News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by saosebastiao on Monday June 01, 2015 @12:52PM (#9640124)
There's nothing like giving away something for tens of thousands of dollars that they could have sold for tens of billions.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by melling on Monday June 01, 2015 @01:59PM (#9640745)
Can you skip the snarky comment and explain why this kind of contest is bad? To me it seems like a great idea for everyone. The contestants:

1. Can win money

2. Gain exposure

3. Network with other contestants

4. Potentially get more funding

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by mfringel on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:06PM (#9640802)
The general problem with doing gigs "for exposure" is that it typically only gets you other gigs "for exposure".
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by robotresearcher on Monday June 01, 2015 @04:17PM (#9641820)
These are talented grad students doing a gig "for exposure" on Amazon's dime with Amazon recruiters in the room hungry for talent. Many other recruiters were there (including Uber - first time I've seen them at an academic robot conference).

edit: should add that not only recruiters were there. Amazon engineers including their head of robot R&D were involved and available on the floor. Nice people.

(I'm not affiliated with Amazon and I don't do picking research)

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by IanCal on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @02:36AM (#9644243)
The teams were almost all Universities. This is research, not business.

Pretty much the only one I spotted in the team list that wasn't, was mitsubishi. Unless they're really struggling these days, I don't think that exposure is an issue.

http://amazonpickingchallenge.org/teams.shtml

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by saosebastiao on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:27PM (#9640961)
If you could teleport packages to my front porch, would you be willing to give that to Amazon in exchange for $25k and "exposure"? Amazon becomes the first trillion dollar company in history and you get your name on a press release and some snack money. I would never want any sort of exposure that told people that I'm easily duped about the value of my brain.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by robotresearcher on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:51PM (#9641193)
The problem is very very far from solved. Amazon is supporting students to work on problems Amazon cares about, and these events are very important for Amazon to recruit engineers. Some of these young people will go work for Amazon and some of them will start companies that Amazon will buy. I don't think they are being duped.

Amazon's robotics group is the Kiva Systems startup they bought for a huge amount of money a few years ago.

I was at the conference and dropped in to this event. Lots of energy and committed teams. Many/most teams did pretty badly. I heard (but couldn't confirm) that only one item was correctly picked on the first day. It's not easy.

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by phlyingpenguin on Monday June 01, 2015 @03:25PM (#9641432)
Do they fund the research groups?

Having been a grad student (EDIT: Hey, it turns out my research group has published at ICRA! But not while this has gone on.), I get why these events are interesting/important. However it seems like AMZ could do a little more than <1/8th of an engineer in prize money (not counting the cost of running the conference).

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by robotresearcher on Monday June 01, 2015 @04:07PM (#9641755)
I believe they did not directly fund these group's research. Just the challenge.

Amazon does in-house R&D and is precious about the IP, like most companies. Academic research needs to have flexible IP deals.

Most of the Amazon funding for this event went to supporting student travel and registrations, plus gear shipping. Details are probably confidential but think roughly an order of magnitude more than the cash prize. Shipping is expensive.

Funding challenges is smart. Some groups are doing funded research anyway, on more-or-less related things like grasping, vision, manipulation, planning, whatever. The challenge gets teams to focus on a more complete and realistic task, thus guiding the development of their general tech in Amazon's direction.

Bottom line: Amazon, the historically conservative low-margin retailer, showed up at the premier IEEE robotics research conference, brought some money and hired some grad students. Students worked hard, learned a lot. Amazon and winners got some good press. Awesome.

It's interesting how the best team was way ahead of everyone else. I'd be very interested to see what Amazon can do internally.

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by marincounty on Monday June 01, 2015 @04:50PM (#9642056)
"Amazon, the historically conservative low-margin retailer"

They are slowly raising prices. It's off topic, but I have noticed their prices are slowly rising. I saw this happen to Home Depot, and Costco. I'm not knocking Amazon, I just got too comfortable clicking away, and should have been looking around for the best price.

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by melling on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:45PM (#9641142)
That's a bit of a ridiculous analogy. People are making incremental improvements. Perhaps or technology is good enough to get vc funding.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by IanCal on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @02:41AM (#9644255)
Rarely have the comments on HN made me so sad.

