News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farming in the Sky by IkmoIkmo on Sunday May 24, 2015 @10:21AM (#9596328)
So far it's always been a great idea, just not very sustainable.

I mean imagine building a home for every plant you eat. It'd be kind of crazy right? You'd need to provide many of the things a typical home has: shelter, electricity, plumbing, food supply, structures etc.

But this is really what is proposed in these types of farms. Instead of available soil, you build a large structure, pots, racks and tracks. Instead of rainwater and rainwater distribution systems (clouds) you build pipes and tubes and plumbing and install pumps to move it all around. And you provide the plants nutrients in this way. And then you build a large shelter to keep everything away from the elements that mostly grow the plants outside. And then you install artificial lighting and electricity systems to pump energy into the solar panels that we know as leaves, to generate food.

For the longest time this has been hugely expensive. And to feed 7 billion people with about 2-3 plants or whatever it is, worth each day (in cereal, greens, fruits and legumes etc), you need to build billions of little plant homes.

And that was just never very economical. Let's not forget that a hectare yields an average of about 5.000 kg of cereal. Wheat goes for about $200 per metric ton, so a hectare nets you about $1k.

Now that's 107k square footage. That's incredibly cheap. Now imagine you want to replace that with a hectare of factory or say the plant houses I described earlier. That's a huge capex investment in the tens of millions compared to the hectare of soil which is priced around $10-15k and can be leased for a few hundred. To compete on price you'd need very high production in cheap economies of scale to offset your fixed costs on building this huge greenhouse structure with infrastructure for every individual plant.

But that's also where the land is much cheaper. It's virtually impossible to run vertical farms on soil, so you need a soilless medium which isn't a problem, but it means you need plumbing to every plant. No biggie. But the same for light, you can't do a vertical farm on scale (i.e. rows and rows) and expect sunshine to reach the bottom plants who sit in the shade. So you need artificial lighting and heating, and that's very expensive compared to sunlight.

High value crops, sure it's fine. (e.g. see every indoor weed farm with artificial lighting etc). But as the future of agriculture (where staple foods worldwide are cheap cereals, legumes, corn etc), no way.

Unless you have very large advances in material science (cheap, sturdy materials to pump out large greenhouses cheaply and sustainably) and energy (cheap solar pv/thermal, wind, geothermal). And that's what we're seeing now. So it's definitely getting more appealing by the day and it's something I've been very interested in pursuing because I just adore the idea of automated farming on some levels (I love to hike in nature, but large corn fields aren't really nature to me and don't excite me more than the idea of an automated corn factory!), but I still don't see how the economics make sense.

And it's more than finance, it's touted as an environmental solution because these farms can be located near the point of consumption. But that's just one part of the story, and incredibly myopic if it's the only part of the story that's considered. For example the problem in community supported agriculture I see is that people will drive a car individually, once a week, to a small location that doesn't get economies of scale, to pick up a tiny amount of food. Because they're under the impression it's more environmentally friendly than a large shipping container moving their beans across the ocean. When in reality their food miles is a bit like saying it's environmentally more friendly drive 2 miles to a store, than to cycle 5 miles to a store for your groceries because 'it's less food miles that way'. Sustainability is a very serious issue and I'm not entirely convinced such factory-style farming is more sustainable (see inherent investments to move from soil to building plant houses). In terms of water usage, it's actually amazing to use a soilless medium, and water is one of this century's biggest challenges. But in terms of materials and energy... I'm very skeptical.

Re:Farming in the Sky by falcolas on Sunday May 24, 2015 @10:37AM (#9596375)
I think the biggest problem with land-based farms is that there is only so much land available for it, and that land is also highly valued for other properties (such as residential and commercial ventures).

I don't think it's unreasonable to see us get to a point where the only room we have to grow our crops is upwards (or on another planet, but that's even further out on the timeline).

Re:Farming in the Sky by fennecfoxen on Sunday May 24, 2015 @11:02AM (#9596448)
> I think the biggest problem with land-based farms is that there is only so much land available for it, and that land is also highly valued for other properties (such as residential and commercial ventures).

I don't think you really understand the distribution of land use and urbanization in the world if you think construction of houses and shops are a substantial limiting factor in its agriculture. Your remedial assignment is to drive from Denver to Chicago.

As for growing plants on another planet... and shipping them back to Earth... if you've got that sort of an energy budget to waste shipping food around why aren't you just building nuclear-powered underground greenhouse-caves or some nonsense like that?

Re:Farming in the Sky by falcolas on Sunday May 24, 2015 @01:08PM (#9596796)
> Your remedial assignment is to drive from Denver to Chicago.

And yours is to drive from Boston to Miami. Or London to Glasgow. Or Osaka to Tokyo.

Cherry picking a route through the breadbasket of America as an example of typical land distribution between urban and agricultural doesn't make for a convincing argument.

