Re:The Way We Look at Technical Debt Is Wrong
by amelius on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @03:47PM
(#9541493)
But a good programmer always sees a number of solutions to a particular problem. Let's say he sees 10 solutions. Solution 1 costs an hour to implement, but gives crappy code and he knows it. Solution 9 gives good quality code, but takes a week to implement, and he then has to sell this to his boss.
And then there's solution number 10, which requires the programmer to invent a new programming language, and requires at least a couple of months to develop. "You hired the best possible person for this job, so let me do the best possible job".
I just bet most people here wished they could always deliver the best possible code.
Re:The Way We Look at Technical Debt Is Wrong
by crdoconnor on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @04:04PM
(#9541596)
>But a good programmer always sees a number of solutions to a particular problem. Let's say he sees 10 solutions. Solution 1 costs an hour to implement, but gives crappy code and he knows it. Solution 9 gives good quality code, but takes a week to implement, and he then has to sell this to his boss.
A good programmer will try and improve code the code incrementally, and won't bother trying to sell anything.
Re:The Way We Look at Technical Debt Is Wrong
by jaggederest on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @04:00PM
(#9541574)
I think what you hear me saying is "never do anything less than perfect work". I'm saying "given your current constraints, don't choose a worse option when a better one is available". Those constraints include time, your skills and beliefs, the environment you work in, the project you're working on, and the problem you're trying to solve.
That said, I'm not implying that you should slow down, just do the best possible work at all times. Don't do a crappy job just because you're time-limited - we all only have 24 hours a day, and there's always more work than can reasonably fit in. The moment you start going "I am going to lower my standards right now", you've started a trend.
I think it's interesting that people are always saying "hire the best possible people you can", and then saying "but don't ask them to do the best possible work they can do".