It is kind of the same as the books point on blackmail: you want to put draconian penalties on the victim of blackmail (if he does what you want) so that he can point to them and say that whatever you are going to blackmail him with ain't as bad as that, thus you wouldn't try to blackmail him in the first case.
Software engineers can't even bargain for overtime pay. Pathetic.
We do in Europe.
I don't think "can't" is the right word. "Choose not to" is more appropriate. Are you willing to make a personal sacrifice for the greater good? There's always a choice.
That's such a crap excuse.
What, taking family before everything else? The relative effect a person can have to the society where they live in is usually non-existent (barring exceptional circumstances). Otoh the impact any parent can have on their families wellbeing by providing food and being an accessible parent, is usually significant.
So, does one choose the action that is unlikely to cause significant positive effect but is an opportunity cost, or the action that has obvious short term observable effects?
Man, it would be way cooler and more relaxing to be a moral crusader rather than a father but I choose the latter. It also drains me to a point where I really don't have any excess capacity to save the world.
That type of discussion about banking practices & fees is totally above his pay grade. Likewise, I'd be called out as a social justice warrior to berate that software engineer on something he doesn't control.
I guess we just have to disagree. I'm not sure what action or solution you're proposing? Should the software engineer quit his job?
Let me turn it around. If I were interviewing someone for a job writing software, and somehow I found out he worked on that re-ordering software at the bank, while it wouldn't be an instant no-hire, I would very much like to hear an explanation about what good that person thought he was doing.
the old cannibalize the young, because they can no longer work. if you look at any asset class, this is how the western advanced civilisations work.
Someone else stepped up and built it for them, I couldn't care less about that at least it wasn't my work that went to screw over a bunch of unsuspecting consumers.
At the same time I've had the porn industry as my customer for over two decades. I guess we all draw our lines in different places such that for every problem there is always going to be someone who will take up the slack.
Feel free to berate me for having sold to the porn industry, I have absolutely no excuse.
A guideline that would make stuff like this more clear would be appreciated, right now the only one I have is the law: if it's legal: I'll build it, if I feel that it is illegal or gray then I will refuse.
Without getting into the rest of the argument, a reply to that last paragraph:
The absence of an alternative course of action doesn't make it right, it just explains it. Saying "I can't think of another way to deal with it" isn't an excuse, it's an explanation. He still did The Thing. You can't think of an alternative? Okay, that doesn't change that he did it.
It's an important detail because you're putting the onus of dealing with his situation on the rest of the world, while he is the one who got himself in there.
"What do you suggest he'd do?" Well, not getting into that situation in the first place would be a good start. Or at least assume responsibility for your actions, when you do.
Morals are not determined by pay grades. And anyone who uses "social justice warrior" as a pejorative is someone not worth listening to. If you act in fear of being called a name that says you care about social justice, you need to reconsider your world, for it is a rotten one and bad for you.
Be mindful of you, and expect others to be mindful of themselves, and hold yourself, and them, accountable for the choices they make. That's the only route--the only route--to a society worth living in. And yes, that does mean giving somebody a ration of shit for jobsworthing us into a worse world.
> Should the software engineer quit his job?
I have. I'd do it again. We are so very, very privileged in that money can be had more cheaply than self-respect. But so many of us, I think because we as a profession house so many people who are stunted in their ability to measure the world, act as if it were the reverse.
Please don't put words in my mouth to make you look ethical and make me look amoral. I said "banking fees" not "morals" are above his pay grade. Which bank allows software programmers to set banking fees? None.
>"social justice warrior" as a pejorative is someone not worth listening to. If you act in fear of being called a name that says you care about social justice,
No. The SJW pejorative[1] would actually say I don't care and I would deserve such an epithet. Lecturing someone about morals if I'm in no position to help them quit their job, is empty platitudes and theatrics. It's the theatrics (not the moral principles) that's called out as SJW and rightfully so. When a parent tells a child not to steal the candy from the store, that's not SJW. The parent has the power to buy the candy or find a substitute later at home.
Yes, we, to some extent as (anonymous) HN posters can all espouse the idea of holding people to a higher moral standard. Sure, in this thread, "someone losing their job" is just some abstract concept so I can definitely join the chorus and tell them to quit the job consequences be damned. Nobody here would know the difference.
However, I was talking about a real life situation where the COBOL programmer was directly in front of me. In that scenario, I will not lecture him. I hope others are not so crass to do it either (especially if the moral crusader is wearing tennis shoes made by exploited children but that's another discussion.) The programmer already feels bad about it. Lecturing him just depicts me as smug & superior and him as inferior.
>Be mindful of you, and expect others to be mindful of themselves, and hold yourself, and them, accountable for the choices they make.
I mostly agree with this. Where I disagree with the other posters is that I'm sympathetic to the all those programmers who are basically good people but are stuck in Dilbert cubicles writing code they really don't want to write. The programmers aren't happy about it but they don't have other opportunities. The list is endless...
The programmers writing dark patterns on LinkedIn, the correlation tracking on Facebook, the dynamic ticket pricing at airlines, etc.
I'm not talking about programmers writing Superfish, or ransom-ware that encrypts the harddrive unless the user pays into a bitcoin account. Those folks are evil and if they didn't have programming skill to write viruses, they'd find another outlet for their evil such as skimming casino accounts or falsifying company expense reports.
