They should have locked the thread or use a wiki page for this. A wiki page is less likely to be edited to add this kind of comment or at least it would be easier to clean up with a bot.
It's surprising that Github doesnt provide "approval" as a native feature
... :)
It's annoying in some cases now because 1) it's anyone, not just the active contributors or even users, 2) people don't use it as a vote but as a general expression of support, 3) -1 isn't really used anymore so you can't scan them and see what the sentiment is, and 4) in this case, it's not even clear what they are lending support to- the merge, or that it is time to discuss a merge seriously.
So yeah, in this case it's noise but in some contexts +1/-1 is a quick and simple way to govern code and it has historical roots. Just ranting as I think they and some in this thread are a little too quick to judge. +1/-1 from the right people could be considered very relevant information to a discussion (esp. within a focused community).
Because subscribing does not show interest/support: the repository owner does not see how many people have subscribed to the issue. Furthermore, supporting the resolution of an issue does not mean you want to be spammed with updates to said issue.
> Google's issue trackers have the same issue: they support starring but people insist on doing "me too" posts.
Google's issue tracker has the same issue to a lower extent: while everybody can see the number of stars on an issue (which is good), starring an issue requires following it and being spammed by it (which is bad).
Then again, people are by and large idiots, even on e.g. youtrack (which has non-subscripting voting) +1 comments abound: http://blog.jetbrains.com/youtrack/2013/01/making-1-mean-wha...
Only way I see to mitigate that is assuming the tracker has orthogonal subscription and voting ruthless moderation and removal of worthless "+1" comments.
Commenting on the issue automatically subscribes you to it. You have to manually unsubscribe if you don’t want to be spammed.
The +1s are so irritating because you have to read through a huge conversation and you also keep getting email notifications because you want to keep in touch with a thread. It actually makes it harder to do what the github topic is about with the +1s.
From the author: "Folks. Please STOP +1 and :+1: -ing GitHub tickets. We get it, but it makes tickets hard to have conversations on. Contribute with something substantive instead."
This is a very common problem for github issues posted on HN/any social media. Would be great if github had a voting mechanism.