> why aren't you just building nuclear-powered underground greenhouse-caves or some nonsense like that?

Because any such location would be more valuable as a spot to pack more humans. Proximity (particularly when you start working on a planetary scale) to urban centers is worth a lot of money.

Re:Farming in the Sky by fennecfoxen on Sunday May 24, 2015 @01:58PM (#9596977)
> And yours is to drive from Boston to Miami. Or London to Glasgow. Or Osaka to Tokyo.

I haven't driven from Boston to Miami in one trip, but I've traversed that entire corridor. My grandparents once owned a few acres on a private lake near Eastford, CT. Lots of cool old dairy-farms, apple orchards, berry-picking, bird-watching, wildlife, et cetera. Most of I95 south of Alexandria is rather boring -- hours and hours of trees -- if you're starting by DC it's a little more fun to divert along US 301, passing through horse territory and then rolling through Fort AP Hill. More travel time, but on the northern part of the route you're more likely to pass the occasional roadside produce stands.

The southernmost bits are the ones I'm less familiar with, though those are possibly the most interesting as in Florida in particular there are places where urban development threatens the most sensitive ecosystems... but the Everglades were never known for agriculture. Agriculture does moreover threaten ecosystems across the midwest (one recent example: monarch butterflies have been suffering massive population drops in the past few years because Roundup-Ready crops have led to widespread herbicide application that kills the weeds that they'd use for food).

But agriculture itself is not under substantial pressure from urban land use at this time. Look, let's ask the US Department of Agriculture: http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/eib-economic-informatio... (2002).

Urban land, 2.6% of the nation's land area. Crop land, 19.5%. Grassland pastures/ranges: 25.9%. -http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/249911/eib14fm_1_.pdf

"In 2002, urban land in the United States was less than 3 percent of total land area, but housed 79 percent of the U.S. population." - http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/250013/eib14g_1_.pdf

Space for physical people has always been a nonissue next to space for their agriculture and other people-supporting land uses.

Re:Farming in the Sky by jqm on Sunday May 24, 2015 @12:01PM (#9596606)
"Your remedial assignment is to drive from Denver to Chicago."

Yep. Or just look out the airplane window at all those little green circles and squares next time you fly across the country.

Re:Farming in the Sky by IkmoIkmo on Sunday May 24, 2015 @12:18PM (#9596653)
There's definitely a bit of competition between agriculture and say forests, urban areas and sustainable energy projects. But urban areas probably are the smallest of them all. We've seen some deforestation, and we've also seen agriculture under pressure from biofuels. The biofuels idea is mostly bankrupt (at least in terms of crops, algae etc have potential), and deforestation is in part illegal and unnecessary, not due to a dire lack of agricultural land.

Our rate of human population concentration is very high, about 95% of humans are concentrated on about 10% of surface area worldwide. Meanwhile we only use 11% of land for agriculture, while about 36% of our land is suitable for farming. (which could be improved to some extent, e.g. there are various ways to take back deserts on small scales, and on large scales too if technology improves enough). And in fact, urbanisation is only growing. We've never had as much concentration of people, and as many people living in cities as today.

So I don't think agricultural land is under that much threat. In fact we could probably pretty easily cut back agricultural land by 50% while increasing to a population of 9 billion if we changed our diets and our use of farmland. For example some rough numbers from 2013:

> roughly 40 percent of U.S. corn is used for ethanol, (roughly 36 percent of U.S. corn is fed to cattle, pigs and chickens. Much of the rest is exported. Only a tiny fraction of the national corn crop is directly used for food for Americans, much of that for high-fructose corn syrup.

Small edits by me. Now imagine what that means when you figure that corn is the nr 1 crop in the US, and a tiny fraction goes to actually feeding people. As for animals, the studies vary between chickens requiring as little as 2 kilos of plant food and cows as high as 10 kilos, to produce 1 kilo of meat. Whatever the exact accurate number is, it's a fact that making food from animals is inefficient. You put more food in than you get out, sometimes by an order of magnitude, for a different taste experience for a minute or so per day.

And that's just corn, it's not alone. More than half of grain is used for livestock, too.

Now obviously land is finite, if you want to live here with 50 billion people, sure. You need to go up. But the demographic projections to 2100 are to cap out at around 10 billion, and then slowly decrease again as the world moves to an average birthrate we see in OECD countries (1.7, while about 2.1 is necessary to sustain a population level). These kinds of population levels can be sustained on flat land, vertical isn't necessary.

Doesn't mean that vertical can't happen. If vertical is better, who cares if it is necessary, it'll be replaced anyway. But the challenge of vertical farming is currently sustainability (large infrastructure costs are necessary to make it possible to get conditions you see on flat land for 'free' (sun, clouds and soil taking care of light, water, food, distribution, containers, germination etc) in a vertical space. And if you can't solve that problem of sustainability, it doesn't matter if there's not enough flat land anyway because we'd be doomed.