News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by hackinthebochs on Saturday May 30, 2015 @08:49PM (#9632501)
I'm as liberal as they come but I will be voting for Rand Paul if he ends up with the Republican nomination. This is one issue where I will be a one issue voter.

Bernie Sanders seems like a great candidate, but I fear he is too reasonable and conciliatory to do what is necessary to properly reign in the entrenched interests of the military/intelligence industrial complex. At this point it seems like nothing short of a campaign of slash-and-burn against these agencies will get the job done, and it's going to take someone as "nutty" as a Paul to do it.

[deleted]
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by hackinthebochs on Saturday May 30, 2015 @09:08PM (#9632561)
As far as I know he is pro-states rights when it comes to abortion and gay marriage. That is, he supports a weak federal government and the right of states to make these decisions.

But either way, the issue of unconstitutional surveillance, and the entrenched interests in favor of it, is by far the single most important issue facing this country. I will be casting my vote with this fact in mind.

It is absurd to judge someone's commitment to liberal ideals by how they weigh the relative importance of issues.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by hackuser on Saturday May 30, 2015 @11:38PM (#9632958)
> he is pro-states rights when it comes to abortion and gay marriage

I don't know about Rand Paul, and certainly many state's rights supporters are sincere, but be aware that state's rights has long been adopted by those who simply didn't like national law on a particular issue, for example on racial segregation. I'm always suspicious when I hear the term used like a philosphical principle.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by dragonwriter on Saturday May 30, 2015 @11:54PM (#9632997)
> As far as I know he is pro-states rights when it comes to abortion and gay marriage.

Presumably, this refers to a different Senator Rand Paul than the one that sponsored the Life at Conception Act with the explicitly stated motivation to ban abortion federally. [0]

[0] http://www.rawstory.com/2013/03/sen-rand-paul-introduces-fet...

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by hackinthebochs on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:37AM (#9633104)
That is unfortunate. But that is a bitter pill I'm willing to swallow for someone I believe will actually reign in surveillance. Backsliding on social issues can be corrected in the future. But there comes a point where the surveillance state is so ubiquitous and their grip on the country so strong, that there's no dialing it back. The direction we're headed with surveillance presents a clear and present danger to America as we know it.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by zxcvcxz on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:35AM (#9633095)
Personally if I had to choose between banning abortions or a government that completely ignores the 4th amendment I'd have to choose to ban abortions.

Luckily this is just a distraction issue and even if Paul did manage to get his legislation passed it would never stick. I know the leftists would really like everyone to think that he'll appoint supreme court justices that are literally immortal, but those guys die all the time.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by MCRed on Saturday May 30, 2015 @09:31PM (#9632627)
I agree.

Libertarians are the original Gay Rights and Abortion Rights supporters, going back to the 1970s. When Obama and Hillary were still anti gay-marriage (in 2013, before it became something they couldn't ignore) and when Bill Clinton was signing the "Defense of Marriage Act" along with 3/4 of Congressional Democrats approval... and for two decades even prior to that, Libertarians were in favor of getting the government out of marriage.

Notice the Libertarian position is not the same as the mainstream "Gay Marriage" position. Libertarians would legalize Poly marriage as well, while I've had Gay Marriage Advocates give me a list of reasons why that shouldn't be legal.

While some Libertarian candidates are personally against abortion, they would be laughed out of the movement if they advocated actually passing laws at the federal level to restrict it. Hey, I'm even personally not a fan of it (though I paid for one once) but that is completely different from being willing to support their bans, and I wouldn't support someone who wanted to ban them. (And yet I work for the Michael Badnarik campaign for a little while and he was "anti-abortion")

Rand is going to have a tough time getting the republican nomination because that party hasn't quite realized that it's being to conservative and not responsible enough.

So I don't mind that he's not taking a stand on these things.

In fact, if we were in a climate where gay rights were being restricted (increased restrictions) or abortion were being fought (at the federal level) then I might be more worried about it. But we are not. W ran on a strong anti-abortion platform and nothing really happened during his term. He didn't even try. He knew it was a wedge issue, more than anything. Only at the state level are Abortions at risk.

The real crime of our time is the out of control federal spying, adventurism and rights violations.

(this is not a rebuttal to hackinthebochs who said nothing I disagree with.)

EDIT: My statements are historical fact and consistent with what's known about libertarians: They want the state out of these kinds of decisions. Yet I'm downvoted. Is it because I'm pointing out that the Democrats don't really support gay rights? Sorry, but it's true. When clinton signed DoMA with broad democrat support, I was out. Sure the republicans were worse at that time, but I'm not going to compromise the idea that I don't have a right to get married!

