News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by rfrey on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:04AM (#9624956)
I'm struggling with this now and I could use some insight.

I absolutely share OP's loathing of these pop-ups. On the other hand, I'm just starting to try to drive traffic to my physical-product website (through PPC ads, facebook marketing, etc).

I KNOW I need to try to collect some contact information. But I cannot find a way to do it that isn't appalling.

- Collect on landing page? How do they know if they want to sign up, they just got here.

- Put on Contact Us page? Nobody will see it.

- Pop up a window after 30 seconds, or three pages viewed, or whatever? I end up on thosefuckingpopus.tumbler.com, and for good reason.

- Don't do anything? Patrick McKenzie finds my house and draws rude things on my face while I sleep.

Has anybody come up with an acceptable design solution for collecting emails from people who are interested in being on your list?

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by patio11 on Friday May 29, 2015 @06:59PM (#9628039)
I sort of like the Drip widgets (http://getdrip.com) and there exist numerous Javascript things which can do roughly the same.

I don't have much experience with physical products and am not sure this generalizes, but in SaaS, one of the best ways to get opt-ins with advertising is to:

a) Send the ad not to a landing page but rather to content pitched in the ad

b) Have a further incentive which takes the piece it's attached to and deepens it. Gate this one with an email submit.

c) You generally want to get to a state where you have N content pieces, M creatives for the premium (downloadable whitepaper or whatever), and P premiums, where N >> M >> P. Then you can start testing to find which ads/content/house ad creatives/premiums get you the best results. It works perfectly adequately with N = M = P = 1 though.

This works particularly well with retargeting. You get someone to visit your site once or a few times organically (your content was on HN or Twitter or what have you), you cookie them up, and some day when they're browsing Facebook your company (which they already trust to give them useful info) says "Hey, more stuff for you to read of interest to you." They come over, read for a bit, and hand over the email address semi-casually. Your marketing and sales processes now take over.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by SimeVidas on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:06AM (#9624975)
Have a “Sign up to our newsletter” section below the main content on every page.

The two main mistakes that you must avoid at all cost are:

1. displaying an overlay on page load, forcing the user to make the decision before consuming any content,

2. showing the overlay while the user is reading the main content; nobody likes to be interrupted.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by Alupis on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:26AM (#9625132)
You find them annoying, but your customers probably wont.

Remember you are not the best case when deciding what is effective at capturing your audience. You are more "internet savvy" or whatever...

Popups, email marketing, retargeted ads, et al are very, very effective means of capturing an audience online.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:29AM (#9625153)
Don't fool yourself. Everybody finds them annoying. Like the frog in the frying pan who sits as the heat is turned up, folks have begun to believe its the price of visiting the internet.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by Alupis on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:38AM (#9625221)
> Don't fool yourself. Everybody finds them annoying

I don't believe that's true. What we see here is an exhibit of the False-Consensus Effect[1]. You believe they are annoying, and many on HN believe they are annoying, therefore they (popups) must be annoying to everyone. This logic ignores the fact that 99% of web users are not technical, and view the web in an entirely different light.

On ecommerce websites, popup forms are incredibly effective at capturing customer email addresses later used in direct email marketing. So effective, there is an entire industry built around providing the technology and controls to target certain customers with the popups (viewed 6 pages but did not add anything to cart yet, sat on a product page for 2 minutes, etc...).

For a lot of popups, an incentive is offered to the potential customer. Give us your email address and we'll give you 5% off your next purchase. We're basically buying the right to email market to you... understanding full well that some customers will be annoyed with the popup, and some might even provide fake details. But for the majority of customers, we just bought their loyalty. They will make a purchase with their new 5% off coupon, and will likely shop the site again when we email them promo offers later on.

If you visited one of my sites, and got annoyed by the popup, then I'd be OK with that... you were not my target. But if your parents or grandparents visited my site... chances are they'd fill out the popup. They are my target.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False-consensus_effect

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:52AM (#9625320)
I think somebody is fooling themselves, and I think it isn't me. Its self-serving to stick a dialog box in somebody's face, then spend 100's of words defending that choice by denying the obvious.