These research groups are building useful tools and giving the results away to the world for free. If you'd invented the teleport system, it'd be so wide-rangingly amazingly useful that I hope it'd be released openly.

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by IanCal on Monday June 01, 2015 @01:31PM (#9640512)
Does amazon now own the IP? If not, then this sounds like a great idea, giving away highly useful ideas for everyone to use.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by jessaustin on Monday June 01, 2015 @01:35PM (#9640560)
I don't think parent was referring to Amazon as having given anything away. Still, if you're not in a position to use this sort of tech, "tens of billions" is probably an exaggeration.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by saosebastiao on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:20PM (#9640897)
If you had a robot that could stow, pick, and pack any item in a warehouse, I have zero doubt you could negotiate $10B, simply for the fact that you could get Amazon, Staples, WalMart, Google, JD.com, Tesco, and AliBaba into a bidding war...and if none of them decided to pay you $10B, you could just offer your own FBA-like service for a fraction of what Amazon charges and make your own $10B.

Amazon is acting like a Pawn Shop owner taking advantage of the guy with the original Picasso by telling him that it was a common forgery. Nobody in their right mind should sign up for these contests, and it pains me to see intelligent people duped into it for "the exposure".

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by jessaustin on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:32PM (#9641010)
If you had a robot that could stow, pick, and pack any item in a warehouse...

TFA was pretty clear that none of the teams at the competition had anything close to this. The winner, which was far ahead of competitors, was able to move ten of a group of twelve specially-selected objects in twenty minutes. It's quite possible that some of the competitors will eventually create what you're talking about, but it doesn't seem that they've given away their grandchildren's inheritance just yet.

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by IanCal on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @02:29AM (#9644227)
> Nobody in their right mind should sign up for these contests, and it pains me to see intelligent people duped into it for "the exposure".

This attitude disappoints me greatly.

The team that won was the robotics research unit at the Technical University of Berlin: https://www.robotics.tu-berlin.de, second place was MIT.

I hardly think they were "duped" into competing.

These people do research. Having a specified task that multiple teams "compete" on is there just to give a good comparison of the different approaches, otherwise everyone is picking their own tasks and it's hard to see what benefits / cons each system has.

What next, complaining that researchers publish open access papers for "the exposure" rather than selling the ideas?

Edit -

Here's a list of the teams: http://amazonpickingchallenge.org/teams.shtml

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by saosebastiao on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @12:34PM (#9647021)
I have no problem with competition nor open research, which is probably how the researchers viewed this competition. My problem was how strikingly small the reward was for custom tailoring months of their efforts and research towards helping a single company eliminate hundreds of thousands of jobs and save billions of dollars. The top prize wasn't even enough budget for a lab assistant for a year! It sounds more like an evil plot from a sinister villain than it does an interesting research opportunity. If you want to do interesting research, don't let multinational companies with obvious agendas tell you what is interesting unless they are also willing to share the reward that they get from your hard work.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by genericuser on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:33PM (#9641019)
This presumes aquiring large quantities of money is a required motivation for developing new technology for one to be qualified as 'in their right mind'. To me this comes off like saying 'No one in their right mind should be a teacher and give knoweledge to others that they could use to get rich'.

Believe it or not some people enjoy the competition, the challenge of solving an interesting problem you had not previously considered, and over all advancing the technology of the world they live in far more than gaining absurd amounts of monetary wealth.

Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by oh_sigh on Monday June 01, 2015 @03:05PM (#9641295)
Amazon bought Kiva for $775M, so it may be close.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by IanCal on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @02:22AM (#9644199)
I know, I assumed they meant the researchers. I meant if the competition didn't require that the researchers give the IP to Amazon, then what has happened is just that Amazon have funded some research / a competition which has resulted in some things being released for all to use.
Re:Amazon crowns winner of first warehouse robot challenge by lumberjack on Monday June 01, 2015 @05:07PM (#9642165)
I generally agree with this sentiment but it's important to note that they don't know beforehand whether their technology is worth anything or not.

In a way, entering such contests is a way of lower risk in exchange for more modest rewards.

If they wanted to setup a startup instead it would have taken them ages to get the same kind of recognition this contest immediately gives them.