News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by tajen on Sunday May 31, 2015 @03:50AM (#9633415)
I don't agree.

Once you've experienced the creation of a company, you realize that when a company gives 25€ to an employee, 68€ was was given to the tax and 7€ to people who help dealing with the tax complexity (accountants, lawyers, inspections). Total 100€, the price the customer pays. And I think those 68€ are too much. So:

Tax Heavens: In Argentina you're not allowed to transfer your money abroad, unless approved by the government. I call that a dictatorship. We must not do the same. Tax heavens exist for a reason. We must rather fight tax complexity. Complexity is a weight on every CEO, it's a hidden tax on every worker.

No to Tobin tax.

Science: Stop exploring the outer space. Let the money for each company/person to hire more employees. When you're old but not disabled yet, don't you want to hire an Au Pair to take care of your laundry? Our people needs money to pay for their local jobs, not for space rockets.

Politics: Dismembering NATO and UN is not any kind of solution. We need our own successful startups (I mean the size of Google and Apple) - Why wouldn't we have those in EU? Then we can equally deal at a worldwide level, menace of spying on the world's emails and businesses, or better, we can equally negociate with US a worldwide non-spying treaty.

Welfare: The Scandanavian model has become a gimick. My flatmate in Australia was born in Thailand on the countryside and at 22 he was making $1000 a week as a waiter in a hotel. That's what I call: One person, one chance.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by jacquesm on Sunday May 31, 2015 @04:51AM (#9633541)
No company has to pay 68% employer wage taxes in Europe. I'm saying that as an employer who has looked into this at some point to figure out if there was any major advantage to running a company in one country or another, the bigger differentiator is simply that in some countries wages are simply far lower than in others.

Tax havens (not heavens) exist as a form of legal arbitrage and allow those with lots of money to dodge taxes at the expense of those without and as such are a real problem.

Nike and Google combined paid less tax in NL last year than I did, which is quite wrong given their massive turnover and profits.

http://qz.com/240511/heres-how-much-tax-google-paid-on-its-e...

Not exploring outer space is the equivalent of shutting down one of the more productive avenues of basic research, if you took away all of the spin-offs of space research from your house it would dramatically change your quality of life.

Your NATO/UN start-up link makes no sense, the EU governments are very much complicit in the spying scandal.

The Scandinavian model can only be compared to other models if you wish to criticize it meaningfully, your anecdote is meaningless, a better alternative will certainly be given more consideration.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by igravious on Sunday May 31, 2015 @05:09AM (#9633578)
You said it better than I could.

I would add that the EU is not standing still at all. It is making moves on a number of these fronts.

Havens: The Irish/Dutch loophole is being closed. Switzerland and Lichtenstein and others are coming under ever increasing scrutiny[1]. But you probably already know this.

Space: ESA[2], Galileo[3]. Note that Galileo is a ESA project, which would be like NASA building/funding GPS. Civilian rather than military.

[1] http://www.cnbc.com/id/100783858 "Europe's Vanishing Tax Havens"

[2] http://www.esa.int/About_Us/Welcome_to_ESA/ESA_history/Forty...

[3] http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Navigation/The_future_-_Ga...

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by tajen on Sunday May 31, 2015 @06:11AM (#9633723)
VAT 20%, Social contributions 46%, income tax 10-15%, residence tax 5%. Mandatory accountant (2000€/year), corporate yearly registration fees, corporate local tax. Assuming no expense at the company level, the employees can buy 25€ of new products.

Total burden: 75€ out of 100€ sales (since some tax are compounded and others have an excess/floor system). Did I make my point? I know you'll keep arguing, but please reckon first that the 75% burden is a fact.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by true_religion on Sunday May 31, 2015 @08:18AM (#9633919)
VAT if you're paying it is a tax that adds to input costs.

Income tax is a tax calculated over profit.

You can't just sum the percentages together as a simplification.

It's (Sales Price - (Cost of Goods * VAT + Cost of Goods))*Income Tax Rate = Y

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by tajen on Sunday May 31, 2015 @01:10PM (#9634767)
Correct, and when you do that, you get 68%. Make the calculation yourself:

100€ sales,

17€ VAT,

15€ various corporate tax and mandatory accountant in average,

No other corporate spending (no office obviously),

Remains 68€ to pay the employee. 31€ for social contributions.

