* Students are forced to depart from the “answer-getting” mentality of mathematics.
* Students are forced to redefine success in learning as making sense and increasing depth of understanding.
* Students are able to work in a context in which failure is completely normal.
If your class tends toward revolt, they have been way too far strayed from the first point, and that may be the professors fault.
That's a huge problem when you've trying to teach them about proofs, and kicking them out of that mentality is the biggest challenge in first year under-grad. This idea of letting them work for a limited time on an unsolved problem seems a useful approach to changing their attitude.
Perhaps because they've been conditioned for 12 years to believe that this is what "math" is.
Students aren't usually taught subtraction is adding a negative number. Students aren't usually taught division is multiplying by a fraction. Students aren't usually taught that there are ways of counting outside of the decimal 'base 10' way of counting, or the advantages of counting in Octal, or how to count in Binary on your hands.
Math teachers love to say "2+2 does not always equal 4" but never explain that's only true in Base2-4 where the representation of "4" doesn't exist and it is represented as 100, 11, or 10.
So not only are we taught "there's always an answer". We're not taught other concepts and sometimes information is left out entirely until you reach a college level of mathematics - at which point all these lies, unexplained concepts, and "answer-seeking mentality" become a problem.
Learn, in my experience.
Getting people to leave a mere "answer getting" mindset and engage with the "technique and problem understanding" mindset is one of the most important parts of the job of teaching freshmen and sophomores (particularly in mathematics). They've often been rewarded for this approach in high school and have trouble letting it go -- but it really constrains the ability to understand things.
The really sad cases are the ones who are really good at it, good enough to survive all the way to grad school sometimes. They aren't doing themselves any favors, and invariably get left behind by people who may have less innate talent but engage more. Hopefully recoverably.
Thing is - it's not these kids' fault, once they do grok the notion of "not yet solved", they are great. It's that they spend the last 16 years being punished for getting something wrong, in a context where there is only a right answer or wrong answer, and that fact is known - even in subjective topics.
The focus on grades and "the right answer" instead of learning and thinking is probably why it can be so frustrating for both parties when someone fresh out of university comes to a (programming) job interview.
I've noticed a lot of attempts on freelancing sites to pay a contractor to complete homework and school assignments. I can't imagine a worse form of self-sabotage, and it seems like students have profoundly the wrong message about education.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8972744
(I don't know why you were so heavily downvoted. I upvoted you.)
That's the important part of this - the instructor didn't give it as homework. And yes, I've seen students freak out on their instructor en-masse for far less than a mission impossible homework assignment.
Yeah, that'd be embarrassing.
That's the context in which being thrown a heretofore unsolved problem in calculus is not particularly amusing for an undergraduate.
This was university maths, in that it was maths, and you were at university, but in terms of the syllabus it was pretty much later secondary school standard, and there was very little emphasis that I can recall on preparing people for further study of maths. So no proving anything. Just telling you how stuff worked, and then a zillion exercises for you to do to try to make it stick.
But SFU (a not so bad University in Canada), - Calculus 151 in Images theater, and Calculus 152. I recall the workload in those two courses very, very distinctly. Both first year courses. In hindsight, I think they served the purpose of filtering out students who weren't prepared to work hard...
I just want to make sure the undergraduate instructors reading this thread realize that doing this on the sly in a standard problem set would be a very, very bad idea. Not cool.
I don't see it!
Not being facetious or judgmental either. And there's strong pressure for calc profs these days to not assign more than 30 problems a week. Sensitivity about workload is very high at many institutions.
Some interviewers would present unsolved problems in interviews as well, if a candidate was happily eating their way through the regular material.
Cambridge is a little unusual in that the only mark that people cite is the one on the final year exam. I believe US universities operate by continuous accumulation of marks? And that ongoing disputes over marking are more common because of this?
It's also already working with a highly selected group of people from the far tail of the ability distribution, and looking for a way to identify the exceptional among the merely very high ability.
Yes.
and not told your students what you had done prior to them leaving for the day?
No. As the comment I responded to says: I
reveal the full truth after they have been working for fifteen minutes or so.
Any professor who handed out that assignment to an undergraduate class without fair warning, would likely face a full scale revolt, possible threats of violence, and almost certainly a significant portion of the class immediately dropping him.
[Edit - to be clear, I'm commending the instructor for not hanging their students out to dry by giving a mission impossible homework assignment]