News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by chasing on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:52PM (#9540693)
Dear Microsoft,

Windows 10.

Just release Windows 10.

No one knows the difference between Windows 10 Pro and Windows 10 Enterprise and Windows 10 Extreme and Windows 10 Cool Ranch Doritos Locos Supreme. Your customers actually don't care.

And as long as you keep selling a baffling array of variations on the same product, no one will believe you've turned over a new leaf.

Windows 10.

With love,

Guy on the Internet

PS: There should be no "it's even more secure" version. They should all be "even more secure."

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by dsg42 on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:19PM (#9540923)
This is information for IT people, and you're treating it like it's for consumers. Consumers will only ever know about Windows 10 Home. The other options are important because:

Windows 10 Enterprise costs roughly ten times as much.

Windows 10 Education is the discounted version that they sell to schools (Apple has a similar program, they just don't tell you about it.)

Windows 10 Mobile because, well...

Windows 10 Mobile Enterprise because, again, they want to make money.

Windows is one of the top 5 most profitable software products in the world. Trust that they know how to make money.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by bhauer on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:34PM (#9541024)
You might be right, but does Windows 10 Pro include any features that have previously been exclusive to Windows 8/8.1 Pro, such as Bitlocker and Remote Desktop? The wording of the blog post is intentionally obfuscated to not name the technologies that are added to Windows 10 Pro, but I think it's clear they are keeping Bitlocker and Remote Desktop exclusive to the Pro edition from the following:

> Windows 10 Pro helps to effectively and efficiently manage their devices and apps, protect their sensitive business data, support remote and mobile productivity scenarios...

I use Bitlocker and frequently remote from any of my Windows PCs to any of the others. So I have Windows 8.1 Pro installed on (nearly) all of them, at non-trivial cost to me.

I agree with the grandparent that for any home user, there should be one edition, and that one edition should include Bitlocker and Remote Desktop. And any other feature that home enthusiasts and evangelists are likely to want. Microsoft desperately needs to stop punishing its evangelists. Evangelists should be courted and treated well.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by pXMzR2A on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @05:05PM (#9541976)
> Windows is one of the top 5 most profitable software products in the world. Trust that they know how to make money.

Monopolization of the markets. I do trust it, but only when I do it. ;)

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by drrotmos on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:34PM (#9541027)
I'm fairly sure many consumers will know about Windows 10 Pro though.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by adamkochanowicz on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:37PM (#9541046)
Beautifully put.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by blumkvist on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:05PM (#9540800)
Making money.

You don't know how to.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by yathern on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:07PM (#9540823)
Actually, he has a point. Too many choices can harm sales significantly. Granted, in Microsoft's position, it's not as applicable.

https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/research-too-many-choi...

https://blog.kissmetrics.com/too-many-choices/

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by ZoFreX on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:45PM (#9541110)
There really aren't a lot of choices though. This isn't like Windows 7. If you're running Windows 10 at home you have two options: Home or Pro. That's it.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by sonnyz on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @03:41PM (#9541455)
You know that, but my mom wouldn't know that. To the average customer they may assume that the Home version is the only version applicable to them. The Pro version looks like it's marketed as a business only solution. Bottom line is that it's more confusing than it should be.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by ZoFreX on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @05:04PM (#9541967)
Your mom won't even hear about the education or enterprise editions. At most she'll hear about home, phone, and pro... and maybe not even the latter.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by blumkvist on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:10PM (#9540864)
Please, this is enterprise software we're talking about, sold almost exclusively through resellers, who are licensing experts and decide what the client needs. This is how you extract the most value.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by yathern on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:24PM (#9540949)
Yes, I realize this - which is why I said it's not as applicable for Microsoft's position.

That having been said, chasings point was more about how it would be wise for Microsoft to make their product line less intimidating for end-users - which would help sell the idea of their latest rebranding - and have benefit for them, and customers as well.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by cwyers on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:26PM (#9540964)
Microsoft makes almost no money off direct-to-end-user sales. It's all either OEM money or volume sales to enterprise/government/other institutions. Microsoft is not about to upend their entire market segmenting strategy just to make things less confusing for people who are at least one step removed from any of the people who actually give them money.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by Retric on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:33PM (#9541014)
As soon as Dell has a dropdown for nomal vs pro, microsoft is selling windows directly to customers.

And guess what, "Inspiron Small Desktopwith Windows 7 Professional". http://www.dell.com/us/p/desktops?~ck=mn#!facets=153558~0~87... Not that I think the average user knows if they want window 7 pro or windows 8.1 which is what most of the desktops on that page are.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by cwyers on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:50PM (#9541143)
> As soon as Dell has a dropdown for nomal vs pro, microsoft is selling windows directly to customers.

No, Dell is reselling Windows to the consumer.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by vetinari on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @03:08PM (#9541260)
It does not matter who is reselling what.

