Why? The basis of in-state tuition for residents is that, through the required residency period, you have subjected yourself to the tax and other obligations that come from living in the state and have contributed to the community independent of nationality or citizenship, and that the tuition break is part of the service that the State provides in exchange for that to residents.
I'm not sure how permission from the federal government to be in the country is even relevant to that.
> I'm not against in state tuition for visa offenders, but at the same time there seems to be an unfairness with regard to out of state students who would have to pay the "full price".
Currently-out-of-state students could choose to move to the state first and establish residency. I'm not sure where the supposed unfairness is.
Also at 17 18yoa you have not paid into the tax system, so that's irrelevant. It's not like we're about to qualify how much parents have or have not contributed into the system.
Yes, wealth makes you able to afford things you could not afford without that wealth. That's true by definition.
I'm not sure how that makes it unfair that the State of California subsidizes tuition for residents (but not nonresidents) regardless, in either case, of visa status.
The State of California generally serves, in order of priority, citizens of the State of California, non-citizen residents of the State of California, and then, maybe, sometimes, non-citizen non-residents of the State of California.
I'm not seeing any unfairness in the State subsidizing UC education for the first two groups but not the third.
> Also at 17 18yoa you have not paid into the tax system
Yes, you probably have. You may not have paid income tax, but income tax isn't the only significant State of California general fund tax. You've probably paid a lot of sales tax.
(If you are financially independent at that age as a resident, you've probably paid state income tax, too; if you aren't, then you probably aren't paying the tuition yourself in any case, and the people who probably are probably the people that are paying your other expenses, who, if you are a resident, have probably paid plenty in both income and sales tax in the state.)
I don't think it's irrelevant actually. I don't know if it's the main reason for this policy, but I'd imagine you're far more likely to remain in the state if you have already lived here long enough for in state tuition. Because if you pick up your bags as soon as you're done with your education, you just drained the state some money.
Why should California have a special obligation to students from New Mexico? Note that New Mexico already gets 37% of its state budget from the federal government, and has among the highest per capita number of federal employees (both civilian and military). Californian tax payers are already heavily subsidizing New Mexico as it is.
California gets a lot of Federal aid too at 27%. New Mexico apparently takes 36% (nice rounding).
> and has among the highest per capita number of federal employees (both civilian and military).
So New Mexico, per capita, has the highest percentage of people working in governmentally mandated jobs, or public service workers, if you will. California should definitely pick up the slack.
> Californian tax payers are already heavily subsidizing New Mexico as it is.
By that logic, California should definitely allow in-state tuition to everyone in Kansas, New Jersey, Illinois, Nevada, North Dakota, Delaware, Connecticut, Hawaii, Virginia, and especially Alaska
...Because they are all subsidizing California as it is.
> ...Because they are all subsidizing California as it is.
Actually, as a net contributor of federal taxes, California is subsidizing all of those states (except fellow contributors Illinois and New Jersey), as well as New Mexico. [0]
But no one is "subsidizing" California via federal taxes, since California is a net contributor of federal taxes.
[0] http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/05/which-st...
I was just annoyed at the combination of entitlement and lack of empathy in the poster I was responding to.
I actually think it’s a good thing to redistribute money from rich states like California, New Jersey, or Illinois toward poor states like New Mexico and Mississippi.
I also really like New Mexico, which is a beautiful state filled with lovely towns and wonderful people.
To live in a society together requires a certain baseline level of equality of means and opportunity so that we can treat each-other with empathy and mutual respect. When some areas are rich financial centers and others have serious social problems and few employment opportunities, it’s smart national policy to redirect federal funds from richer areas toward poorer areas to encourage economic development.
W/r/t higher education specifically, I think it would be a wonderful thing to send more federal money to state universities in places like New Mexico, which are really hurting financially these days. (As a thought experiment, if we replaced a substantial portion of the military spending that currently goes to poor states with education spending, I daresay the outcomes would be dramatically better for everyone involved.)
Then, like the visa-less (and with less risk!) they can establish residency in California first. Or pay the price that the seller (California) is willing to offer for people who don't choose to "buy membership" that way.
The famous Romney 47% was based on an analysis of net federal income taxes, which is completely irrelevant to whether they've paid into California's general fund taxes (which include, primarily, California's state income tax and California's sales and use taxes.)
And even less relevant to whether they've generally established roots in the State such that it is in the State's interest to serve them as part of its constituency.
Or if they’re being paid in cash under the table, as sometimes happens for both undocumented immigrants and for immigrants with visas or permanent residents, that’s 100% the responsibility of the employer.
Indeed, undocumented workers often end up paying more tax than they would if they had authentic papers, because they’re less likely to file for tax rebates at the end of the year.
They also pay sales tax, if they’re paying rent are ultimately contributing to property taxes paid by the landlord, etc. etc.
If you want to see some data about this w/r/t state and local taxes, here’s a recent summary: http://www.itep.org/immigration/
Documented workers who earn below a certain level have the entirety of their income tax deductions returned to them by the IRS. This happened during my first few years of working.
Workers who earn an exceptionally low amount, and have additional dependents or are paying college tuition, can earn additional tax credits, such as EIC or Hope.
In this way, many working households benefit from welfare and have someone working and/or going to school.
But I know that often people that do not have access to instate tuition because they lack the visa requirement. Yet they grew and have lived most of their lives within the state.
I'm not against in state tuition for visa offenders, but at the same time there seems to be an unfairness with regard to out of state students who would have to pay the "full price".