Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by Mizza on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @04:55PM
(#9579241)
Well, you can.. but that's kind of your fault for being cheeky. So yes, you can lose control over your account if you do that, but that's not really a bug, that's a PEBKAC.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by yellowapple on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @03:13PM
(#9578501)
"I will not use Pubmail for spamming or any illegal purposes."
Not checking that box until "illegal" is defined. Which jurisdiction?
Also, I'm not too keen on requiring an email address to create an email address.
EDIT: and apparently, checking that box is not required to create an account.
EDIT 2: is there a way to use SMTP and POP/IMAP (i.e. use a standard email client)? If not, is this something in the works? I have a feeling this is dead in the water if you're targeting politicians without letting them use their Outlook.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by secstate on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @04:46PM
(#9579177)
I don't think the goal of this project is to allow public officials to respond in public, but rather to avoid having to copy-paste email chains with public officials when they stonewall or downright circumvent laws in what they believe is a private channel (traditional email).
POP, SMTP and IMAP would seem contrary the whole idea of a public stream of email communication. The idea here is that reporters, investigators or concerned citizens can use a pubmail.io address to simply maintain public communication with a public official.
I'd love it if a politician could use it, but I don't think that's going to happen in the near future, so this gives the public a tool to foce more transparency without the politicians/reps themselves having to commit to it.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by yellowapple on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:48PM
(#9579876)
Can you answer the initial question about legal jurisdiction, though? This is still not clear in the About page, and if you're including a checkbox (that's thankfully optional) asking if one's use of Pubmail will be for "legal purposes", it's generally a good idea what "legal" means in the context of the site. "Legal" in terms of American law? British law? Iranian law? Somali law? Sharia law? UN law? Sealandic law?
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by Mizza on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @07:40PM
(#9580105)
Yeah, I mean, I don't honestly have an answer for that. I guess I should.
It basically means, "don't be a dick, don't harass, don't spam." I'm not a big fan of laws, but I am a big fan of common sense and decency, and that's all I want.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by yellowapple on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @08:19PM
(#9580257)
The answer would probably be the same answer as "Which country does this site operate from?", but IANAL.
Regardless, changing the text of that checkbox to what you mean - "I promise to refrain from being a jerk, harassing people, or spamming" - would make the question moot.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by hnyc on Thursday May 21, 2015 @12:13AM
(#9580924)
> POP, SMTP and IMAP would seem contrary the whole idea of a public stream of email communication
I disagree. I believe it would create for easier access to a public stream of email communication, in particular to the person who sent the email. Sure, there's an easy way to get a notification when one gets an email, but how about replying to it? If one could reply to the email from the notification email (and see the contents of the email), that would be going towards a better solution (in my opinion). But even better would be POP, SMTP, and IMAP support, for the easiest way of getting emails, checking them, sending them, replying to them, etc.
POP, SMTP, and IMAP would not remove the web access and the public viewing of all emails, it would extend what has already been created.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by anateus on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @04:41PM
(#9579141)
It's not really intended for politicians to use it, but rather for people to communicate with politicians using it, and having these communications available publicly.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by deskglass on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @03:12PM
(#9578492)
Awesome idea and execution! I'm reading through the featured emails and laughing at how unresponsive public officials are.
I recommend adding a signature feature. If I were to use this service, I'd want to add a signature to the effect that all emails to and from the account are publicly accessible.
Also, I recommend adding a way to read through a specific account's emails (nevermind, they have that) and a way to search through all email.
The signature issue is interesting. On one hand, the point isn't to 'trick' people and it should be transparent, on the other hand, putting that "up front" may negatively impact response rates. However, I think you're right that it should be the user's option.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by jszymborski on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @03:21PM
(#9578567)
Yah, a signature feature would pretty much need to be essential. It's pretty essential you tell some one they're on speakerphone, let alone a permanent record.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by ffn on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @05:13PM
(#9579346)
Cool service, OP, where/how are you hosting this, btw? I ask because some years ago I built a ruby-based service very much like it for personal use, but the monthly aws costs started getting to me (it was costing me about $40 a month to run... yes, I am that poor).
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by Mizza on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @05:23PM
(#9579416)
This is hosted on a super cheapo DigitalOcean droplet. I think it's about $10/mo. The mail service is provided by MailGun, which is an amazing API/library set and super cheap!
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by hellbanner on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @03:18PM
(#9578532)
Hey, thanks for making this! I've considered doing this as a pre-emptive for NSLs relating to geolocation (building GPS apps). Nice to see someone do it.
Have you gotten any corporate accounts or politicians signed up you want to share with us?
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by Mizza on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @03:32PM
(#9578647)
No, not yet, as this is the first real 'coming out' for Pubmail. It's mostly just been me and friends testing it out so far.
That being said, I'd love if it political/corporate users had their own accounts, but I don't think that will ever happen. It's more about doing the opposite - having ordinary people post their communications with political/corporate officials to the public by default.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @05:33PM
(#9579470)
> That being said, I'd love if it political/corporate users had their own accounts, but I don't think that will ever happen. It's more about doing the opposite - having ordinary people post their communications with political/corporate officials to the public by default.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by fapjacks on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:45PM
(#9579857)
This is an excellent idea. I have no idea if this is already a feature, but it would be nice to see when the recipient has opened/read a mail. I really wish something like this would be implemented by policy in government. I understand it would divert "meaty" conversations even further behind closed doors, but something like this is definitely a good start. Bravo!
