News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Plot Against Trains by mindcrime on Friday May 15, 2015 @04:04PM (#9553291)
High-speed trains have the potential to dramatically shrink distances between major hubs, giving people an alternative to aviation for their mid-range transportation needs, and could allow people to live in more affordable neighborhoods without an unbelievably long commute.

No question. Like I said, I'm pro-train. I just don't think that subsidizing trains is a proper role for government. If there is enough market demand to fund and support trains (or Interstate highways, or the Post Office, or whatever) then more power to them. If not, I don't believe in propping them up through taxpayer funded subsidies.

Re:The Plot Against Trains by dragonwriter on Friday May 15, 2015 @04:08PM (#9553328)
> Like I said, I'm pro-train. I just don't think that subsidizing trains is a proper role for government. If there is enough market demand to fund and support trains (or Interstate highways, or the Post Office, or whatever) then more power to them. If not, I don't believe in propping them up through taxpayer funded subsidies.

One idea behind taxpayer subsidies for these things is that they have external benefits (either directly, or in that they have less externalized costs than alternatives). With trains, particularly, the argument is that they have less externalized costs than other forms of transit.

(Of course, you could address this by imposing taxes on the more-externally-costly alternatives, but that's equivalent to subsidy to the alternative with less external costs, so it amounts to the same thing.)