News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by JakaJancar on Sunday May 31, 2015 @03:58AM (#9633436)
Am I blind or is the question not really answered?

So the hole is there so that air gets through and the pressure difference is at the outermost pane, OK. What's wrong with it being on the middle pane? What would happen if there was no hole?

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by leoc on Sunday May 31, 2015 @04:36AM (#9633497)
My main guess (I'm not an expert) is that it's to ensure that the double-window system is fully redundant. Without the hole, in the event of an outer-window failure the inner window would already have gone through a variable and probably large number of hours of stress from differing air pressure. With the hole, the middle window is (hopefully) effectively factory-fresh with zero service hours at the moment it takes over. That would be especially good if the failure of the outer window had anything to do with a quality defect in that window (or mishandling of it) instead of being completely adventitious: in that case, maybe it's not the only window pane in the aircraft with a dodgy service-life rating? If the outer windows have to be replaced every n flying hours, then not stressing the middle windows would also make sure that they don't have to be replaced as often. (This seems a bit clearer from reading the io9 version http://io9.com/why-is-there-a-hole-in-airplane-windows-17036... , though I don't think it's stated explicitly there either.)
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by weinzierl on Sunday May 31, 2015 @06:52AM (#9633782)
The purpose of the smudge pane should be obvious. There are two panes and a hole left to explain.

First for the panes:

The article says the two panes are for safety reasons and I buy that. Equally important in my opinion is another reason. It's the same reason you probably have double panes in your home: thermal and noise insulation. Air has terrible thermal and noise conduction. So you need two panes and air between them.

Why the hole:

Remove moisture, I buy that. Allow pressure to equilibrate between the passenger cabin and the air gap between the panes. I buy that too but the article does not really explain why this is necessary.

If the two panes would be sealed absolutely tightly the pressure between them would stay at normal level in any case. As an aircraft climbs, the air pressure drops in both the cabin and the outside air — but it drops much more outside, as the aircraft’s pressurization system keeps the cabin pressure at a comfortable and safe level.

Without the hole and with perfect seal if the pressurization fails for some reason you'd have maximum pressure gradient on both panes. The redundancy of the second pane would be lost.

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by mturmon on Sunday May 31, 2015 @02:53PM (#9635118)
Just to put a number on it, the cabin pressure at high altitudes is given by Wikipedia as around 0.75 atm. (It varies by aircraft model.)

If the inner cavity between the two windows did not have a hole, the full sea level pressure would be pressing outward against the outer window. But with the hole, only about 75% of that pressure is present.

Additionally, if there were no hole, the inner cavity between the windows would be positively pressurized with respect to the cabin. This means the force on the inner window would be backwards from what it would have to bear if the outer window failed.

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by beachstartup on Sunday May 31, 2015 @03:58PM (#9635325)
> But with the hole, only about 75% of that pressure is present.

wait, what? this isn't how pressure works... am i missing something here?

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by mbrameld on Sunday May 31, 2015 @04:36PM (#9635439)
I think it's saying if the two panes were sealed without a hole at ambient pressure when the plane is manufactured then the outer pane at elevation would have ~1atm of pressure pushing out on it and the middle pane would have ~1atm pushing in on it. With the hole the outer pane only has cabin pressure pushing out on it, which is ~75% of 1atm.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by mturmon on Sunday May 31, 2015 @07:51PM (#9636091)
Yes. This whole exchange could have benefited from a simple diagram (numbers approximately correct for 35K feet):

          |       |
  [cabin] | [gap] | [outside]
  0.75atm | X atm | 0.23 atm
          |       |
If "what to make X" is your design choice, you would not want to have it always pegged at 1 atm, as it would be if it was/could be completely sealed at sea level. It's simplest to have it equalize with the cabin pressure.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by weinzierl on Monday June 01, 2015 @04:20PM (#9641839)
The ASCII diagram is very helpful. I wish I had thought of including something like this in my original comment. Thanks a lot.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by curun1r on Sunday May 31, 2015 @07:18PM (#9635988)
When looking at designs of these types, I find it's instructive to think about what catastrophic event the designers are trying to mitigate. In this case, my guess is some sort of decompression where the pressure inside and outside of a window is rapidly equalized and the people onboard don't have time to react in an intelligent fashion.

I think the purpose of the hole is to ensure that stress does not build up on the redundant pane so that it is only used in the case where the main pane fails. When you build redundancy into a system, it's important to ensure that failure of both pieces doesn't happen at the same time. Either can fail on its own, but they can't both fail.

So you want the middle window to be as close to the ideal condition as possible when the outer window fails. By adding the hole, you accomplish this. Moreover, once the outer window fails, the hole ensures that the middle doesn't need to take the full pressure differential and allows the pressure to equalized in a somewhat controlled manner. Yes, the pressure in the cabin will drop, but there are oxygen masks that will drop if it gets too low and the pilots can always descend to a lower altitude. The people onboard will have the time necessary to take both necessary actions.

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by copsarebastards on Sunday May 31, 2015 @08:53AM (#9634000)
This explanation makes a lot of sense--I agree that not having the hole removed redundancy--but I'm not sure some of your details are exactly right.

> If the two panes would be sealed absolutely tightly the pressure between them would stay at normal level in any case.