All the arguments above are about the site, not about the visitor. "capturing customer email", "Buying the right to email market" are not about the visitor gaining value by reading a blog entry. And those who object to the process are "not my target". Very convenient. Perhaps I was a whale with a blank check, reading the blog entry to find out more. One popup and now I'm gone. You'll never know, since you've already convinced yourself this is all ok.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by Alupis on Friday May 29, 2015 @12:06PM (#9625418)
> Perhaps I was a whale with a blank check, reading the blog entry to find out more. One popup and now I'm gone.

You don't run websites (especially ecommerce websites) hoping and praying for a "whale" to come along and bless you with their deep pockets... just like you don't play baseball hedging on hitting only home runs. That's a recipe for failure.

> Its self-serving to stick a dialog box in somebody's face

Yes, that's the point. I want their email addresses.

> then spend 100's of words defending that choice by denying the obvious.

Frankly, you cannot argue with the effectiveness of popup email collection. Every time we blast our 150,000+ email marketing list (mostly gathered via the popup as well as other means), the websites are almost crushed under the traffic load. 1 email can generate $10's of thousands in revenue... so yes, collecting emails is of very high importance for us, and many similar ecommerce companies.

> are not about the visitor gaining value by reading a blog entry

You are certainly right -- it's more about the company gaining value, however, a great many of our customers gain value by seeing deals on products they are interested in. That is a win-win for everyone.

> And those who object to the process are "not my target".

If you aren't buying something from my site, or clicking an ad, then you are not my target. Instead you are just consuming my company's resources and ultimately won't convert into a sale. To be frank, we don't want those types of visitors on the website, although it's unavoidable (ecommerce generally considers an average 3-5% conversion rate to be good).

The point is, you are annoyed by popups, and choose to punish sites that employ them. Just like some choose to punish sites that provide free content but pay the bills with ads. It's a strong bias to impose on the rest of the internet users... especially when you are in the minority percentile.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by Veedrac on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:51AM (#9625315)
Have you done user-testing?

I haven't but I've seen non-nerds get irritated by popups. Heck, given that their primary complaint about computers is that they're confusing, the last thing they want is for popups to confuse them further.

[EDIT] Here's a study that agrees with me:

http://www.nngroup.com/articles/most-hated-advertising-techn...

I can't find the actual source, though, if a source even exists.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by notdanariely on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:33AM (#9625193)
Well, it kinda is the price of visiting the internet. Because most content is free but ad-supported... doesn't that mean viewing ads is the price you pay? (At least in a large sense -- I'm intentionally ignoring adblock technology because as of right now it's just not that significant)
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:53AM (#9625334)
"Most of the Internet" is Netflix (by bandwidth). They charge for their services, and have zero popups or ads.

The rest of the Internet is pay-to-play like Steam. At least for me.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by Alupis on Friday May 29, 2015 @12:16PM (#9625479)
> At least for me.

You are not the average internet user.

Your biases do not apply to 99% of internet users. The things on websites that annoy you do not annoy 99% of internet users. The marketing antics that work for 99% of internet users do not work on you.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 29, 2015 @03:16PM (#9626665)
Wrong. Netflix is the larger part of the internet. That has nothing to do with me.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by notdanariely on Friday May 29, 2015 @06:13PM (#9627816)
In case you aren't just being argumentative, using bandwidth as the metric of choice when discussing lightbox-style page elements is sub-optimal. Or when discussing business models of websites that use those page elements.

A better metric is some sort of pageviews / site visitors / uniques / etc.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by JoeAltmaier on Saturday May 30, 2015 @09:45AM (#9630148)
Come on. Netflix is the single largest consumer of the Internet. Any metric you want to name. Consumer interactions being the most important. They beat other video-on-demand services by a large margin. And most of those others have popups (or forced ads injected into the content). And Netflix beats them all. You understand the argument.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by notdanariely on Saturday May 30, 2015 @09:25PM (#9632613)
You have honestly lost me. Not only am I unsure of any argument you set forth except "Netflix is the biggest consumer of the internet", but I can name many metrics by which they aren't top 10. Namely, pageviews, unique visitors, alexa rank, or just about any other metric that doesn't measure bandwidth.

