News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by raverbashing on Thursday May 14, 2015 @10:24AM (#9545305)
So, this is the so-called "intelligent design"?

I think not.

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by lotharbot on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:59AM (#9545875)
Sitting on my desk right now is a long-handled object with a heavy mass at one end, just like a hammer. But the heavy mass pivots in relation to the handle, the handle is ergonomically crafted in the opposite direction from a hammer, and it's covered in buttons. If you try to evaluate the design as a hammer, it's obviously a terrible design -- but it's a pretty good joystick (good enough for me to use, as the 12th best Descent pilot of all time [0].)

What can we say about a designer from just looking at their design? Not much, if we don't understand what their design is for. If we're guessing at intent or guessing at design constraints, there's very little useful we can say, pro or con.

[0] remember Descent? You can still play: http://descentchampions.org/new_player.php

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by raverbashing on Thursday May 14, 2015 @01:44PM (#9546432)
Since the subject is the human body, Descent was great, but it caused me major "motion sickness" (not sure what's the correct term)
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by lotharbot on Thursday May 14, 2015 @04:22PM (#9547352)
> "motion sickness"

That's the correct term. It's also called "kinetosis" -- it's basically when your eyes and the rest of your body disagree about the way you're moving, and your brain freaks out. (Going back to the "design" question -- we don't know why the brain freaks out, or whether there's a benefit to it, so it's hard to evaluate whether it's actually a good system or not.)

Some people have reported significant improvement by playing with higher resolution, a wider field of view, different textures, or (with VR devices like the Oculus Rift) some sort of persistent viewpoint (like a fake nose).

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by scarmig on Thursday May 14, 2015 @10:41AM (#9545411)
Just to play devil's advocate...

It almost certainly is intelligent design, because it's intelligent given certain constraints (the existing gene pool in a given generation, and the fact that something working is better than something theoretically better but doesn't actually exist). God iterates using an Agile process.

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by posnet on Thursday May 14, 2015 @10:45AM (#9545441)
Backlog:

Epic - Improve test coverage

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by boie0025 on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:43AM (#9545788)
Yes, one gigantic integration test (Live/Die) is unhelpful and makes it very difficult to pinpoint problems. Looking for something beyond "it compiles".
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by ForHackernews on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:52AM (#9545838)
All evidence suggests God is an adherent of the Worse is Better design philosophy.
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by cristianpascu on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:57AM (#9545867)
Like someone playing a piano concerto with 10 fingers. That's such a terrible design. Dawkins would have made the humans with 12 fingers.
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by turar on Thursday May 14, 2015 @03:17PM (#9547009)
Resulting in 12 Commandments instead of 10, and base-12 numeral system? :)
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by cristianpascu on Thursday May 14, 2015 @05:15PM (#9547619)
That sounds about right! :) And 16 apostles.
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by raverbashing on Thursday May 14, 2015 @10:46AM (#9545443)
and loads of technical debt, apparently!
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by swsieber on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:14AM (#9545614)
I don't know that you can even call this a counter argument to all intelligent design schemes: Christians believe that Adam and Eve live in the garden and were cursed for eating the forbidden fruit. That would make the poor parts the result of transgression and not design (most likely). So they might view it as "corrupted intelligent design"? Unclear.

I'm not too up on all the arguments surrounding intelligent design, I think the biggest issue is that there's no good way to prove / disprove it? In that regard this doesn't really contribute that much then.

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by ceejayoz on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:46AM (#9545802)
The major argument of intelligent design is that everything's so perfectly designed it couldn't have happened by chance. Permitting corruption of that design pretty much eviscerates that primary argument.
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by SilasX on Thursday May 14, 2015 @10:33AM (#9545354)
I'm glad you bring that up, because these are the kinds of things you should cite to refute someone claiming that biological life bears the signs of an intelligent designer, supernatural or otherwise. What distinguishes intelligent from naive optimization is the ability to refactor instead of just making local improvements.

Unfortunately, there seems to be a trend toward refuting IDers by claiming that the very prospect of discerning intelligent from unintelligent signals is "unscientific", which is so wrong that it can only survive by groupthink. E.g. How do you even know it's a voice on the other end of the phone rather than static? How do you know the marks on paper are words rather than accidents?

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by cristianpascu on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:52AM (#9545841)
I believe you're wrong. Take german and french cars. One of them, won't say which, are better designed than the others. To say that a plan is NOT designed because it's flawed is like calling names on a programmer because he uses Java.

You don't refute ID by showing some sub-optimal function in an animal body plan, firstly because ID doesn't claim everything is optimal. ID implies intentionality, but does not and can not explicit intentions. Anyone can make an object that by all means can not be the product of a natural phenomena, and still someone else being able to tell it's design, could not really tell the purpose of it. And, of course, if function is obvious, there's also a better solution.

