News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by pierrefar on Friday November 20, 2009 @11:12AM (#952617)
When you're a skeptic looking for "evidence", you'll find plenty in there.

When you're a scientist looking for an informal discussion about thinking critically about the evidence and data interpretation, you'll also find plenty in there.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by izend on Friday November 20, 2009 @11:37AM (#952674)
However, the way Al Gore has presented Climate Change has not at all been like scientific discussion, it has been portrait as a topic where the discussion and debate is over. That is my problem with individual such as Al Gore because statements like this,

"Land warming since 1980 has been twice the ocean warming — and skeptics might claim that this proves that urban warming is real and important."

show me there is still room to discuss and debate the evidence.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tome on Friday November 20, 2009 @11:41AM (#952683)
There may be room for debate, but is there time for debate?

Is there a plausible case that we cannot afford to wait?

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by crystalis on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:14PM (#952774)
This is a reasonable question to ask.

If global warming is "wrong" but the accepted answer, pollution heavy businesses go through some inefficiencies and there's a smaller amount of pollution production.

If global warming is "right", but not accepted as something that requires response, potential existential crises ensue.

It seems like betting on a Jack-high hand with your life on the line.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by krschultz on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:28PM (#952806)
If global warming is "wrong" we needlessly reduce our economy and people today feel real hardships from lower wages, lost jobs, and higher prices.

If global warming is "right" we might have a problem 100 years from now with rising sea levels and different weather.

If you have the luxury to be worrying about rising sea levels 100 years from now, you haven't seen someone trying to scrape together a buck in change to buy a cheeseburger at McDonalds recently. Who do you think businesses will be cutting first when they have to make up for carbon credit costs? Hint - not from the top.

This is what people who are pro-climate change legislation sound like to me, a bunch of whiners completely over exaggerating the consequences of global warming (existential crisis? really?) while completely ignoring the real human suffering their ideas will cause in the short term.

Lets wait until we can really prove global warming is true before we jump to conclusions, because we could very well be inducing even more massive suffering on the lower class in our country who have already been squeezed very badly over the last 10+ years with stagnant wages, lost jobs, and rising healthcare costs. I haven't seen inconclusive proof in a scientific sense (we're programmers, we all know you can put garbage in and get garbage out from a computer "model" if you do it one way or another. and if they aren't showing the data they have (see the whole lost temperature data debacle) and in same cases the code for the models, what are they showing?)

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tensor on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:03PM (#953059)
I've never been convinced by the "it'll ruin our economy" arguments. Why? How could you possibly know this? Are you ignoring the potential jobs green legislation could create in the area of green technology?

Personally, I see plenty of reason to proceed with green initiatives regardless of the global climate change issue. Do I want cleaner air in cities? Yes. Legislation to reduce car emissions has already made a very noticeable impact in my own city in just a decade. Do we really want to have air like they have in China?

The same can be true of power generation. We need more power, and nuclear waste is dangerous * independently* of climate change. Coal and gas have negative impact on our air quality. Thus we are left again with green technologies for now.

I don't know if all the proposed changes intended to help climate change have other benefits like the ones I described. That would be an interesting question to have answered.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by CWuestefeld on Friday November 20, 2009 @05:52PM (#953644)
This is economics 101. If there were an alternative that were more profitable and green, don't you think somebody would already be doing it out of greed if not altruism?

No, the fact that those greedy capitalists must be forced to do it pretty much shows that it's losing money, relative whatever else they might do with that money.

And what might those alternatives be? Why, investing in new businesses to create jobs, improving infrastructure, etc.

Really, the idea that the government is so much wiser about business and economics than the corporations, so the laws will drag us kicking and screaming into prosperity, are just absurd. The government is incompetent at managing the entire system. And Friedrich Hayek's Nobel-Prize winning work proved that this is necessarily so -- it's absolutely impossible for any centralized authority to integrate all of the distributed data about needs, priorities, resource availability, etc. Only the distributed cloud of the market can do that.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by InclinedPlane on Friday November 20, 2009 @08:41PM (#953953)
Quite so.

