I am currently of the opinion that major logistical infrastructure can't feasibly be done by any non-governmental entity since such company can't force land acquisition and usage approval by their own fiat. A company could propose a project to legislators, but would have to invest significantly before that stage with no guarantee of return. If a company could feasibly be granted such power plenipotentiarily, it would be a huge bill of rights issue (that eminent domain is controversial is another discussion). Other than government, I don't see a feasible solution here.
I never said it would be easy.
If we can eliminate government, we can eliminate the people's protection racket. This will allow private companies to flourish, and the weak to be eliminated.
I find it amusing that you would cite that example as an argument FOR government, as I think it stands as a classic example of the worst of what government enables.
Every company that exists as separate juridical entity (e.g., every corporation, for starters) does so with the explicit sanction of a government and is an exercise of government power.
The East India Company was a private company in exactly the same sense as any other "private" corporation.
That's just being pedantic. It was a "private company" yes, but a private company that was granted powers far beyond those given to pretty much any other private company. They were allowed to maintain their own private army and effectively rule large parts of India as though they were the government. That's a HUGE difference from the typical private company.
It seems like you didn't think your cunning plan all the way through, because you seem to be implying that you need more government regulation on what private corporations can do, correct?
Or are you saying that, without government regulation, the East India company wouldn't have formed their own private army?
Do you think private armed militias, that are legal today in the US, be allowed to exist?
You're going to have to reconcile your position of "less government" with "leads to more private armies".
Can you give me a plausible scenario for how, without a government and its concomitant military power, a band of people from a small island in the Atlantic ocean could take over the entire Indian subcontinent?
Specifics, please.
Most likely. Of course it's all hypotheticals, but since we - for the most part - define government as that entity which has (mostly) a monopoly on the use of force, a private company would not generally be considered empowered to do that without the sanction of a government.
Or are you saying that, without government regulation, the East India company wouldn't have formed their own private army?
Correct.
Do you think private armed militias, that are legal today in the US, be allowed to exist?
Of course they can exist. Now, of course, we're at the bottom of the stack, so to speak. What if one of these private militias "goes rogue" and commits unspeakable atrocities? Who's to stop that, right? And I guess your answer would be "the government"? I'd argue that the answer is "some other voluntarily assembled mutual defense entity, or no one". Anyway, all we've really shown here is that if you drill down deep enough, human conflict is inevitable and at some level we may never get away from "force vs force". But I argue against institutionalizing the idea of using force to compel people to do things, and keep the use of force reserved for self defense.
You're going to have to reconcile your position of "less government" with "leads to more private armies".
I'm not opposed to private armies in general. I'm opposed to private armies, operating with the sanction of the State, and essentially becoming one more arm of the government, and being used to violate people's rights. Or, you could even omit the "with the sanction of the State" bit, and the rest would still stand. The problem is, when we accept the presence and authority of something like a State, and then it endorses or sanctions "evil" (for lack of a better term) acts, it's that much harder to muster opposition to those acts, since they're nominally "legal".
>Correct.
This is why libertinism is often relegated to that of a sweet, innocent 12 year old idealists, because they do not know about the real world.
In the real world, what happens without government is that warlords form. This happens throughout history, such as colonial expansion into indian territory, or after the collapse of the Soviet Union, etc. And it's happening RIGHT NOW in places like Iraq, Afghanistan, and Sudan.
You don't need a state to sanction violence for violence to happen. Violence will happen when there isn't a state to sanction it.
This is why the correct solution that adults agree on is a strong, centralized government with power. The whole point of a strong, centralized powerful government is to limit the rights and freedoms of individuals, so people AREN'T allowed to do what they want.
Because, when people are allowed to do what they want, they form violent armies. Government limits peoples rights and freedoms to do that.
To stop this, you need a) a strong, powerful government, and b) that government to say "no violence."
Government is the social contract you offer to other people. And only though a social contract can you prevent violence.
That's what you get with your "strong, powerful, centralized government".
If there's ever been a government that actually said "no violence" and followed through on it, I haven't heard of it.
Can you name a few?
Which system is better? A libertarian warlord system? Or the US government?
What exactly makes a warlord system more favorable than the US government?
If you want an example of a government, you don't need to bring up Stalin's Russia or Nazi Germany.. you have an example of government right here in the US!
Clearly you thought through your cunning "less government" libertarian plan, and have concluded that such a system, which results in warlords, would be better than the US government, right? Let's hear that rationale then.
You're pretending that the only options are no central government at all, on the one hand, and an all-powerful central government on the other.
That's not actually the case.
And please drop the silly "cunning plan" business, this is Hacker News, not reddit.
50 years ago that railroad was private. Freight rail today in the USA is privately owned and doing really well.
I would fully support all interstate highways being private toll roads, but I don't think highways and rail travel are comparable any more than highways and air travel is. And airlines are privately owned (though heavily regulated).
Believe it or not, this was known 5 years ago -- you can find it on old documentaries, where they talk about it with conviction this was the future of transportation. The problem is simply the early investment. The tech is here.
With our current pace of innovation, a pharaonic transportation project with recoup costs on the order of a century is hard to justify. The need to physically displace yourself is changing rapidly with the internet, and who knows what we'll need in 100 years!
It's been known for a lot longer than that. Larry Niven had them in his novel A World Out of Time (1976) and I think Heinlein had them in some of his novels from the 1960s.
I suspect the concept predates those novels.
Now you can have some routes (such as the Buffalo to NYC one that you mentioned), but again if it is paid for federally, then unless there are similar situations that the majority of the country could take advantage of, it doesn't make sense.
This is specious. It's the whole Bastiat "That which is seen and unseen" problem of economic manipulation. You don't know what would have happened if trillions in resources hadn't been diverted. I find it very easy to argue things would be better if Ike had never taken over the highway system and federally subsidized it. We've wasted massive amounts of public resources spreading thinly used infrastructure out all over the land and it's been largely enabled by the interstate system. Also consider the absurd highway fatility/injury rate in America and how much that costs.
No question. Like I said, I'm pro-train. I just don't think that subsidizing trains is a proper role for government. If there is enough market demand to fund and support trains (or Interstate highways, or the Post Office, or whatever) then more power to them. If not, I don't believe in propping them up through taxpayer funded subsidies.
One idea behind taxpayer subsidies for these things is that they have external benefits (either directly, or in that they have less externalized costs than alternatives). With trains, particularly, the argument is that they have less externalized costs than other forms of transit.
(Of course, you could address this by imposing taxes on the more-externally-costly alternatives, but that's equivalent to subsidy to the alternative with less external costs, so it amounts to the same thing.)
Can you imagine the US without the Interstate? That's the sort of opportunity you're missing out on here.
The subsidy the government has given American businesses a huge competitive advantage, you can ship almost anything cross-continent within a few days. This has enabled companies like UPS to exist.
High-speed trains have the potential to dramatically shrink distances between major hubs, giving people an alternative to aviation for their mid-range transportation needs, and could allow people to live in more affordable neighborhoods without an unbelievably long commute.
There are people that live in northern France and commute to London and it takes them about an hour. Meanwhile getting from Buffalo to New York City takes a full day.