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by SilasX on Thursday May 14, 2015 @12:33PM (#9546044)
>I believe you're wrong. Take german and french cars. One of them, won't say which, are better designed than the others. To say that a plan is NOT designed because it's flawed

Which is why that wasn't the argument. Both French and German cars have evidence of design (non-local improvements over earlier transportation), and both clear and garbled speech through a telephone have evidence of an intelligent agent behind them. In no case did I suggest making the inference that flaw -> not design. Rather, it's "being constrained to one domain of attraction in designspace" that indicates lack of intelligence behind the optimization.

>You don't refute ID by showing some sub-optimal function in an animal body plan, firstly because ID doesn't claim everything is optimal. ID implies intentionality, but does not and can not explicit intentions.

Specific variants of ID claim certain intentions, and the lack of intelligent optimization would refute intelligence being behind that intention. (To the extent that this intention is deliberately vague and kept from having observable implications, it can be rejected as non-scientific on that basis, without having to assert the claim, which I was criticizing, that the whole enterprise is unscientific.)

>Anyone can make an object that by all means can not be the product of a natural phenomena, and still someone else being able to tell it's design, could not really tell the purpose of it.

That just means inferences here (as everywhere else) are imperfect, not that detection of intelligence is impossible or unscientific. You can't know to 100% certainty whether the sound on the telephone is someone speaking to you or just a random coincidence of static, but that doesn't mean you throw up your hands, remain agnostic, and lambaste the ignoramuses who dare to claim they have heuristics for speech recognition.

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by cristianpascu on Thursday May 14, 2015 @05:19PM (#9547637)
There's a little difference between the amount of information in a noisy AT&T iPhone model 1 conversation and a functioning brain. Just sayin'.
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by iolaknfd89 on Thursday May 14, 2015 @12:59PM (#9546166)
The implication of a very sub-optimal design is that the "intelligent" designer is a C- student who probably shouldn't have gotten their degree.
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by mikeash on Thursday May 14, 2015 @10:56AM (#9545505)
The "unscientific" argument is used because the "we are horribly designed" argument has been done over and over again and ID proponents just dodge it with nonsense about how it's all due to The Fall of Man or whatever.

It's not like they don't know about these problems, or nobody ever told them. They just don't think it disproves their ideas. They're offering an alternative explanation that matches the data, but provides no predictive power. You can't refute that with data, because anything that fails to match results in an alteration of the explanation to match it. All you can do is point out that an explanation with no predictive power is useless.

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by cristianpascu on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:55AM (#9545857)
Darwinism is also full of "x happend differently than previously thought". Any theory is allowed an must adapt to new data. It's not like you're explaning a dozen of particles to which you add a new one every two decades or so. The domain of the theory shapes the theory.
Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by mikeash on Thursday May 14, 2015 @12:40PM (#9546079)
Yes, scientific theories also adapt to new information. However, there's a substantial difference between this and what ID proponents engage in. The evolution (pun intended) of scientific theories involves saying "that was wrong before, here's what we think now" and the newly adapted theory is criticized and tested. Any scientific theory is falsifiable; even if not actually falsified, there's always some test that could, if it produced the appropriate results, disprove the theory.

Intelligent Design is just the God of the Gaps dressed up in scientific-sounding language. It collects the unanswered questions in biology and says, "We do not know how this happened, therefore an intelligence was involved." And of course if you dig deeply enough, "an intelligence" is almost always Yahweh, father of Jesus Christ, although they often try to keep that quiet in order to appear more objective.

There are two basic categories of contradictory facts for ID: there are things like the flaws we're talking about here, which say "this could not be intelligence" and there are direct attacks on the gaps, where unexplained things like the emergence of "irreducibly complex" features are explained naturalistically. Intelligent Design deals with both easily. The former can be dismissed by just saying that the intelligence wasn't involved in that particular bit. Or it can just be ignored, which seems to be the standard reaction. Any resource that discusses evolution will discuss unanswered questions and problems with the theory. Resources for intelligent design, as far as I can find, also discuss unanswered questions and problems with evolution but make no mention of any potential problems with ID. The latter can be dismissed by just moving on and continuing to object to other gaps. Or, as often happens, it can be dismissed by labeling the scientist as an anti-religious bigot.

There is literally no imaginable discovery that could overturn intelligent design. There are many imaginable discoveries that could overturn evolution. That's fundamentally what makes the latter scientific and the former not.

Re:Top Design Flaws in the Human Body: Our bodies are full o... by wolfhumble on Thursday May 14, 2015 @12:14PM (#9545944)
Who has said that planned obsolescence is not involved? Genesis 6:3 talks e.g. of a 120 year life span.