When I worked at Company X, one of our competitors was failing and offered us to buy them out. The most expensive part of the buyout was calculated basically by #users*<some price>. And really that's all we wanted, was their userbase, since we already had the product they wanted. We could absorb their users and immediately grow our business.
You end up in a situation where you have a few huge companies that have shitty expensive products and huge amounts of money. If anyone ever does better, they use some of the money to acquire the customers. No one ends up with something better or more cost effective; the 800lb gorilla just pays a tax to remain the only choice, and that cost is easily passed right back to the customers.
I actually think the "free market" works pretty well at this, even if it's not perfect. Nothing is.
Yet another case whereby a natural consequence of a free market is "bad" for the free market.
In reality it's only bad for the consumer, and certainly not the businesses.
vs
Amazon buying Newegg and rerouting the Newegg website backend through its own network.
NewEgg selling customer data to Amazon, AND EBay, AND LinkedIn, AND Joe Schmoe's Tech Emporium. Each have their own data sharing policies.
vs.
NewEgg selling the entire business and assets to Amazon (and only Amazon). In this case, everything; hardware, product stock, servers, and data too.
In the end, Amazon would end up with the consumers data, so to the consumer there is no difference. Are you saying that there is a difference? That's what I wanted clarification on, what that difference was.
In the example, Amazon can do whatever it wants with the data.
Data submitted to almost anyone online (maybe with the exception of large companies or companies specifically designed to not track data) should be considered public unfortunately.
I have seen some states recently put in place laws to protect this data from being made public or sold carelessly, but for the most part it is unregulated as far as I can tell.
The fact that your data isn't protected can't be used as an argument that it shouldn't be. Just because something is legal doesn't make it right, either.
I'm not claiming privacy policies are legally binding, just that they can be an indicator of trustworthiness and integrity. That's what I really meant when I said "[Option #1] would breach customer expectations because they are outright lying."
The way I read mc32's "I think there's a difference" is moral difference, because I share the same sentiment as him or her ("I hope the FTC wins its case...") which would turn that moral difference into a legally binding one.
TRUSTe was suppose to do something similar, but it's seal doesn't mean much anymore (not that it ever really did). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TRUSTe
Medical records, children's data, and sensitive financial data is protected under US law. US-EU Safe Harbor has some consumer data protection rules.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personally_identifiable_informa...
Think of it like software, your data is not the property of Facebook, but rather, they have a license to use it.
> For content that is covered by intellectual property rights, like photos and videos (IP content), you [...] grant us a non-exclusive, transferable, sub-licensable, royalty-free, worldwide license to use any IP content that you post on or in connection with Facebook (IP License).
There would be a difference if the license is non-transferable. Then Facebook wouldn't be able to give or sell that data to 3rd parties as part of a bankruptcy sale.
Edit: in the case of RadioShack's user data, I doubt that they got customers' agreement for a transferable license to the data.
No, "you" generally do not effectively retain the right to license your data collected by a third party out to other entities, because (as far as I know) there are no laws which require that third party to provide you with the data they've collected.
Examples here would be 23andMe vs. Fitbit.
23andMe is in the business of collecting data from you (in essence), then providing it to you and using it for their own purposes.
Fitbit is in the business of collecting data from you, then processing it and performing a number of black box calculations, then providing you summarized results. (Caveat: yes, I am aware that most activity trackers have API / export functionality. However, in all the instances I looked at that's limited and generally crap compared to the raw take the main party has access to)
I bet this had nothing to do with user data, but with user acquisition cost.
if company spends $10 on marketing and $15 on R&D per new user every quarter, then paying #users$10 when buying a dying competitor is a bargain.
Now, suppose the purchasing company isn't buying the entire business, but (say) half of it? What's changed? (This is roughly what is being proposed here)
There is no gray area here.
The issue here is whether RadioShack may sell the consumer data when its privacy policy said it would never do so.
Whatever the result of this case, it won't apply where the privacy policy permits transfer in bankruptcy (as most now do).
This is a beautiful slogan. I think that it is far from something by which that businesses will ever abide, or laws will ever try to force them to abide, but I would love to live in a world in which it was true.
How would you sell one company to another? There isn't much difference between a company being sold because it's being acquired and a company's assets being sold because it's bankrupt and needs to pay creditors.
Consumer data should be one of those things which most companies consider something toxic but necessary so they handle it with care and use the least amount possible rather than collect as much as possible and worry about things later.
RadioShack may not have the reams of data an ISP has, but still need a precedent for future data handling and ownership resolution. It'd be great to see this kind of data devolve back to the consumer, i.e. destroyed, once its original user is no longer there to use it in support of ongoing business operations and should not be a mainline of business per se.