Demographic Consequences of Defeating Aging: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3192186/
Too many people? No, too many Malthusians: http://www.spiked-online.com/newsite/article/7723
Superlongevity Without Overpopulation: https://books.google.com/books?id=EakLzDV-xJ0C&pg=PA169&lpg=...
The Eternal Return of Overpopulation: http://reason.com/archives/2010/10/19/the-eternal-return-of-...
If everyone stopped dying, there's a very real prospect of this occurring. Unchecked, it results in the population equivalent of compound interest: when combined with our current population growth rate of 1.1%, we end up with a projected population in 100 years to over 46 billion.
Even Japan, with their currently negative growth rate of -.14%, would experience sudden and staggering (for them) population growth rate of upwards of .6%.
To address the Malthusian argument: could we alter our behaviors to reduce the birth rate to mitigate the population growth caused by "slaying the dragon"? Definitely.
Could we potentially find a way to support humanity's exponentially growing energy and dietary needs sustainably? For a little while (there are hard limits[1] to how much more energy we can create while limited to the Earth).
Could we convince everyone to cope with an even higher population density? That one's harder.
The real problem is that most of these hurdles aren't technological. They're sociological - a place where we have historically advanced much more slowly; the eradication of death worldwide couldn't tolerate slowness. China's current condition is a great example of how hard it is to impose checks on population growth.
All that said, there's an even more fundamental question: could we find a way to prevent an asteroid from hitting earth and wiping out all benefits of "slaying the dragon"? Unless something major changes, no, we could not. In my opinion, this is more important than creating any form of superlongevity. It's the difference between the continuation of humanity and our extinction.
The Earth has a ticking clock, and we don't know the position of the hands. What will we do with the time we have?
[1] http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/07/galactic-scale-e...
Ultimately, for humanity to survive this planet, we will need to expand. Even with all Malthusian predictions aside, humanity's existence is up against a ticking clock whose hands we can't even see.
However, if we eliminate "old and infirm" as a Very Large social category by making our species effectively immortal and perpetually healthy, then our efficiency as a species goes way, way up.
Older people feel better. Our species becomes stronger and more capable. We get to colonize other planets sooner. Everybody wins.
Would you have argued that absent provocation the Allied powers should have done nothing to stop Nazi persecution of Jews, Gypsies, and homosexuals because (and this was true) no nation was willing to take in the refugees? No. Priority #1 is stopping the ongoing slaughter of 100,000 people _per day_.
6.2 million doesn't seem like much (a little less than creating and populating a New New York City), but I believe it's fair to say that the number of children which are produced won't change too much (barring outside forces), resulting in the population equivalent of compound interest.
In 100 years, this means the planet will be supporting (somewhow) more than 17 billion people.
Urbanization, good retirement systems, voluntary birth control, education and economic opportunities for women, and lower child mortality are all proven ways of lowering birth rates. Many developed nations hare having children well under replacement rates.
Watching the first half of torchwood "Miracle Day" was both enlightening and frightening in that regard.
That's the real problem we need to solve first