If anything, I think it's preferable that the community engage in pattern matching and question where their heroes come from. It doesn't mean Patrick is a fraud, but it might mean that he's not the god everyone makes him out to be.
I will admit that when I first arrived here on HN, I too believed that his 'status' was a reflection of BCC's success. The way I saw it evolve was that the consulting discussions were only made possible by the fact that BCC was touted as a model product for bootstrapping success.
That could very well be my mistake, but judging by this discussion, it seems I was not the only one to make it.
I think this is why so many people are surprised by the low revenue numbers.
As for the sale itself...3x on a dying business is a pretty good deal if I must say so myself. Questioning the time he put into making the sale is silly. You can't put a price on peace of mind.
But a lot of people rightly view him very highly personally, and view his advice as very good advice.
Some people in this thread are calling it into question, and a few of us are trying to get across the fact that we've known him online for many years, lots of people around here have known him in person for many years, and the accusations that his claims are exaggerated is wrong.
Also, his advice is very good - I speak as a former consultant.
A lot of commenters seem to have missed the fact that BCC hasn't been Patrick's primary business for over 5 years.
He did a whole different product, after getting his consultancy off the ground, that is not Bingo Card Creator.
I'm not going to name names, but I'm pretty sure most of the community knows the few I am referring to. It just so happens that they've also been speaking at conferences, including Microconf and others like it.
The point is this:
1. Person A builds up a persona on HN as a guru, product person, consulting expert, etc. 2. This person then sells an e-book, leaning upon that reputation. 3. This person's uses the launch as an example of being successful. 4. The cycle repeats.
This is an obvious manifestation of the age old Mass Control, Product Launch Formula, etc, and I have no problem with that. My point above is that it's OK for people to vet the parties behind these products, and I think it's lazy to immediately dismiss criticism as jealousy.
You may be right, it may be jealousy to critique such a thing when many of those critiquing likely have never: 1. taken an idea and turned it into a viable commercial product; 2. maintained a company in the black for multiple years; or 3. sold an entire company they created from scratch. Then again when one has never done any of the three of those things and they are just seeing dollars (as you say it is magic to them anyway), it is probably very difficult to understand the inherent value in the actual experience of doing any one of those things. In the single comment I saw Patio11 write in this thread, it was very clear he gained knowledge/experience taking part in this exit and moving forward I doubt he is ever going to look back and think to himself, "gee I really made a mistake by selling BCC b/c of the opportunity cost", if anything on his future exit he will probably be thinking "this is such a larger deal by orders of magnitude, yet it is going much smoother, I am glad I have been here before."
Meatball wiki calls this "vested contributor". It is a problem. I sometimes post unacceptable but not flag worthy comments. (I welcome downvotes if you see me doing this - it makes me edit the post or withhold replies. Or email me if you don't yet have downvote privs).
> It would be an interesting exercise to remove names from comments for a while and see how they do. I suspect the exercise would surprise some people.
This is an excellent idea. I would happily use a plugin that provides this functionality. It's make my HN life better and easier. I suspect I would upvote more often.
Now that I think about it, an HN alternative without karma where everyone is anonymous would be an interesting experiment.
Please don't make threads worse by feeding comments you think are trolling. Instead, flag them and move on.
To flag a comment, click on its timestamp to go to its page, then click 'flag'.
What an utter abomination.
Another explanation is that your comments are viewed as either mean, disingenuous, unsupported, or wrong and people are downvoting accordingly.
Scratch all that jealousy. Grow up and be happy for his sake instead! HN is richer because of people like him. Here's my real comment on this news:
Congratulations Patrick! I'm looking forward to hearing more about Starfighter. You said a few weeks ago a couple of months ago, so you better push something soon ;)