I think higher pressure inside the plane would push out on the inner pane, pushing it closer to the outer window, so the pressure between would go up compared to the outside.

That is to say, cabin pressure would be highest, pressure between the panes would be in the middle, and pressure outside the plane the lowest. But ALL THREE pressures would be lower than air pressure on the ground.

> Without the hole and with perfect seal if the pressurization fails for some reason you'd have maximum pressure gradient on both panes. The redundancy of the second pane would be lost.

The air in between the panes would provide some "padding" so the outer pane would receive less pressure than the inner pane, but there's not much air between the panes so the padding, and difference in pressure, would likely be small, so yes, redundancy would be lost.

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by moioci on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:24PM (#9634605)
"That is to say, cabin pressure would be highest, pressure between the panes would be in the middle, and pressure outside the plane the lowest. But ALL THREE pressures would be lower than air pressure on the ground." I think this is incorrect. Assuming the windows are sealed at ground level, the pressure between the panes would be slightly below ground level at altitude, due to flexion of both inner and outer panes; the pressure in the cabin is substantially lower than ground level; and outside pressure is the lowest of all. Thus the pressure between the two layers is the highest of the three compartments at altitude, subjecting both layers to considerable stresses with every pressurization/depressurization cycle. Now if you sealed a near-vacuum inbetween, that could help with thermal insulation and prevent condensation, but would cause more stress on the ground.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by copsarebastards on Sunday May 31, 2015 @03:27PM (#9635231)
You're right, good catch. :)
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by jordanb on Sunday May 31, 2015 @11:59AM (#9634523)
It seems likely to me that the sill is designed to resist pressure principally from inside the plane to outside the plane.

If sea level pressure was trapped between the two windows you'd have pressure in the opposite direction on the inside window whenever the cabin altitude increased, which would happen every flight and induce cyclic stress on the sill that it wasn't designed for.

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by cactusface on Sunday May 31, 2015 @03:29PM (#9635241)
> It's the same reason you probably have double panes in your home: thermal and noise insulation. Air has terrible thermal and noise conduction. So you need two panes and air between them.

I think it's the lack of air in double-paned windows that helps. Usually double-paned windows have a vacuum so that air molecules can't move from the outer pane to the inner pane. Surely air is a fine conductor of heat if we consider our weather system. And surely it's also a fine conductor of sound, if we consider our hearing system. In soundproofing applications, open air channels are the top priority, and the simplest way to dampen the sound is by adding mass. Sound doesn't travel at all through a perfect vacuum though (no sound in space), so typical double-paned glass should have an effect there.

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by weinzierl on Thursday June 04, 2015 @02:41PM (#9661218)
I didn't know that there are indeed double-paned windows that have most of the air removed from the space between the panes. That was interesting news to me.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by cactusface on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:16AM (#9664260)
Apparently sometimes Argon gas instead of a (partial) vacuum, but I didn't read up on why...
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by lucaspiller on Sunday May 31, 2015 @04:26AM (#9633484)
> a separate but related function of the hole: to release moisture from the air gap and stop (most) fog or frost from forming on the window.

You could get around that by having the panes airtight and produced in a moisture free environment, but that would be more complicated. Think about failure rates in double paned windows which don't have to undergo the stresses on an aircraft. I'd assume even the outer panes aren't completely airtight to keep things simple:

http://aviation.stackexchange.com/a/953

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by waxjar on Sunday May 31, 2015 @06:13AM (#9633729)
I'm just guessing, but I think the breaking of the middle pane would damage the outer pane anyway, since the pressure is coming from inside. That would leave you with two broken panes.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by Neil44 on Sunday May 31, 2015 @04:14AM (#9633460)
I guess it's good that the hole is inaccessible to passengers? Also there's good progression of failure this way.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by achow on Sunday May 31, 2015 @05:06AM (#9633573)
Agree, the answer to the question was not articulated properly.

Right at the beginning they should have said that the hole is for "releasing the moisture from the air gap and stop (most) fog or frost from forming on the window."

The hole actually dilutes the safety wee bit: "In the extraordinarily unlikely event that the outer pane fails, the middle pane takes over. And yes, in that case, there would be a small leak of air through the breather hole—but nothing the aircraft’s pressurization system couldn’t easily cope with."

TL;DR: Aircraft window hole compromises safety to improve the view :-)

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by LukeShu on Sunday May 31, 2015 @05:29AM (#9633624)
Um... that's not how I read it. It's about controlling the failure modes. The pane with the hole is the "backup"--without the hole, it would be stressed roughly the same as the outer pane during normal operation. This has a major consequence: when one breaks, the backup will probably be in the same sorry state as the primary before it broke, so it will break soon too! Not a very good backup!

Sure, because they are sharing the normal load, it is less likely to break in the first place. But, you'd have essentially doubled the strength, but removed the backup. That's not a good trade-off.

Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by achow on Sunday May 31, 2015 @05:57AM (#9633689)
You could be right. But if that is the case then why doesn't the outside pane fog up?
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by LukeShu on Sunday May 31, 2015 @11:38AM (#9634459)
Because the hole also releases moisture, as your post said. That's just a bonus.
Re:Why do airplane windows have tiny holes? by WalterBright on Sunday May 31, 2015 @01:27PM (#9634822)
A pinhole like that is not going to affect pressurization in the least.