News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by JCThoughtscream on Thursday November 26, 2009 @01:40AM (#962370)
I can think of a half-dozen reasons off the top of my head as to why the records might have had to been adjusted, starting with "equipment calibration" and moving widely on from there. I think the media's been a little too eager to jump on the climate change denial bandwagon...
Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by thaumaturgy on Thursday November 26, 2009 @02:11AM (#962397)
Yes; I think the simplest and most likely explanation here is going to involve specific facets of the data or analysis which people won't be familiar with unless they've been studying it for several years.

That doesn't mean it isn't sloppy though, and while I can sympathize with scientists' decisions not to release their data or their methodologies -- they aren't well-enough funded to spend their time answering the various challenges of laypeople that aren't educated enough to understand the field -- it's still a really poor choice in the longer term that's going to result in a lot of suspicion regarding their work.

Or, alternatively: we're seeing some confirmation bias at work.

Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by nickjohnson on Thursday November 26, 2009 @05:14AM (#962508)
"while I can sympathize with scientists' decisions not to release their data or their methodologies " - I can't. If your results can't be reproduced independently, it's not science, it's an assertion from authority.

This is a really, really basic part of scientific research. Failing to do it should raise huge red flags.

Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by pyre on Thursday November 26, 2009 @02:01AM (#962387)
Let's just face the fact that 'climate change' has become a political topic more than it's a rational and/or scientific one.

"Climate change denial" has become secret code for, "I'm a neo-conservative and I really want it stick it to Those Damn Liberals(tm) because not only do they want to take away my Hummer and my hamburgers, they want to take away my guns too!"

There are plenty of journalists and talk-show pundits on the conservative side of the spectrum that see this as some sort of vindication that they were, "right all along," or just as a chance to get all sorts of coverage/attention/viewership/advertising money.

Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by anamax on Thursday November 26, 2009 @02:08AM (#962394)
Similarly, AGW has become secret code for, well, you can fill in the blanks.

However, there are some differences. For example, the skeptics haven't been suggesting that their opponents be thrown into jail for their beliefs. And, they aren't proposing restrictions or taxes.

Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by JCThoughtscream on Thursday November 26, 2009 @03:40AM (#962440)
No, we simply have "skeptics" that've decried climatologists as anti-industrial communists that ought to be tarred and feathered if not outright lynched for their views.

Comparing crazies doesn't make for great discourse.

Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by natmaster on Thursday November 26, 2009 @03:10AM (#962429)
I'm not familiar with the hamburger political controversy. Do enlighten me.
Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by pyre on Monday November 30, 2009 @04:53PM (#968782)
See the conservative assumption that "liberal == vegan" or "liberal == animal activist."
Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by anamax on Thursday November 26, 2009 @02:05AM (#962391)
There are valid reasons and there are invalid reasons. That's why being open about the raw data is important.

[Edit] I should have also mentioned that it's also important to be open about how the data is adjusted. Explaining your reason for adjusting the data is not enough.

Which reminds me. Someone commented that scientists don't share code. That's not quite true. In many areas, it suffices to share data because the analysis routines are already shared.

Re:Raw climate data in New Zealand tells a different story t... by JCThoughtscream on Thursday November 26, 2009 @02:07AM (#962393)
I fully agree! But both sides are guilty of subjective analysis. As to which side is most guilty... well, choosing either/or gives away your position on the issue.