Are you only discussing VOD sites? That's the only way I can make any sense of your arguments. (Also, what do you mean by netflix being a "consumer of the internet"?)

[http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/netflix.com]

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by Alupis on Friday May 29, 2015 @05:13PM (#9627491)
You provide one example of a single website out of millions that does not use a popup, and claim QED?

Like stated before... you are letting your personal bias creep into a pseudo-fact.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by JoeAltmaier on Saturday May 30, 2015 @09:42AM (#9630141)
'A single website' that is the largest single fraction of the entire internet traffic, yes. And what's with the 'pseudo' slam?
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by Alupis on Sunday May 31, 2015 @06:21PM (#9635827)
I honestly don't know what you are trying to debate anymore. Netflix might account for the largest bandwidth consumption, sure, but it's not even in the top 50 websites by users/pageviews. Your analogy falls down hard; we're talking about a common tactic to collect email addresses... to my knowledge Netflix does not have a newsletter they send out. Does that mean nobody should collect email addresses and run a newsletter campaign? Absolutely not.

> And what's with the 'pseudo' slam?

You are making up facts to support your skewed and biased view. You don't like popups that ask for email addresses, therefore you assert they are ineffective and annoying to all users. This is absurd, and provably false.

You assert Netflix has the most consumption of bandwidth for a single service on the internet, and they don't employ a popup to collect email addresses... and therefore conclude that nobody should use a popup to collect email addresses. This is equally absurd.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by emodendroket on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:39AM (#9625238)
If "everyone" finds them annoying why are they clicking the links or giving their e-mail addresses?
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:54AM (#9625337)
9800 out of 10,000? That sure sounds like pretty much "everyone"
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by emodendroket on Friday May 29, 2015 @12:03PM (#9625399)
I don't usually engage such popups but I also don't find it very hard to dismiss them if I want to read the article. Reading an article takes at least a few minutes, depending how long it is. Dismissing a modal takes seconds.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by mc32 on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:13AM (#9625031)
I think that depends on your audience, target market. Some audiences loathe the intrusion, other audiences feel it's par for the course, so maybe try to determine who your core audience is and what methods they find acceptable?
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by userbinator on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:38AM (#9625224)
Collect on landing page? How do they know if they want to sign up, they just got here.

Put the form at the bottom of the content. Presumably those who have read through and like it will then sign up.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by Leftium on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:34AM (#9625197)
How about pop-ups that only come up when the user is about to close the browser tab? The user is free to continue to close the tab if the pop-up doesn't interest them.

Some demos:

- http://www.popupdomination.com/

- http://optinmonster.com/features/exit-intent/

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by emodendroket on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:38AM (#9625233)
That's obnoxious and will not help with someone who's going ot use the back button or go to a different page.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by alextgordon on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:19AM (#9625084)
The answer to this question is the same as the answer to all business questions on HN: copy how patio11 does it. http://www.kalzumeus.com/blog/
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by mplscoder on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:14AM (#9625043)
If they scroll all the way to the bottom then have a bottom bar that appears.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by emodendroket on Friday May 29, 2015 @11:40AM (#9625240)
Excellent; now 98% of users will never see it.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by mplscoder on Friday May 29, 2015 @03:21PM (#9626712)
If they didn't read to the bottom, they probably aren't interested in the product enough to sign up for an email.
Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by emodendroket on Friday May 29, 2015 @08:02PM (#9628266)
That's just not that true. People rather frequently do things like share articles they only bothered to read half of on Facebook; there's no reason to think they wouldn't want a newsletter or a product. c.f. http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2013/06/...

> Schwartz’s data shows that readers can’t stay focused. The more I type, the more of you tune out. And it’s not just me. It’s not just Slate. It’s everywhere online. When people land on a story, they very rarely make it all the way down the page. A lot of people don’t even make it halfway. Even more dispiriting is the relationship between scrolling and sharing. Schwartz’s data suggest that lots of people are tweeting out links to articles they haven’t fully read. If you see someone recommending a story online, you shouldn’t assume that he has read the thing he’s sharing.

Re:F*** those popups – signing up those who deserve it by mplscoder on Sunday May 31, 2015 @10:31PM (#9636517)
Well good counterpoint, but there's got to be something better than forcing me to close a popup.