If you claim P=NP, and I show a flaw in your proof, am I also required to provide a proof of my own? Of course not.
This is how science should work; both scientists, their competitors, and anyone else with a passing interest will carefully try to discredit existing work. In this case, it looks like a specific attempt to discredit it failed.
You are correct that creating proper charts off proper data would be the best solution. Unfortunately, much of the data has been "lost", making this impossible.
This is what happens in the evolution debate on a regular basis: someone comes up with some minor technical complaint about peppered moth observation, spends a long time debating it, and then declares that evolution is "in controversy" despite the fact that even if their complaints were valid, there are thousands of other pieces of evidence in favor of the larger theory.
I don't know enough about global warming to know if its critics are merely hacking away at a weak sapling to draw our attention away from the dense forest that they can't cut their way through. But I know that tactic has been applied in the past, so I don't think it's unreasonable to wonder.
Scientists tend to get caught up arguing over whatever particular claim is being criticized, but I think in this situation, it would serve the climate scientists well to point the public eye towards less vulnerable data and claims, if they're out there...
It is like physics: millions of buildings have been built employing Newtons laws. Sometimes an architect gets it wrong and the building falls down. But that doesn't refute the laws of physics - it is just some guy or a team of builders making an error.
However, fraud and errors are different. Science is (to a great extend) based on trust. When I referee a paper, I trust that Fig 1 is really generated by Algorithm 2 if the caption says so. If it turns out that Fig 1 is photoshopped, my report is meaningless. Peer review is meant to find mistakes and evaluate importance, not eliminate fraud.
If a scientist cheats, we must consider all their work to be flawed until they can prove otherwise (i.e., release all data, code, etc). We need to stop and scrutinize all the fruit of their poisoned tree.
AGW may be true, and the science may be solid. But until we have more openness, we will never really know.
No, it's easier to assume trust, but science works best when there is almost zero trust in any single authority. This is why it's expected for you to present your methods, data, math, and then your conclusions. Ignoring malice a tiny mistake can drastically change an experiments outcome. So an experiment yet to be independently verified is next to worthless, but it's not sexy to work like that and it does not help your reputation.
Edit: IMO, what's missing from this discussion is the idea that independently verifying their results is a reasonable thing to do. This does not mean plugging their numbers into their code and looking at the results but starting from scratch using their methods and testing it yourself.
PS: One of the reasons that social science has such a poor reputation is the willingness to accept minuscule sample sizes as representing real research. A little less trust would go a long way to revitalizing those fields. Unfortunately neuroscience seems to be falling for this trap.
In reality, referees do trust that authors are making a good faith effort to present their results accurately (except for a little bit of cherrypicking and glossing over messy parts). As a referee, I'm simply not paid enough to search for fraud.
To search for mistakes, I skim a paper, think "yeah, that graph looks about right", [1] and give an opinion.
To search for fraud, I would need the entire source tree for the paper: data, programs, etc. I'll need to verify that the source code does what the paper says, and that the output of the program is really the source of the graphs. (This ignores the issue of fraudulent data, but that's really tricky to find.)
Since the data was destroyed (oops, I mean lost), this simply can't be done.
[1] I also check the proofs for mistakes, but that's irrelevant for this discussion.
Also I don't think this was the only data set in the entire world that relates to global warming. So it hardly invalidates all climate research if some random researcher formats his hard drive.
As for means, isn't the whole fossile fuel industry supposed to be behind the warming skeptics? They should have shitloads of money. In fact I wonder if by now they have their own research stations in the arctic, drilling for historic ice. I mean, they should? They really can not afford to buy their own thermometers?
I think they would probably have enough money to buy dozens of universities dedicated to climate research.
Climate science appears to have a lower set of standards.
Some of the CRU emails criticize climate journals which were considering adopting a "release all data" policy, and argued for not submitting papers to those journals. Other CRU emails discuss deleting data to prevent Steve McIntyre from getting it, and conspire not to release the data to him or other skeptics. This is why climategate is such a big deal.
As for other data sets, there are a few others. However, the CRU is one of the major sources of paleoclimate data. They aren't the only game in the world, but they are a big game. Both their data, and various analysis which are based on their data, are now inherently suspicious.
To make an analogy, imagine that a major open source regex library (maybe PCRE) is completely tainted (e.g., a rootkit). How large an impact would that have on open source software?
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/environment/article693...
I see some emails that give a strange impression. How about investigating more details before calling it fraud? ESR can not even point to an actual application of the alleged corrections. I think for fraud we would need a little more.
Note I don't say it wasn't - I don't know anything about the people involved, their standing or their research. But I believe in the good old innocent until proven guilty. I think it is one of the cornerstones of civilization.
So far I also haven't seen any "flaws in proofs". I have only seen words like "trick, milk data" that can or can not mean bad things - take your pick depending on what you want to believe.
I simply used an example most people here would be familiar with; my broader point remains unchanged for data analysis. One can legitimately critique an analysis of data without providing new data or even performing a correct analysis.
I've come to believe that AGW probably exists but am not married to the idea either - but nor am I convinced we need massive corrective policy versus adaptation (heck - I live in Canada after all, and after last winter we could use a little warming). That said, and I'm not saying you're doing this but many proponents of AGW are attempting to minimize the implications in the emails but their impact cannot and should not be denied: http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/georgemonbiot/2009/nov...
Also - given the lack of transparency and the emails that have now come to light, the researchers most certainly open themselves up to questions that include whether or not the underlying data has been manipulated/adjusted such that the coding adjustments are no longer necessary http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/11/26/mcintyre-data-from-the...
The whattsupwiththat thing was discusses in another thread, again I don't think it is all it is cracked up to be. It is just anti-warming people jumping at a chance, addressing the dumb public who doesn't understand scientific jargon or processes.
If this leads to a better grasp of the public about this, it might at least be some benefit. I am not claiming that academia is perfect these days.
It might as well be. It wouldn't be an exaggeration to point out that the consequences of basing political and economic decisions on the content of those papers will run into the trillions of dollars.
If there were ever a field in which it's important to avoid even the appearance of impropriety, climatology is it.
Also, this is pure speculation. From ESR's article I gather that it is not even known how and when the data was used. They could not yet point to an actual published article.
And, who are these people, are they like the most famous climate researchers ever, the Einsteins of climate research? Are they the only climate researchers on the planet? I can't imagine that they have that much influence.
OK, but kinda the point of this is that these scientists themselves attempted to discredit other scientists who disagreed with them, rather than refuting them through data. That lays them open to ad hominem attack.
Phil Jones, the director of the East Anglia climate center, suggested to climate scientist Michael Mann of Penn State University that skeptics' research was unwelcome: We "will keep them out somehow -- even if we have to redefine what the peer-review literature is!"
Yep. That's a great summary of the contents of the emails.
In other words, he doesn't know a damn thing. I can't help but feel that the anti-warming crowd (which includes ESR if I remember correctly, he wrote some long rant about peak oil?) is trying to blow a tiny mite up to be an elephant. It's typical revisionist behavior, just like the creationists who find a small bone that is not where biologists have predicted it would be, and they think they have refuted Darwin.
In any case, this all seems to be very ad hominem (revisionists trying to discredit scientists instead of providing data). Even if somewhere out there in the vast internet a false chart is floating around, it does not refute global warming. (Note: I don't claim that global warming is real - I don't know. I just don't like the style of this "mite-gate").
The way to resolve this seems to create some proper charts off proper data.