News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by Animats on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @02:07PM (#9571975)
To support containers, is Linux necessary? Would it be sufficient to run Xen under a container loading system? That would simplify things enormously. Server farms need very few drivers. They don't need a command line environment, daemons, development tools, etc. Those are all elsewhere.

Administration tools don't run on the target platform any more. They're either devoted to creating containers or managing container instances on the farm of target machines. The server side could get much simpler.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by pjmlp on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @03:27PM (#9572504)
It is the revenge of the mainframes and micro-kernels.

Also a return back to the days where the language runtimes were the OS.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by agumonkey on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @08:57PM (#9574082)
I love how layer shape-shifts up and down like this.

Maybe I'm off but it reminds me of 'the unix programming environment', it was a programming system, binary processes as functional primitives, PATH and environment for late binding, files as memory and communication mean.

"The language of the system" to quote clojure author.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by pjmlp on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @01:43AM (#9574841)
I feel more that way in regard towards the Xerox PARC systems, but I get your point.
Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by stephengillie on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @03:31PM (#9572530)
I know the Container world is full of idealistic developers who are busily waxing poetic about the benefits of portability and interoperability. But a Containerized app must still look to the OS for its DLLs and other underlying code.

To which end it looks like a Linux OS is required to run Apache containers, and a Windows OS would be required to run a .NET web app. Or we can run cross-OS binaries, aka WINE & Cygwin.

These files have to be somewhere. Unless we're baking them into the Container, at which point it's not much different than a VM.

Administration tools haven't been tied to the target platform for decades. A great many green administrators still connect directly to the platform to administer, but the tools to do the work from your own system have existed on almost every platform for a very long time.

Server farms need about 1 driver per microprocessor in each server's chassis. But this isn't about drivers, it's about not having to think about the part of the system you don't want to care about, to reduce your cognitive load.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by Animats on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @03:36PM (#9572570)
"Unless we're baking them into the Container, at which point it's not much different than a VM."

A little more than a VM, but not much more. A file system (which might be on another machine) and a connection to a network interface are all that are necessary. .dll and .so files are part of the application, not part of the OS. Besides, static linking is making a comeback; Go and Rust are usually statically linked.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by nulltype on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @04:09PM (#9572781)
A docker container is basically statically linking your binary one level higher. Rather than just including the libraries, you include all the support files and other processes. A VM is then like the next level above that.
Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by forgottenpass on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @03:34PM (#9572552)
To support containers, is Linux necessary?

Nope, it's just software. With enough money, you can do whatever you want. Linux isn't necessary, nothing really is, but it's a very practical choice. The shorter path is to strip down linux as much as possible and then diverge from traditional use, rather than build something entirely new from scratch. Plus you have a rich environment from the get go, and can share platform advances back and forth with ease.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by Animats on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @03:42PM (#9572600)
"share platform advances back and forth with ease."

Which means "do system administration". The advantage of not having much machinery underneath is that it reduces the need to change it. It also reduces the attack surface for security holes.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by forgottenpass on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @03:56PM (#9572689)
Which means "do system administration".

Not really, to me I mean code reuse. The article is CoreOS, so lets look at that context. Right now if a performance bottleneck is fixed in the network subsystem of the linux kernel, CoreOS feels that benefit. But micro-kernel-deisnged-for-running-containers-on-top-of-Xen-OS won't share that benefit. Of course one could argue that MK-X-OS doesn't have the bottleneck in the first place, and maybe it doesn't, that's not my point. I'm saying it's duplicated effort.

I don't know what you're on about with too much machinery underneath, I'm not saying to keep libfoo and interactive logins around if you don't need them. Just that nobody has to reinvent the libbar wheel.

Re:CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet by nulltype on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @03:00PM (#9572318)
I imagine that if OSv becomes popular it will look like that.