I think what we're really running into are the egos of oenophiles.
This is a problem when you go to a wine event and try a whole bunch of different wines and decide to buy a couple of cases of the 9th or 10th wine you tasted. I will no longer buy wine after more than 5 tastings because I don't trust my judgement anymore. I really have no idea how any judge can taste 80 wines in a day and pick anything good.
Talking about palate destroying I once bought a wine (mid priced) that had such a terrible taste that I instantly rang to the sink to spit it out. The truly diabolic thing about this wine is it made any wine tasted for hours after this taste terrible as well (I opened 4 different wines I knew well over 3 hours as I could not believe such an effect was possible). No food or any drink could get rid of the effect. I always thought this would be the perfect wine to enter into a tasting competition.
[0] http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/jun/23/wine-tas...
I was told by a man who professionally tested wines around the world that I should generally not spend more than $20 a bottle, and I'm often happy with $15.
But, as they say in Latin, de gustibus non est disputandum. My mother and my wife detest the Margaux that my father and I enjoy so much - my mother charitably calling it "a man's wine" and my wife calling it... something much less charitable. But I think both of them would agree that it is certainly very different - in taste, colour, and bouquet, even if they can't actually enjoy those aspects of it - to what you could buy in a supermarket.
There are other reasons not to eat junk food. Drinking wine that you like that also happens to be chap isn't necessarily bad for your health. Seriously, how did this comment end up on top?
My point wasn't related to health, but to the aesthetic qualities of the food itself. I don't think Panda Express is very unhealthy, and no more/less healthy than good Chinese food.
I did not understand the point to be that wine critics are frauds – it's that they're playing a game that someone lacking the "deeper understanding and appreciation" simply doesn't have to participate in by buying expensive wine.
As you rightly say this applies equally to all areas of taste, but wine is a good one to call out because people seem to feel a bit bad about knowing nothing and overspend to be on the safe side.
> means that a person has developed an arbitrary
> preference drive by the wine industry ... I don't buy
> this at all
You should talk to a wine expert then, who'll happily tell you that different grapes come in to and out of fashion, and hence are priced differently. Riesling as a great example of a great grape that's "underpriced" because it's not so fashionable.May I suggest that concluding that there is significant difference between wine based on the price, despite scientific evidence to contrary, because another class of items does show a value/price relationship is a nice example of:
* Appeal to probability
* Argument from (personal) incredulity
* False equivalence
And I'm sure a few others.
I don't buy this at all. Almost everyone can relate to some field where they have more sophisticated tastes than the average person, whether it's music, art, food or wine (EDIT: how could I forget coffee). By the author's logic, we should all eat McDonalds or Panda Express.
I'm not claiming that expensive wine is objectively better, but rather that people with experience and knowledge have a different taste to the average person, and this difference isn't just arbitrary, but reflects a deeper understanding and appreciation.