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by fapjacks on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:52PM
(#9579897)
Ah, I've got it backwards! I meant originally that the pubmail email could be seen as having been read, but that was my backwards thinking that the politician would be the one using the pubmail address. This way, yes, it would be impossible to get a return receipt without image/js or something.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by MichaelGG on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @07:21PM
(#9580013)
Gmail no longer does. They download the images for you, so your IP isn't leaked. I'm not sure if this is done beforehand (removing all info from the load), or after you open the email.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by oceanplexian on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @05:49PM
(#9579553)
Yes there is. Public disclosure of private facts but only if it's not in the public interest AND it needs to be offensive. But realistically this is the United States and you're going to have a hell of a time convincing a judge to go for it. US libel and privacy law is very weak.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by kolev on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:06PM
(#9579653)
Nice, I was thinking of implementing something like this myself as I hate retweeing reps' emails. Just one suggestion - why do you need to confirm every action including non-destructive like logging out?
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by Mizza on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:08PM
(#9579666)
Accounts stuff is provided by an upstream package, django-allauth. Confirm on logout is handy so you can't trick a user into GETing a log out page, it has to be POSTed.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by spoiler on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @05:41PM
(#9579518)
There should be an option to flag email as spam, or as unwanted email, or as scam, or just a general "flag" option (for other people's mailboxes, too).
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by Mizza on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @05:56PM
(#9579594)
There is a spam filter acting already, but it looks like we already have our first troll spamming it.. great. Knew this would happen, hoped it wouldn't happen two hours after launching. =/
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by spoiler on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:54PM
(#9579903)
Ah, I was thinking more along the lines of generally inappropriate email that a spam filter wouldn't pick up. Like public shaming or flaming, for example.
Re:Show HN: Pubmail.io
by rohitv on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @06:23PM
(#9579754)
It seems like [email protected] is stuck in some sort of a loop?. I apologize if I somehow caused that. I just tried to email myself ([email protected])... :/
now that the link is publicly visible, can I lose control of my account?
EDIT: some others did the same, bright minds think alike :)
Not checking that box until "illegal" is defined. Which jurisdiction?
Also, I'm not too keen on requiring an email address to create an email address.
EDIT: and apparently, checking that box is not required to create an account.
EDIT 2: is there a way to use SMTP and POP/IMAP (i.e. use a standard email client)? If not, is this something in the works? I have a feeling this is dead in the water if you're targeting politicians without letting them use their Outlook.
POP, SMTP and IMAP would seem contrary the whole idea of a public stream of email communication. The idea here is that reporters, investigators or concerned citizens can use a pubmail.io address to simply maintain public communication with a public official.
I wrote up an 'about' page here, but it's a bit lofty: https://pubmail.io/about/
I'd love it if a politician could use it, but I don't think that's going to happen in the near future, so this gives the public a tool to foce more transparency without the politicians/reps themselves having to commit to it.
It basically means, "don't be a dick, don't harass, don't spam." I'm not a big fan of laws, but I am a big fan of common sense and decency, and that's all I want.
Regardless, changing the text of that checkbox to what you mean - "I promise to refrain from being a jerk, harassing people, or spamming" - would make the question moot.
I disagree. I believe it would create for easier access to a public stream of email communication, in particular to the person who sent the email. Sure, there's an easy way to get a notification when one gets an email, but how about replying to it? If one could reply to the email from the notification email (and see the contents of the email), that would be going towards a better solution (in my opinion). But even better would be POP, SMTP, and IMAP support, for the easiest way of getting emails, checking them, sending them, replying to them, etc.
POP, SMTP, and IMAP would not remove the web access and the public viewing of all emails, it would extend what has already been created.
You can use a pubmail email address to sign up for pubmail, then check the public pubmail account to verify it.
(Or you could use Mailinator for the same purpose)
I recommend adding a signature feature. If I were to use this service, I'd want to add a signature to the effect that all emails to and from the account are publicly accessible.
Also, I recommend adding a way to read through a specific account's emails (nevermind, they have that) and a way to search through all email.
The signature issue is interesting. On one hand, the point isn't to 'trick' people and it should be transparent, on the other hand, putting that "up front" may negatively impact response rates. However, I think you're right that it should be the user's option.
Have you gotten any corporate accounts or politicians signed up you want to share with us?
That being said, I'd love if it political/corporate users had their own accounts, but I don't think that will ever happen. It's more about doing the opposite - having ordinary people post their communications with political/corporate officials to the public by default.
I love this. Thank you!
It wouldn't be that hard to add a 1x1 invisible pixel in the message footer and see how well it works.
Interesting.. maybe this is do-able after all.. /mail/{{mail_id}}/{{open_tracker_id}}.gif
What’s your stack? It spoke Polish to me on your login page because of my IP :)
I'll F/OSS this whole project soon enough, but I need to fix a few bugs first.. https://pubmail.io/mail/thread/20150517210222.16302.49561/we...
For example a politician might well reply with information that is not intended for general circulation (private information etc).
Oh jesus.. fixed..
I guess that it might make you liable if you get a "confidentiality required/don't read if it's not sent to you" sort of emails?
I actually looked into that, and basically that's just a cargo-cult pseudo-legalese things that people do, they aren't legally binding in any way.
There is a 'tag' feature: https://pubmail.io/mail/tag/police/
Do you think it would be useful to be able to 'follow' users?