News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by swombat on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @01:05PM (#959631)
Excellent, excellent. Could this be applied on a wider scale, or would the loss of novelty dull the effect on students?
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by tierack on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @01:26PM (#959675)
It seems like it would only work for subjects where students have the capacity to figure out errors on their own. It would be disastrous in a foreign language class if you were told the word for "mother" was "banana".

As I've mentioned in another discussion, I once had a math professor who would sneak in impossible problems into the homework (e.g. prove the continuum hypothesis). It worked very well to get us to spend countless hours just trying things out, and eventually to spur us to prove decidability of the problems, all of which made us much better. But I imagine it would get old fast if every class I took did something similar.

Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by icefox on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @03:24PM (#959905)
When I was learning Norwegian that happened to me. Every weeks lesson had new words, but we were not told what they meant and we were supposed to figure out them on our own. As you would expect I translated and memorized a few wrong every week. This had a snowball effect of making the class harder and harder as I tried to learn new words and unlearn the words/rules I previously memorized incorrectly.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by SlyShy on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @07:49PM (#960340)
It's interesting that you feel that way. I've taken two foreign languages at the university level, and they were both taught in an "immersion" style manner (that is to say, all the instruction was in the native language) and have found it beneficial rather than harmful. But perhaps I reach for a dictionary more often than you did.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by oujheush on Thursday November 26, 2009 @10:23AM (#962730)
I'm guessing the "figure them out on their own" precluded using a dictionary? Otherwise you're right, a dictionary should solve the problem.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by stonemetal on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @02:45PM (#959839)
>> It would be disastrous in a foreign language class if you were told the word for "mother" was "banana".

How so? 20 min with a bilingual dictionary(which is more than likely in the back of the textbook) would be enough to verify definitions. Though I don't think it would have the desired effect since it doesn't really promote learning just rote fact checking.

Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by pradocchia on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @05:25PM (#960070)
> How so?

Learning a foreign language is all about internalization. It takes time and is hard to correct. The last thing you want is to inadvertently internalize the wrong thing. Root vocabulary would be relatively easy to fix, but pronunciation and grammar would be very hard.

Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by stonemetal on Wednesday November 25, 2009 @12:00AM (#960658)
Yeah, pronunciation would suck if the only person who knew how to say it correctly was just fing with you.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by dbz on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @02:38PM (#959825)
As soon as I read that comment I thought the exact same thing; however, I thought about it for math. Not above calculus level math (because the students in those classes should be smart enough to call something fishy out immediately), but high school or elementary school math. A simple lie could destroy a students math career. Especially one a day!
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by amalcon on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @02:57PM (#959854)
When I was In a numerical approximations course, one other student in the class and I managed to correct the professor about once a week. He wasn't deliberately lying; actually, it was because he had a very poor textbook to work with and was trusting it too much. We were just in the process of doing this again when he demonstrated that you can legitimately say O(n) when you mean O(n^2).

Come to find out, he was a math prof, and very much not an algorithms guy. There are two versions of big-oh notation: one for algorithmic complexity, and one for accuracy of approximations. They are exact opposites of each other: higher numbers are "better" for approximation accuracy, at least in the sense they were used in the course. He was unaware of the former, but both of us were unaware of the latter.

Not such a great teacher, no. Still, the last mistake was an entirely reasonable one. It's a great example of how even math students need to be on their toes.

Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by pmiller2 on Wednesday November 25, 2009 @12:16AM (#960674)
One thing I'd like to mention is that math and science profs rarely mind being corrected when they're wrong (assuming it's done respectfully). I've seen profs in other disciplines become positively incensed when a student tried to challenge what the professor was saying, but I've never seen a math or science prof do so. Your mileage may vary (and I admit this is really nothing more than anecdotal evidence of anything), but I think it says something about the culture of science vs other disciplines.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by eru on Thursday November 26, 2009 @10:02AM (#962703)
I can verify this for my math profs. I guess it has something to do with coming closer to `one single truth' in math than every where else.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by dbz on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @03:28PM (#959912)
Oh yes I agree. I personally am a math guy. My algebra two teacher was...well...Let's say that I sat in the back of the class the entire year and just corrected him several times a day. Almost all of the people who left that class struggled to understand concepts of their next math course because they:

1) Didn't have a solid understanding of algebra. and 2) Didn't even learn all of the algebraic concepts.

I was fine (because I could recognize the concepts even though he made a TON of mistakes) and skipped (precalc/) trig (which I learned during..) and went right on to AP calc . But the point is that the fact that the teacher made so many mistakes led to the students not being able to comprehend slightly higher level math. (and him being fired)

Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by eru on Thursday November 26, 2009 @10:03AM (#962708)
It's one the big-O notation and the other the small-o notation, or so? There's also the \omikron or \Omega notation (or so) that has to be asymptotically correct (up to a factor) in both directions.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by iterationx on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @01:58PM (#959751)
reminds me of a Monty Python skit
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by pmiller2 on Wednesday November 25, 2009 @12:17AM (#960675)
No it doesn't.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by tetsuo13 on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @02:00PM (#959756)
I'm reminded of the reference book "Writing CGI Applications with Perl." In the introduction the author warned that there will be several purposeful mistakes in every chapter as an exercise to the reader to find and correct. Using this technique in a reference manual was bad enough but it made things even more difficult given that there was no key.

I got rid of the book. Tough to learn from a book that lies.

Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by cyen on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @02:43PM (#959835)
How absurd. The best part of this learning technique is the discussion and the collaboration between students to solve the puzzle - you even learn by pointing out false positives, with someone correcting you and reinforcing that bit of information. A textbook / reference book is entirely different from a classroom - what was that author thinking?
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by InclinedPlane on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @08:13PM (#960374)
I think that author was thinking "hmm, how can I skip a long editorial fact-checking process without looking completely unprofessional."
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by tetha on Wednesday November 25, 2009 @01:39AM (#960764)
In fact, this is happening to me right now around the third time in the row, and it still is interesting.

However, in our case, this is happening, because this is the third time in a row we organized and talked a professor to give us a lecture around 6 people (which, at the moment, is 1/3 of all students in this term and study course). The conclusion is that the professor is not that prepared, and because the entire course is pretty math-heavy, errors in proofs and lemmas just slip in. Pretty often, they are just little typos, but it still is fun to hunt and spot them.

Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by xenophanes on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @01:21PM (#959663)
Why is the sibling to this (my) comment dead? I don't see anything horribly wrong with it!
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by ynniv on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @01:39PM (#959710)
I've seen this happen to users before. Looking at tomjen2's history, all comments from the last 11 days have been killed with 1 point. I take this to mean that they were killed quickly and automatically before anyone voted on them.

Of course, if you aren't +showdead, you would never know.

Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by swombat on Wednesday November 25, 2009 @06:49AM (#960984)
My guess would be http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=936379 had something to do with it.
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by dschobel on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @03:26PM (#959909)
Re:One of my favorite professors in college was a self-confe... by xenophanes on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @03:57PM (#959944)
I see.

I think the "do not notify" policy is evil in most cases.

Humans should not be treated like spam bots. Look how much time/effort he wasted writing perfectly legit comments afterwards.