What matters is that the consumer has to choose between SKUs and that choice was created by MS.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by Retric on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @03:09PM (#9541267)
Resellers take on risks for unsold inventory; Dell does not take on risks for unsold copies of windows. They do take on those risks for other components. EX: Case screws.

PS: This does vary by sales channel. If you buy a dell from best buy they clearly already exist, but if you get a custom dell from their website they buld it after you order it.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by Retric on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @09:56PM (#9543073)
I really don't care about downvotes, but it does amuse me when people get pissy about being wrong.

PS: A reseller is a company or individual (merchant) that purchases goods or services with the intention of selling them rather than consuming or using them. This is usually done for profit (but could be resold at a loss). http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reseller

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by cwyers on Thursday May 14, 2015 @10:41AM (#9545414)
I didn't downvote you. I also don't see how that citation does anything but reinforce the original point -- Dell is buying Windows from Microsoft and reselling it. It's not even a retail product situation, like Best Buy -- Dell isn't selling Windows, it's selling computers that come with Windows. You can't buy the computer at your link without Windows, and you can't buy Windows without the computer through Dell.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by Retric on Thursday May 14, 2015 @11:49AM (#9545821)
Resellers are a specific economic niche. From a customer perspective CostCo and BestBuy are both just stores. However, BestBuy regularly returns unsold inventory to their suppliers where CostCo generally just has to keep lowering their prices or eat the costs.

Dell does not take unsold inventory risks with Windows so it's simply not their business model. Plenty of small PC manufactures do take this risk by buying windows 10 or 100 packs. But, if suddenly more customers want Home vs Pro edition of windows Dell does not end up with unsold inventory and get forced to offer a discount.

PS: The term Authorized Reseller often muddles the issue in people’s minds, but it’s really a different term. The App store is another great example, Apple does not buy a copy of the app before a customer does.

Edit: As to your comment about bundling. Dell does not manufacture their case screws, but they’re not a case screw reseller.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by blumkvist on Thursday May 14, 2015 @12:56PM (#9546151)
Dell is an OEM. How they chose to package their product is their business. More importantly their direct-to-consumer sales are a drop in the bucket. They use resellers too. When you go to Best Buy, nobody chooses their windows. The smiley guy shows you a few laptops based on what he thinks is best for you and you chose the one who looks the best. There are very specific rules about which windows versions go in which models and there are very specific rules about rebates. The rebates dictate what is getting sold to whom. It is such a sophisticated operation, with so much analysis behind it, that people generally don't understand it at all. I tried to hint that if you make such statements, you might not be qualified to talk about it, but apparently you are not willing to entertain this possibility at all. You think you are understand supply and demand better than the collective of thousands of people who run analysis that makes up this strategy, because you read article on a blog... Nothing more to add.
Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by Retric on Thursday May 14, 2015 @01:18PM (#9546267)
OEM != Reseller

Most stores != Reseller

Best buy is a store you can buy a prepackaged dell from. But, they are not a Dell reseller.

Again, Reseller is a term based around two sales for the same item which has specific legal meanings.

PS: Book stores are a classic example where they will destroy unsold inventory and ship the covers back. Clearly, if the book store had already purchased the book doing this would not result in a check from the publisher.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by blumkvist on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @04:36PM (#9541785)
It wouldn't be wise, because they will lose a truckload (several dozen truckloads) of money from doing so. MS doesn't make money from end users. MS licenses are resold. Either from OEM or ISV. Customers go to them and the reseller decides what they need. The reseller doesn't need simple licensing. The reseller has a floor of people whose only job is to know the licensing structures.

Why hire so many people to navigate the licensing? Because that's how you extract the maximum value (money) from the market. This is why I said chasing doesn't understand how money is made in such situations. He sees something and takes it at face value. "Derp-a-derp-a-derp, I'm a clueless consumer, don't overwhelm me with so many decisions... why Microsoft sucks so much at business?"

No, they don't suck at business. You do.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by chasing on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @05:06PM (#9541983)
I don't use their products, so they may not suck at business, but they suck at getting my business. And given how successful Apple has been at courting both consumers and professionals, I don't think it's at all ridiculous to argue that maybe Microsoft needs to tweak how they present their products to the world. Especially their most successful products.

Or I could use your logic:

Apple makes even more money and they only offer one version of Mac OS X. They don't suck at business. Microsoft does. QED.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by blumkvist on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @05:20PM (#9542056)
Apple sells mobile phones, Microsoft sells software, how can you compare them? Or are you arguing that Apple PCs are more successful than Windows PCs?

It is very funny that you think you made your point with this example when you actually did exactly the opposite. Apple almost went out of business when they competed with MSFT in the PC/OS business, exactly because of those pricing/reseller strategies that MSFT employs.

Re:Introducing Windows 10 Editions by amyjess on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @02:24PM (#9540953)
It could worse. We could have ended up with the mess Vista had.