Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t...
by nickjohnson on Thursday November 26, 2009 @05:14AM
(#962508)
"while I can sympathize with scientists' decisions not to release their data or their methodologies " - I can't. If your results can't be reproduced independently, it's not science, it's an assertion from authority.
This is a really, really basic part of scientific research. Failing to do it should raise huge red flags.
That doesn't mean it isn't sloppy though, and while I can sympathize with scientists' decisions not to release their data or their methodologies -- they aren't well-enough funded to spend their time answering the various challenges of laypeople that aren't educated enough to understand the field -- it's still a really poor choice in the longer term that's going to result in a lot of suspicion regarding their work.
Or, alternatively: we're seeing some confirmation bias at work.