Even in the 1990s the Libertarians were the only party that was clearly pro gay rights and so I joined them. The past 20 years have proven me right. I take down votes (without comments or rebuttals) as merely an admission of the frustration at this truth.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by jbrown on Saturday May 30, 2015 @10:20PM (#9632765)
Gay Marriage Advocates tend to be skittish of embracing poly marriage because that would make them look more extreme. If they can show that their position is not the most extreme one out there, then they have a better chance of seeing their agenda actually become reality. The funny thing is that while poly marriage advocates might not like that right now, in the long run it might actually help them because it will probably speed up the necessary changes.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by sjwright on Saturday May 30, 2015 @10:53PM (#9632853)
The broadest possible reading of the essence of marriage is a single relationship entered into exclusively, voluntarily and with full awareness.

An arranged marriage fails the voluntary test.

A union involving a young child fails the awareness test.

A unions that includes a non-human entity fails the voluntary and awareness tests.

A union of three or more entities fails the exclusivity test. (Between two people there is just one relationship. Between three people there are three relationships.) I have no problem with the idea in theory, but it will require a lot of structural change of law to implement and is therefore sufficiently different to warrant a different technical term in law.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by MarkPNeyer on Saturday May 30, 2015 @11:15PM (#9632902)
> Between two people there is just one relationship.

no there isn't.

my wife talks to my dad in a way i never have. they get each other. they understand one another, and she respects aspects of him that i didn't know existed until i saw that a lot of what i love about my wife is true of my dad.

my wife talks to my mom in a way i haven't understood until recently. my mom is very loving; i never knew how much more loving she was until recently, when my wife explained just how intense that is.

i have a relationship with mama, my catonese mother-in-law, who understood the importance of computers even when it was the early 90's and she'd never seen one, who grew up during the cultural revolution, who doesn't trust authority figures for the same reason i don't.

my wife is good friends with many of my siblings - that's 8 more relationships there; 13 when you include the in-laws. my brother matt is married to michelle, who's talked to my wife, christine, about a lot of topics, and the two of them have a relationship far more intense than many biological siblings.

no man is an island.

no man is an island.

no man is an island.

no man is an island.

please for the love of all that is good in the world, can we stop pretending otherwise?

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by sjwright on Saturday May 30, 2015 @11:44PM (#9632975)
Your relationship between yourself and your father isn't marriage.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by serge2k on Sunday May 31, 2015 @06:20AM (#9633742)
woah, you said no man is an island 4 times.

It must be extra extra profound and smart sounding now.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by jbrown on Saturday May 30, 2015 @11:15PM (#9632900)
How is exclusivity crucial to marriage in the maximal broadness sense? It might be crucial in the current legal landscape, but that's not what we're talking about here. I tend to think that in the broadest possible sense marriage is just a contract and there's nothing preventing it from including more than two parties. Or, even if you do create a compelling argument for it being a contract between only two people, why should that preclude me from making another similar contract with a different party?
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by sjwright on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:09AM (#9633032)
We are absolutely talking about the current legal landscape. If you want to discuss polygamy in a spherical cow universe, that's fine, and I've already said I have no in-principle objection to formalizing polygamy.

However, a union between three or more people (or multiple concurrent marriages) is in an engineering sense a very different mechanism. It has more moving parts and more complicated parts. Most critically, its interfaces to the outside world are different.

It would require substantial root-and-branch changes to a massive amount of existing legislation in every country and state. Using a different word in law (while accepting colloquial use of the word marriage in everyday parlance) is a practical necessity.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by dragonwriter on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:17AM (#9633048)
> However, a union between three or more people (or multiple concurrent marriages) is in an engineering sense a very different mechanism.

Forming, adding to, withdrawing from, dissolving, and otherwise handling unions of three or more people, including in dealing with how the members of the union deal with their rights and powers vis-a-vis the property and prerogatives of the union as such between each other and in interfacing with outside entities has been dealt with fairly extensively over the past several centuries in the evolution of partnership law. And most of it can be viewed as a fairly direct multiparty generalization of the two party way similar things are dealt with in existing marriage.

There's no real reason that a generalization of marriage law to handle multiparty relationships that reduced naturally to the same handling for two-party cases as status quo rules would deserve any different name.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by sjwright on Sunday May 31, 2015 @05:24AM (#9633612)
It is still a very different mechanism.

It is still a very different social construct.

Sorry, but polygamy doesn't get to ride the coattails of gay marriage for free. Despite the howls from conservatives, this slope isn't inherently slippery. You have to change minds before you can discuss changing laws. (And besides, I thought we all agreed the anthrozoologists were next in line? Then NAMBLA. Wait your turn.)