Nobody needs to convince, or legislate for, steel mills to recycle scrap iron. They do it because it's practical and it makes economic sense.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by run4yourlives on Friday November 20, 2009 @04:56PM (#953521)
Why? How could you possibly know this? Are you ignoring the potential jobs green legislation could create in the area of green technology?

Have you not noticed how dependent we are on fossil fuels at all?

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by InclinedPlane on Saturday November 21, 2009 @06:17AM (#954434)
Keep in mind that at current rates the world will be about 4x richer in 2050 compared to today. Per capita. Adjusted for inflation. Given the tight correlation between energy use and economic growth today it seems like a very questionable conclusion to say that money we spend today in drastically curbing carbon emissions will be so much more effective than anything future societies will be able to do with 4x as much money at their disposal (and all of the technological advances of the next 4 decades as well).

Especially when you consider that the greatest amount of effort needed will be in getting developing countries to avoid massively increasing their Carbon emissions as their economies grow. Personally I think that an affluent, say, Bangladesh capable of dealing with some of the potential negative consequences of global warming is all around a better solution than a Bangladesh which endures yet another century of poverty but avoids emitting much CO2 into the atmosphere. I imagine the Bandladeshis, and the Chinese and the Indians and the Indonesians, etc, etc, feel the same way, and it will be immensely difficult to get them to curb their growth in CO2 production, making anything the G8 does on its own to curb CO2 production completely irrelevant.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @03:13PM (#953291)
"If you have the luxury to be worrying about rising sea levels 100 years from now, you haven't seen someone trying to scrape together a buck in change to buy a cheeseburger at McDonalds recently."

OK, in a single sentence you've managed to:

-understate the extent of the climate risk

-play the "what about the poor working class?" card, which is the Rust Belt, recession-era sequel to "but what about the children?"

-intimate, without actually proving, that reducing climate emissions will hurt the poor

-systemically dismiss any and all long-term concerns, implying that there's no point tackling larger problems if someone, somewhere, has trouble affording a cheeseburger.

None of what you've said anywhere else in this thread seems to overcome the essential weaknesses of that argument.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tome on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:35PM (#952823)
Well I don't know about you, but personally I'm pretty scared of the damage that could be sustained to me and my country over the next 50 years when I'll still be alive, and the next 70 or 80 when I might be.

If we have to make sacrifices now to mitigate that risk I'm prepared to do so. I'm also prepared to pay more tax to help the less well off who lose their source of income. We've been doing it in my country for nearly a century.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by krschultz on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:10PM (#952905)
Then you are out of touch with the realities of what is going to happen if we pass this bill.

We already pay more for labor, energy, environmental regulations compliance, and corporate tax in the USA than pretty much anywhere else. When you start making energy even more expensive, the economics are going to shift for the remaining factories and we're going to ship pretty much every one left in this country to somewhere they don't have cap and trade. That is going to cost a lot of blue collar jobs.

Then food will be significantly more expensive because of the increased energy costs - and not to mention they produce a lot of CO2. Who gets hit most by the cost of food? Those at the bottom or those at the top?

Everything about this is really really regressive. You are willing to "make sacrifices now", because frankly you don't have to make any sacrifices. "I'm willing to pay more tax". Wow, what a sacrifice. Might have to pass up on the next iPhone. Taxes take away discretionary income from the upper classes. Big deal. Regressionary laws that destroy blue collar jobs and make the cost of living higher for those at the bottom cause real, true, heartbreaking hardship. Get off Hacker News and go into an area like Detroit that has been hit by these problems and see what I mean. If you can't afford food and can't afford your rent and lost your job and are trying to raise kids, those are more than just little sacrifices. Honestly that is way worse than the alternative. What is going to happen if climate change comes? Sea levels will rise and some houses will be lost in most areas on the coast, and cities will have to have levies built. Is that better or worse than destroying the lives of millions of people today?