Net salary 37€.

Employee pays 4-6€ income tax.

Employee is left with 32€.

Of course if you take a partial lifecycle, like "The income tax is only 10-15%", it looks like nothing. You need to take the full lifecycle of the money, from the customer to the company and back to the employee.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by true_religion on Sunday May 31, 2015 @02:45PM (#9635084)
In the USA, sales-tax is deductible from your income so you're not required to submit to double taxation.

In Europe, is VAT not tax-deductible?

My initial reaction was "wait.. no one looks at the full lifecycle of money", but after that first double-take, I'm starting to think that you might be onto something.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by jacquesm on Sunday May 31, 2015 @04:11PM (#9635369)
It's complete poppycock and mixes corporate taxes and private income taxes.

If you want a 'full cycle' accounting then you'd have to know what the money gets spent on, for instance, if you buy fuel you'll pay a lot more tax depending on which country you are in (or very little, that's how the rates differ).

If you really want to do 'fully cycle' taxation you're going to conclude that all money eventually ends up in the tax coffers but clearly that's not how it works because people actually end up with certain goods and services.

An example:

A business turns over 10M, makes a net profit of 20%, so 2M. Depending on the country it will pay roughly 35% corporate income tax, so 1.2M left. That 1.2M can then be paid out as dividends @ (again, depending on the country) 10% to 25% dividend tax, so the individuals owning the stock will receive anywhere from 800K to 1.1M.

So on that level you're paying anywhere from 45 to 55% tax.

If you're earning a wage then the above does not apply (because for a company wages are a cost), so the company will pay your social security, corporate component, quite a bit of which is your pension, social security and various healthcare components (depending on the location). You could see these as 'taxes' but in fact they will benefit you in a very direct way.

Your income tax will be anywhere from 25% to 50% depending on your country of origin and your income level (assuming staggered scales).

After that the situation for both forms of income is roughly the same (we're now on the expense side of things):

If you spend that money to buy a house VAT does not apply.

If you spend that money to buy food then VAT will be typically a low rate (4 to 10%, again, depending on the country).

If you use it to buy consumer goods, you'll be paying 15% to 25% VAT depending on the location.

If you use it to buy energy or fuel you may end up paying no VAT to a terrible amount depending on your location.

VAT is typically not tax deductible in the EU, but to avoid double (or n-fold) VAT taxation companies can in fact reclaim their VAT.

VAT is an end-user tax and the purpose of it would be totally defeated if it were deductible for private individuals.

Note that in many countries VAT was instigated after WWII as a 'rebuilding tax' that had a 15 year sunset clause, but (of course...) the money was too good and the tax remained (and climbed substantially in %age).

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by tajen on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:13AM (#9637005)
Good pount that there are different flows, like buying a house where there is no VAT.

Note that dividends are taxed at the corporate level (IS, 15.5%), then the recipient must pay his income tax on top. The rest of your calculations is correct.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by jacquesm on Monday June 01, 2015 @03:16AM (#9637124)
> Note that dividends are taxed at the corporate level (IS, 15.5%), then the recipient must pay his income tax on top.

Not in every country, for instance in NL you only pay 10% private on top the 15% dividend tax, foreigners don't even pay the 10%.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by ac29 on Sunday May 31, 2015 @04:01PM (#9635333)
Isnt VAT equivalent to sales tax and paid by the customer, not the company? Its disingenuous to say 100€ sales if the company sold 83€ of goods. Would not corporate taxes and so on be paid on the 83, not the 100?

I would be curious to see your actual math.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by tajen on Monday June 01, 2015 @02:09AM (#9636994)
In Europe consumer prices must be displayed including VAT. Example: Apple TV costs 79€, which is 65,83€ plus 20% VAT. If you're a supermarket for business (like office supplies), then you might exceptionnaly be allowed to display the non-VAT price in a bigger font than the total price.
Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by tim333 on Sunday May 31, 2015 @08:40AM (#9633972)
The rates are different in every EU country. Which one are you referring to? The average EU tax take is about 36% of GDP vs 27% in the US but we get health care included in that. The tax plus healthcare cost is probably similar between the US and the EU.

