP seemingly intends to go further still, not only preventing nations from exercising sovereign powers against corporations but allowing the corporations (which are really proxies for the plutocrats) to exercise equivalent powers over those nations.

We've seen these sorts of powers in use by tobacco companies suing countries for trying to improve citizens health.

It's fantastic capitalism - profit above environment, profit above health, profit above morality, profit for the few against rights and freedoms of the many.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by cies on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:30PM (#9671720)
Thanks for clearing it up. I was indeed trying to make that point.
Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by blumkvist on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:08AM (#9670850)
1) A true democracy has never existed. The needle is pushed by a tiny percentage of all the people. Such is the nature of humans. Whether that's a good thing or a bad thing is up for a debate. Do you really want that Walmart cashier lady's take on policy? There are counter arguments as well of course, but that's not the main point of this thread.

2) >It's fantastic capitalism - profit above environment, profit above health, profit above morality, profit for the few against rights and freedoms of the many.

This statement shows that you have 0 understanding of capitalism in regards to society. Capitalism is not about selfishness. It is about self-interest. For example, it is not in the long term self-interest of energy companies that we are experiencing global warming and they know it, and despite what you think they are working on fixing that. It's just not so simple to shift.

3) Having said that, I for one, don't want someone who has such strong feelings about things he understands so little about, to have a say in policy making. He can be swayed so easy by emotions and articles in the NYT and form an opinion about complicated problems he has no clue about. But representative democracy is great, right?

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:46AM (#9670959)
>Do you really want that Walmart cashier lady's take on policy? //

Indeed, democracy is flawed - IMO it's the least worst system we have a chance of implementing effectively and with relative stability. I may not want a particular group's opinions but I'm prepared to accept that system over others.

As for "0 understanding of capitalism in regards to society" - I'm using capitalism as a short form for "Western capitalism" which is epitomised by things which aren't truly "capitalism" per se.

Semantic niceties aside energy companies in my country regularly act against their long term interest as do most businesses. Indeed they usually only act in a way that might be termed moral to fulfil legal obligations and then they tend to find a way to subvert their obligations. But then as the rhetoric here often reminds us "companies are there solely to make profit", shareholders complain if they do anything beyond their obligations. Energy companies are looking at their own goals and not societies needs.

As for 3 ... I'll confess now I didn't read the NYT article [I just assumed it was the same content as has been doing the rounds in the last couple of months - very similar to what's happening with TPP], I've been following TTIP since I learnt about it from ex-colleagues in the IPR community about 18 months ago. 38degrees started their campaign about 14 months ago IIRC. I'm the first to admit I'm ill informed on it, but that's almost the whole point - negotiations and details of the direction and end goal are hidden and actively kept secret even from representatives. There's no way for me to be completely informed. Representative democracy can't work if the representatives aren't even allowed to access the knowledge needed to make decisions for the people and it fails to be democratic when the people aren't able to see if those representatives are acting in their own interest or in the interests of the people they deign to represent.

Re:TTIP explained: The secretive US-EU treaty that undermine... by task_queue on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:32PM (#9671729)
I'm the oil company that will continue to sell oil until wells pump out dust, destroying the environment in the interim, but its okay because we've diversified and have many contingency plans.

Have you seen our catalog of contaminate filters for your home's closed air filtration system?

If you subscribe now, you can have access to our Above The Clouds solar farm. Yields on surface farms have decreased considerably as the out of control heating of the atmosphere blocks out the sun.