Not to mention, if you pass cap and trade you won't actually do a damn thing to help the climate. Every factory that moves offshore will be going somewhere they don't enforce these kind of laws. In fact a lot of countries you offshore to have incentives to reduce automation and increase job supply, so something that might take 1 guy here takes 4 there. Generally that is related to reduced automation and reduced technology. Which is also related to lower efficiency and higher emissions. The power plants in the US are a heck of a lot cleaner than the equivalent in a lot of the countries we are outsourcing to. And then you have the transportation emissions getting it here.

So you are talking about definitely hurting a lot of people today, and hoping that just maybe you might be able to make tomorrow better than it could turn out to be if these computer models are correct, or it might make tomorrow just as bad or worse if compliance isn't 100% globally - which it won't be.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:06PM (#953073)
If we apply cap and trade regulations to imports as well, there's no escape--all goods consumed in the US would have to be accounted for against the US carbon budget. You're right that it's pointless to tie cap and trade purely against production.

The rest of your argument rests on a lot of mistaken labor-leftist political ideology, but I'm not interested in arguing it right now.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by krschultz on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:21PM (#958635)
Well considering I'm a libertarian, that is quite false.

But I am an industrial engineer, so I know a thing or two about factories.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tome on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:19PM (#952922)
I think you might have confused me with someone else. I'm not trying to pass a bill.

I'm expressing concern about my own future, and the future of others in the possible case the climate change is catastrophic.

The problems of offshoring jobs could be solved by Obama at Copenhagen if he gets China to sign up to a cap on its omissions.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by gnaritas on Friday November 20, 2009 @05:53PM (#953648)
> What is going to happen if climate change comes? Sea levels will rise and some houses will be lost in most areas on the coast, and cities will have to have levies built.

I think you seriously underestimate the change and damage that will occur with climate change. There will be large effects on the natural world, on other species; species we may not be able to live without. To blow it off like oh it's just a few houses isn't very smart.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by forensic on Friday November 20, 2009 @09:32PM (#954024)
If doom and gloomers would publish their data and code maybe I would start to believe their fantastic visions of the apocalypse.

The burden of proof is on you... and the only evidence we really get is a giant appeal to authority and a billion dollars spent on commercials.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by jstevens85 on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:07PM (#952894)
You're view of the impact of climate change is surprisingly and disappointingly American centric. The result of doing nothing will be far worse for the world's poor in Africa and Asia than for the American working class if carbon emissions are restricted.

Also, if we're waiting for "proof" of the existence of global warming, I image we'll be waiting quite a while. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe it's possible to prove anything in the physical sciences. Newton's theory of gravity was believed to be correct for over two hundred years before scientists began to suspect that it was inaccurate in certain cases.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by andreyf on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:06PM (#952889)
Rising sea levels and "different weather" could lead to the flooding of cities and death or displacement of billions (yes, with a B) of people.

Reducing carbon emissions would mean employing engineers and professionals to upgrade much of our industrial infrastructure. More employment, not less.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by dantheman on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:26PM (#952800)
But there a lot of decisions like that. 1. If we don't invest in SETI aliens could come and wipe us out; seems like a bad bet to make we should fund set at 10000% 2. We need better protection from asteroids one could wipe us out; we need to tax every human being @ 80 % to build a giant defense network. 3. There could be a disease that wipes out the human race we need to increase the amount of spending on health care... etc etc

Looking at the extreme edges with out an idea of probabilities is an easy way to get confused.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by crystalis on Friday November 20, 2009 @03:09PM (#953283)
I'd say you've gone wrong twice, here.

You have included problems (with unusual "solutions") with probabilities on hugely different magnitudes on the same list, and presumed that every problem is equally soluble.

Global warming has a reasonable probability distribution and a very feasible solution. Compare that to hostile aliens with the ability to travel from the far reaches of undetectability to Earth- the technology gulf would be impossible to overcome.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by yummyfajitas on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:28PM (#952804)
Pascal asked a similar question:

If the bible is wrong but the accepted answer, you lose a finite amount of hedonic pleasure in the near term and there are some short term benefits (smaller amount of killing/stealing/coveting).