(from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_revenu... - not sure that includes all VAT etc)

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by istvan__ on Sunday May 31, 2015 @01:13PM (#9634771)
How about taxing corporation based on their income rather than on the profit? Just like you and me are taxed.
Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by igravious on Sunday May 31, 2015 @04:42AM (#9633511)
No offence. I don't even no where to start in responding to you.

In reverse order. Welfare: a single anecdote is no rebuttal, how could it ever be? I've lived in Finland, I've _experienced_ the Scandinavian model first hand and I keep up-to-date on global stats. Granted, they are not perfect places but in terms of inequality (hint: this metric _really_ matters), social inclusion, access and quality of healthcare, education, public services and so on the countries of Scandinavia frequently come out on top _globally_. That is uncontested. Yay for your Thai friend. Maybe they would have made €700 (going rate) a week as a waiter in a hotel in Scandinavia?

Politics: I _said_ re-make the UN _security council_. Not dismember the UN! I can't take you seriously if you don't give an honest reading of what I said. But yes, I am advocating disengaging gradually from NATO, it is a source of tension in the world _and_ importantly for Europeans it makes Europe subservient to US foreign policy. The rest of what you say there I cannot understand.

Science: Eh hello? All our eggs in one basket? We need to become multi-planetary ASAP. The tech discovered in attempting to do so will actually help improve life on earth. Not a zero-sum game, sorry!

Tobin tax: You may not have noticed the recent implosion of the world economy a.k.a. The Great Recession. And the subsequent bailing out of the financial industry. Inequality growing to levels not seen since the Gilded Age. Most people know that the one way to make the financial sector subservient to the rest of the economy and not the other way around is to implement some form of Tobin tax. The UK is quaking in its boots in the EU because it recognises that France, Germany and others want this.

Without context your numbers are meaningless. With all respect, you need to realise that anecdotal unreferenced data-points are not a rebuttal to statements of general opinion. For instance you need to assert what you think is wrong with the Scandinavian model, wrong with the idea of a Tobin tax, and so on.

Tax havens: You're happy with people scamming the system. I'm not. This process is already well under way by the way.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by tajen on Sunday May 31, 2015 @06:41AM (#9633773)
+1 for responding point per point ;)

Welfare: At least you've experienced the Scandinavian model, so I'll give credit to your testimonial. I've lived in Australia so I've experienced another one, pretty much at the opposite, and if you say my Thai friend could have made the same money in Oslo, with more healthcare and education, then I'd vote for the Scandavian model.

Science: "We need to become multiplanetary asap"? Social inclusion or sustainability is a higher priority to me. Concerning the technological advance that space exploration brings us, well, wherever we pour dozens of billion euros we'll get a technological advance. So I'd rather we explore world hunger than space. But nowadays it's easier to get votes for supporting ESA than world hunger.

Tobin tax: If it could solve everything you mention, I would be all for it. But it won't solve inequality and it will slow down our economy again.

Re:China’s New Silk Road: Implications for the US by igravious on Sunday May 31, 2015 @11:58AM (#9634520)
Hey, no problem. Kudos for taking the criticism graciously.

Welfare: I can't comment on Australia. Australia is resource-rich and people from this part of the world keep emigrating to there and not coming back. I don't know how well Oz treats its poorest, which is my measure of any society. But I'm no commie :)

Science: This is what I'm saying. I don't think is totally zero-sum. Granted, money spent on the space programme is money not spent on "world hunger" (where does this go by the way, charity?) But there are economic benefits from pursuing space. I've heard that a lot of world hunger could be solved by reducing subsidies to EU and US farmers which is a form of protectionism which goes against the capitalist spirit, and I'd be all for that to the limit of US and EU being food-independent. So you see, I'm not commie either :)

Tobin tax: Clearly there is an economic imbalance to the benefit of the financial sector of the economy. In fact, it seems like many governments get "captured" by finance and so can't effectively regulate and legislate. The Tobin tax is supposed to address this and to the best of my knowledge is said to be a good way of addressing the imbalance by taxing certain types of capital flows. It totally is meant to rebalance the economy thereby making everybody a bit equal which should boost economic growth!