News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The In-State Tuition Break, Slowly Disappearing by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @04:54PM (#9579232)
> What amazes me is that out of state students would have to pay out of state while someone in the state without a visa could get in state tuition.

Why? The basis of in-state tuition for residents is that, through the required residency period, you have subjected yourself to the tax and other obligations that come from living in the state and have contributed to the community independent of nationality or citizenship, and that the tuition break is part of the service that the State provides in exchange for that to residents.

I'm not sure how permission from the federal government to be in the country is even relevant to that.

> I'm not against in state tuition for visa offenders, but at the same time there seems to be an unfairness with regard to out of state students who would have to pay the "full price".

Currently-out-of-state students could choose to move to the state first and establish residency. I'm not sure where the supposed unfairness is.

Re:The In-State Tuition Break, Slowly Disappearing by mc32 on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @04:56PM (#9579245)
Rich kids can afford the full price. Poor students can't afford to move to get residency to qualify for in state tuition.

Also at 17 18yoa you have not paid into the tax system, so that's irrelevant. It's not like we're about to qualify how much parents have or have not contributed into the system.

Re:The In-State Tuition Break, Slowly Disappearing by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @05:04PM (#9579291)
> Rich kids can afford the full price. Poor students can't afford to move to get residency to qualify for in state tuition.

Yes, wealth makes you able to afford things you could not afford without that wealth. That's true by definition.

I'm not sure how that makes it unfair that the State of California subsidizes tuition for residents (but not nonresidents) regardless, in either case, of visa status.

The State of California generally serves, in order of priority, citizens of the State of California, non-citizen residents of the State of California, and then, maybe, sometimes, non-citizen non-residents of the State of California.

I'm not seeing any unfairness in the State subsidizing UC education for the first two groups but not the third.

> Also at 17 18yoa you have not paid into the tax system

Yes, you probably have. You may not have paid income tax, but income tax isn't the only significant State of California general fund tax. You've probably paid a lot of sales tax.

(If you are financially independent at that age as a resident, you've probably paid state income tax, too; if you aren't, then you probably aren't paying the tuition yourself in any case, and the people who probably are probably the people that are paying your other expenses, who, if you are a resident, have probably paid plenty in both income and sales tax in the state.)

Re:The In-State Tuition Break, Slowly Disappearing by arenaninja on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @05:48PM (#9579545)
> Also at 17 18yoa you have not paid into the tax system, so that's irrelevant.

I don't think it's irrelevant actually. I don't know if it's the main reason for this policy, but I'd imagine you're far more likely to remain in the state if you have already lived here long enough for in state tuition. Because if you pick up your bags as soon as you're done with your education, you just drained the state some money.