If the bible is right, but not accepted, you will burn in hell for all eternity.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by andreyf on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:00PM (#952876)
The flaw in Pascal's argument is that just because we can imagine something, doesn't make the probability of it occurring greater than 0. Since there is evidence for it, however, the probability of climate change is certainly greater than 0.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by prewett on Friday November 20, 2009 @04:44PM (#953491)
If I recall correctly, Pascal's argument was that if the Christian God is truly the one and only god, then if you follow him, you go to heaven and have infinite pleasure. Nothing else gives you guaranteed infinite pleasure, therefore the expectation value for being a follower of the Christian God is the highest.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by dave_au on Friday November 20, 2009 @06:57PM (#953782)
Nothing else? What about the other gods that will damn you for not following them? I'd say it's an even split between all religions with a positive afterlife. Better heavens and nastier hells might skew the distribution...
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tome on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:39PM (#952833)
Sure, but that's rather over-exaggerating to make a cheap point.

Every business asks a similar question every day.

"If I decide to do A, I might make $B dollars or lose $C dollars. Is this a wise thing to do?"

We tend to think that Pascal's cost benefit analysis was flawed. That doesn't mean we should drop the principle altogether!

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by yummyfajitas on Friday November 20, 2009 @06:01PM (#953672)
I'm not advocating against cost benefit analysis. If the original poster said "anthropogenic warming has a cost $X with probability P, the fix costs $Y < $P X, therefore do the fix" I wouldn't have said anything.

I'm all in favor of the rational cost benefit analysis you hint at. Most environmentalists are not - witness the reaction to Bjorn Lomborg.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by soldarnal on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:42PM (#952993)
The most devastating problem to Pascal's wager, in my opinion, is the many claimants problem - the idea being, "Which god?" The one whose favorite number is 1? 2? 3? etc... I think the same problem will ultimately be devastating to any attempt to apply it to global warming. Which solution? We only have finite resources. Do we build a giant solar shade or do we implement a cap-and-trade solution? There are perhaps an infinite number of possible solutions, each a claimant upon our wager.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tome on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:12PM (#953087)
Each solution to reducing carbon dioxide emissions pulls in more or less the same direction. Choosing a god to worship certainly does not!
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by soldarnal on Friday November 20, 2009 @06:09PM (#953702)
Presumably the goal isn't reducing carbon dioxide emissions, but maintaining global temperatures, in which case possible solutions do pull in many different directions...

But anyway, that misses the point. The wager isn't cost-benefit analysis where probabilities and expected values are certain; it's decision making in the absence of compelling evidence. What you have essentially done is respond to the multiple claimants problem by saying, "But any form of belief in the Christian God pulls in more or less the same direction." In the uncertainty that the wager confronts, however, "reducing CO2 emissions" and "increasing CO2 emissions" have the same expected value - that is, they are equal claimants. Hence my point that the multiple claimants problem is equally devastating when the wager is applied to global warming.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by randallsquared on Friday November 20, 2009 @04:39PM (#953476)
Waiting to do something drastic until we're forty or fifty years richer and more technologically capable seems like an easy answer, assuming you're willing to agree that we're getting more capable of solving the problem faster than the problem is worsening. And assuming that the recent plateau doesn't signal the beginning of the end of the interglacial, which, I'm sure you'll agree, would be a far worse problem than global warming...
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by youngian on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:58PM (#952872)
http://blog.iangreenleaf.com/2009/02/pascal-and-global-warmi...

I totally beat you to the punch on this one :D

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by cschneid on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:29PM (#952949)
You touch on a point that swings my view of the political response towards the "do something" end of the spectrum. Climate change, true or false, is tightly tied to pollution. By taking action against climate change (in the traditional ways, less coal, more wind & solar, less waste), we also take a big step towards reducing pollution, and nobody is a pollution denier....
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tome on Friday November 20, 2009 @11:56AM (#952723)
This is a valid question I think. "An Inconvenient Truth" came out three years ago. In that time it may or may not have come to light whether or not we can afford to wait. I think it's likely that it in fact has. If you disagree please reply instead of downmodding.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by fnid on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:30PM (#952809)
I think if the earth has actually been cooling since 1980, that's pretty good evidence we can wait. It's actually evidence that it isn't human action causing the climate change, so we can forget about trying to change whatever behaviors it is of ours that are causing it and focus on the real problem: How do we adapt to a warmer planet?