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by avn2109 on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:18AM (#9633050)
I have always wondered why the government is involved with marriage at all. Seems like it would be simpler if we set it up like this:

Everyone pays the same taxes no matter what, and you better write an explicit will and testament to control who gets your stuff when you die/can pull the plug on your vegetative state. Ie. no special benefits/drawbacks for married people.

If you want to get married, great---go find a church or a mosque or a ship's captain; it's none of the state's business. The government doesn't recognize the institution of marriage as anything special. Marriage would be an entirely private association, like joining the Elks lodge or something.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by dragonwriter on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:28AM (#9633075)
That's "simpler" in the "fewest number of base rules" sense, and more complex in the UX sense.

Given the frequency of the desire to enter into a partnership with something like the kind of mutual exchange of commitments and agency relationships packaged in civil marriage, it makes sense as a UX optimization for government in terms of providing sensible defaults for common needs (with the ability for users interested in different configurations to reconfigure the defaults to a certain degree.)

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by nationcrafting on Sunday May 31, 2015 @02:34PM (#9635031)
Funnily enough, I too have often wondered about that.

I've also often wondered why your gender is the state's business at all. One way to make the whole gay marriage thing a non-issue would be to say it's nobody's business what you have between your legs, except your doctor and your partner.

There are a couple of scenarios where it would be an issue, like if you go to jail and there are no mixed gender jails, but it's likely that a little bit of imagination would fix that.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by dmix on Saturday May 30, 2015 @09:51PM (#9632685)
Just because people downvote you doesn't mean they disagree with you, or what you said is not factual. Hyper-political comments tend to get downvoted on HN in general because of the type of toxic comment threads they breed. Having libertarianism vs democrats categorization, gay rights, and abortion in one thread fits that category quite well.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by MCRed on Sunday May 31, 2015 @01:21AM (#9633191)
I'm being brigaded. It's not just this one comment, it's comments on other threads, non-political and non-controversial ones as well.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by hackuser on Saturday May 30, 2015 @11:41PM (#9632963)
> This is one issue where I will be a one issue voter.

Consider all the other issues. For example, with Rand Paul as President, the GOP would certainly control the White House, and House of Representatives, very likely have a 6-3 majority on the Supreme Court within a few years (depending on Justice Ginsberg) ... they'd need only the Senate for one-party rule.

Many, many other things would happen that you probably would not like.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by pauleastlund on Sunday May 31, 2015 @01:06AM (#9633162)
When you become an utterly dependable one-party voter you really diminish your say in what your party stands for.

More than that, though, if Rand Paul actually got the nomination -- which he almost certainly won't -- and went on to win the general election, that would potentially be a lot bigger than one minor victory in the constant right-vs-left tug-of-war over American government. It would be a political realignment, because the coalition Rand Paul would build and the platform he would run on are not the traditional Republican coalition and platform.

It could be the start of America actually having a pro-liberty party. That tradeoff might be worth it even for folks on the left who lean libertarian.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by zxcvcxz on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:27AM (#9633069)
It seems the choice is between an Authoritarian left or a small-government right.

I'll take small government over monolithic Authoritarianism any day.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by mikeyouse on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:53AM (#9633142)
Just a reminder, the small government right led by Rand Paul would dramatically expand military spending..

Http://time.com/3759378/rand-paul-defense-spending/

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by zxcvcxz on Sunday May 31, 2015 @09:35AM (#9634115)
But what president won't?
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by mikeyouse on Sunday May 31, 2015 @01:26PM (#9634818)
Many wouldn't but in the context of this discussion, Bernie Sanders is probably a good example.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by adamnemecek on Saturday May 30, 2015 @10:43PM (#9632831)
are you aware that rand paul compared public health care to slavery https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUXwDMqjC-A ?
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by zxcvcxz on Saturday May 30, 2015 @11:25PM (#9632929)
I'd still vote for him.

The only other option is Sanders and he seems to just want to concentrate all power at a federal level, like the USSR did. The left claims to want a more European style governance model but fail to accept that the EU does not have one healthcare system, does not have one schooling system, and does not have one college system.

When you concentrate all power into a small point it makes manipulating that power much easier for the elites. No longer do they have to bribe politicians in each state, just the ones in Washington DC. The founding fathers knew this (they experienced this with the British Monarchy) and that's why they intended on having a very limited federal government that had little control over social programs and whose main purpose was to see that states take it upon themselves to enforce rights provided by the constitution.

Remember when we integrated schools? The left would like you to believe the DOE is some kind of federal schooling system when in fact all it really does is issue pell grants. The federal government did not take over the schooling sector. The only thing the federal government did was step in when a state refused to integrate.