Not everybody gets to write software to send virtual "Get Well" cards to kids with cancer. There just aren't enough of those morally perfect jobs to go around.
I'm talking about the hundreds of thousands just getting through the day at the office. I'm actually shocked that more of us aren't sympathetic to the situation and see that not every programmer supporting business grey areas can just quit. And testimonials from a handful of HN posters proudly proclaiming they quit does not convince people. That shows a total lack of understanding in what type dialogue actually works. People need empathy and support, not righteousness.
It's not just programmers. It's the young lady selling overpriced cosmetics at the department store to the customers that don't need it. It's the minimum wage cashier at McDonald's constantly asking, "would you like extra supersize fries with that?" even though the customer in front her weighs 300 pounds and is one burger away from a heart attack. You think someone lecturing a low-level worker about selling fries is appropriate?
I believe in moral sermons backed up by support (financial, offering a home to say, etc) if the employee loses his job. Otherwise, it's empty platitudes.
[1]http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=social+justic...
are those jobs really dilbert cubicles? i really have negative sympathy for these people's essentially first world problems and a backlash against them is inevitable, and in my opinion welcome at this point.
Yes... that, or open office plans with Dilbert bosses. Direct your backlash at the corporate management, not the programmers. Many of the software engineers already feel bad and would like to do something else (start their own company, whatever.)
However, they have $50k-100k in college debt and avoiding the programming jobs that reprice airline tickets doesn't make that debt disappear.
it's not my backlash, i don't own it - therefore i won't be directing anything.
just because somebody got into debt to get education that isn't necessarily required to do a job - doesn't absolve them - or warrant any sympathy.
You're right in a way. Values like these come from the top, in the project manager, the CEO etc. Morality is found in the company culture, and shouldn't be found exclusively in the worker bee software engineers.
But what else I see is that this can also come from the bottom up, in the way software engineers can "manage up". Software engineers are by definition more intimately aware of the details of a project, and they need to be listened to by management when they have a concern. Because frankly management can't be so aware of the details. It's our responsibility to be concerned about ethics, so that we can better manage up to spread that concern throughout an organization, so that it can filter down to someone else.
As a software engineer, it is extremely likely that you are replaceable, and you always have to factor into your considerations what your replacement is going to do. You don't usually have the choice between "the thing happens or does not happen"; your choice is often something more like "you can do the thing, try to convince people that it's a bad idea, or roll the dice and see if your replacement - who is expected to be more average than you - is both willing and more able to convince people that it's a bad idea".
The average doctor follows the Hippocratic oath. What does the average software engineer do?
(The above argument does not apply if your goal is publicity/drama rather than effective change)
Software engineering does not have that sort of heavy load.
My project pipeline is half full right now. Where are those easy buck projects ...
Most of the evil in the world is not due to top of the pyramid arch villains like the CEOs of the banks that screwed us all, Dick Cheney, the head of the NSA, or even Hitler. It's due to all the people below who enable it. It's called The Banality of Systemic Evil: http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/09/15/the-banality....
That is a potential interesting point you (accidentally) skipped over: I have zero moral issues in making a porn site, unless it did scummy things (install malware). How can we agree about ethics if what we genuinely consider bad is so different?
For example, everyone loathes the example of banks re-sequencing customers' deposits and checks such that it's more likely to overdraft and net the bank a lucrative penalty fee. The business exec or MBA who dreamed up that scheme isn't the one who coded that in COBOL or whatever; it's the the software engineers who wrote that despised piece of code. But like 99% of the rest of us, software engineers have families to feed and they can't go on a moral crusade.
On the other hand, a software engineer who is making their mark in the world as an entrepreneur definitely has some choices. I suppose many of us can make an easy buck developing clever (and legal) sex/porn websites but many of us choose not to. We want to do something we wouldn't be embarrassed to show our mothers.
The Hippocratic Oath is more applicable to doctors because they have more professional independence administering medical care. Software engineers with day jobs do not have that type of autonomy.
EDIT to the replies:
I wasn't contending porn and naked bodies was unethical. Possibly awkward to explain to your parents yes, but certainly not unethical. Unfortunately, porn websites and the porn businesses are often a very shady (malware, fake singles ads, etc) and many of us choose not to get into that area.
As for the power for low-level software engineers to enact change in the world...
I would LOVE to lecture software engineers on morality. The "Fountainhead" Howard Roarke architect who blows up his building to remain true to himself is an incredibly appealing narrative. Howard did it and got the girl in the end, can't you do it too?!?
However, my standard for telling a software engineer what is right or wrong (that has serious personal consequences) is to back it up with a $100,000 check in my hand. This way, I can soften the blow of any consequences (e.g. his unemployment.) Since I can't do that, my words are just armchair lectures and empty platitudes. Besides, my words of wisdom are not really necessary. The software engineers are already morally troubled by it; they're just not in an easy position to override their managers.
Personally, I don't have to write questionable software but it's because I have the economic ability not to. My finances allows me to avoid writing software I don't agree with so it seems very wrong to use that as a pulpit for moral superiority over others.
I think many of the replies are being unfair to the life situation the typical software engineer faces. The rhetoric comparing the writing of code to optimize bank transactions to gassing the Jews" or "experimenting on babies" is unwarranted. Yes, writing code to engineer financials is distasteful but let's not get carried away with the counter arguments. The software engineers want to do good but they often feel powerless to do so. The harsh criticism levied by posters here does not change that at all.