Re:A400M Airbus Flier crashed because of software issues
by lambdaelite on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @01:36PM
(#9571758)
Not sure if I'm understanding your question correctly, but Wind River claims their Diab compiler is validated by TÜV NORD and is has been used for stuff up to SIL4.
In fact, they (http://windriver.com/products/product-overviews/PO_Diab_Comp...) say:
Diab Compiler has been a reliable code generation tool for
avionics products certified for DO-178B, products for the
nuclear market certified to IEC 60880, railway applications
certified to EN 50128, and industrial products certified
to IEC 61508, and is now qualified for use in automotive
applications certified to ISO 26262.
Ada does have some built-in advantages, but I think my point still stands: the language is a small part of the entire SDLC, and I don't think it's the most important part.
Re:A400M Airbus Flier crashed because of software issues
by castell on Wednesday May 20, 2015 @08:14AM
(#9575772)
Is TÜV Nord/Sued known for extensive software checking?
Re:A400M Airbus Flier crashed because of software issues
by CHY872 on Tuesday May 19, 2015 @04:06PM
(#9572759)
Are you sure that Ada compilers are verified correct?
I'm pretty sure that the only industrial formally verified compiler is CompCert (for C), though I could be wrong. The motivation for CompCert was certainly that Airbus wanted such a compiler.
Ada wouldn't be a better choice simply because it's designed for security. It'd be a better choice if it turned out better in practice. I've read some of the studies that have been done, and I haven't found them convincing.
Requiring additional tools just isn't a problem, if it works well. Don't criticise the process, criticise the result.
AFAIK (partial) assurance in C/C++ can only be handled by additional testing tools, Frama-C for instance.
I agree that C/C++ should not be used for security applications. Ada is a much better choice because it was designed for security.