I urge leftists to reconsider their position. I'm in favor of social programs like single payer healthcare, but having the federal government do it is just asinine. The federal government needs to pass a bill that makes healthcare a right, then leave it up to the states to implement free healthcare. Those that don't will be forced to, just like we did when some schools refused to integrate.

If you hate too big to fail companies, then why allow one entity to monopolize a whole sector of the economy? As soon as one of these huge social programs fails, down goes the whole economy. It happened in the USSR and it could happen here. Just let the states handle it like they do in the EU. That way, when one states social programs fail it doesn't bring down the whole economy. Notice that this is a compromise. The left still gets it's healthcare while the right still gets a small federal government. It's a win-win. Unfortunately both the left and right would like you to believe that any compromise is giving into the other side, they must perpetuate the idea that you only have one right choice and that if you're not with them you're completely against them.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by adamnemecek on Saturday May 30, 2015 @11:58PM (#9632998)
I've read your comment. I might have responded if it weren't for the stuff such as "like the USSR did". Sentences like that make it obvious that any discourse would be futile.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by zxcvcxz on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:20AM (#9633054)
It wouldn't be fair to compare the US to socialized countries like individual European nations because most European nations aren't world powers policing the globe and have much more economic and political stability. Most socialized European nations aren't experiencing social unrest or widespread disagreement about social policies.

The US on the other hand has much more disagreement. The USSR consisted of many countries dominated by the Soviets who didn't agree with many policies of the government. While the US isn't taking over other countries and making more US states, the states are already similar to small countries.

As we concentrate power more and more at a federal level we take away sovereignty from the individual states. This, in my opinion is very similar to what lead to the collapse of the Soviet Union. They spread themselves thin and forced everyone to assimilate under one political ideology. This only works when a large portion of the country agrees with said policies.

While the US will probably never suffer the same fate as the USSR, I could easily see us spreading our selves to thin across the globe, mismanaging money, and pissing everyone off, thus leading to economic decline and loss of faith in the political system as a whole (this is already happening).

America won't be able to handle socialism. We want too many things.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by adamnemecek on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:28AM (#9633074)
K.
Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by zxcvcxz on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:44AM (#9633124)
It seems to me you don't really have a counter argument to make at all. You're just looking to delegitimize my opinion by not even considering it.

K.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by hackinthebochs on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:29AM (#9633079)
Yeah I've seen that before, and it's obviously false and slightly nutty (as long as there are people voluntarily willing to provide care--and there will be--there is no force involved). But going up against the entrenched interests to reign in defense and spying is going to take someone slightly nutty. So at least on this particular issue its a virtue.

I'm aware that his politics comes with some, possibly many unsavory views, but I fully believe unchecked surveillance presents an existential crisis to America as we know it. Backsliding on marriage or abortion can be corrected in the future. There comes a point where there's no turning back the clock on ubiquitous surveillance.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by adamnemecek on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:35AM (#9633099)
> Yeah I've seen that before, and it's obviously false and slightly nutty

It's not "false and nutty", it's either malicious or outright idiotic.

Just fyi, Bernie Sanders' stance on NSA spying is very similar to Rand Paul's.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by hackinthebochs on Sunday May 31, 2015 @12:48AM (#9633134)
If it came down to Sanders and Paul, it would be a tough decision to make and I'd probably lean Sanders out of concern for all the other issues. But at this point Paul is more likely to get the nomination for his party than Sanders so it seems like a moot discussion.

But the fact that I haven't heard Sanders make surveillance the forefront of his campaign is a bit concerning. Also the fact that he didn't make an appearance at Paul's "filibuster" says quite a bit. Say what you want about how useless the filibuster was, lack of awareness of the facts around the surveillance issue is the biggest factor in the government's favor. Making a very loud and public stand against surveillance has tangible benefits. I was disappointed that he didn't take advantage of that opportunity.

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by dragonwriter on Sunday May 31, 2015 @01:09AM (#9633174)
> If it came down to Sanders and Paul, it would be a tough decision to make and I'd probably lean Sanders out of concern for all the other issues. But at this point Paul is more likely to get the nomination for his party than Sanders so it seems like a moot discussion.

Not that you can tell much about who is likely to win the nomination this far out from the first primary (basically, what you can tell now is name recognition prior to significant campaigning, which would mislead as to the winner of the nomination in most elections where there isn't an incumbent President or Vice President in the primary.)

Re:Rand Paul: 'I will force the expiration' of portions of P... by enupten on Saturday May 30, 2015 @08:53PM (#9632510)
Bernie Sanders does appear much more consistent than Hillary; and he unlike Hillary has talked of dismantling the NSA. I'm afraid he won't make the Democratic nomination.

The other republicans seem like a bunch of idiots. It's likely that Hillary will come to power. She does seem to have the money for it.