That is the real problem with the whole debate. It is centered on "humans have cause climate change." If the reality is that the sun is causing climate change or, "Climate change happens in cycles," which it has since the earth formed, then the response and the path forward is very different from the ones currently proposed.

EDIT: You know, in a way, saying climate change is human responsibility is enabling us to avoid doing what we have to do now. For example, if sea levels will continue to rise for 100 years, we should stop all new coastal development. Saying humans can stop the warming and lower the sea levels allows us to keep building on the coasts. Essentially, saying, "In the future, we can stop climate change" allows us to do nothing in the present.

Imagine the difference if we knew it was not caused by humans or in fact, there is nothing we can do, the planet will continue to get hotter for 100 years, then we start building cities underground, moving civilization to the poles of the earth, inventing more heat tolerant crops, better local climate control, etc.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tome on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:52PM (#952861)
Your point in your EDIT about being unaware or unaccepting of (potential) real ways to mitigate climate is an excellent one, thanks!
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by antipaganda on Saturday November 21, 2009 @01:26AM (#954274)
How can the Earth have been cooling since 1980 if most of the 10 hottest years in recorded history were in the 2000s?
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by BearOfNH on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:18PM (#952921)
Is there a plausible case that we cannot afford to wait?

If it isn't caused by humans it's unlikely to be fixable by humans.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by tensor on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:55PM (#953034)
I'm not sure why you'd assume that. Humans can indeed make big changes to the environment. Typically these are negative, clearing of huge areas of forest, the air/smog in China. But perhaps there are positive examples too. And if not, well, we really wouldn't know unless we try.

Do we even know enough about climate to know what to try and do though? Its not something I've spent a huge amount of time researching.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by spoondan on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:06PM (#952749)
OK. We get it: You don't like Al Gore. But he is completely, utterly irrelevant to this discussion. He's your bugaboo. Bringing him up is just trolling.

Also, the quote you've selected is quite obviously not the author saying, "These data can legitimately be used to prove urban warming." He's rather plainly saying that he thinks the data will be misinterpreted and so needs to be placed in its proper context. This is neither nefarious nor even the least bit notable.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by pierrefar on Friday November 20, 2009 @11:45AM (#952690)
There is plenty of room for debate if the skeptics stop polarizing and politicizing the debate.

Also, if anyone in this debate can be counted on to change their mind, it's the scientists: we do it all the time when shown evidence to the contrary of the current belief. I sincerely doubt that your average skeptic walking into this debate is actually willing to change their mind if shown evidence. Their mind is already made up and it won't change.

So yes, plenty of room for debate, but it needs the right mentality.

BTW, I once convinced a very creationist skeptic that evolution just might be correct in like 3 hours. How? He was willing to listen and see that there just might be an alternative explanation to the things he's seeing. He was willing to accept a different point of view and my job was to present my case. Luckily I did OK.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by randallsquared on Friday November 20, 2009 @11:54AM (#952721)
There is plenty of room for debate if the skeptics stop polarizing and politicizing the debate.

You're suggesting that the global warming folks would be willing to avoid politicizing? If it weren't for the policy prescriptions and other political fallout, the skeptics mostly wouldn't even care. I'm sure the vast majority of the skeptics would be willing, even eager, to drop all potential politics from the debate, but the whole reason it's important (from the viewpoint of such a skeptic!) is that it's now more about politics than science.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by pierrefar on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:13PM (#952768)
Absolutely it's more about politics than science. What I don't understand is that why politics got so injected so fiercely into the debate. Because of all the anti-climate change efforts, the climate change case actually got better as scientists did what they do best: they found more evidence to settle the points of contention raised by the skeptics.

Are the skeptics listening to this new evidence objectively? All I hear from them is "Ah yes, that may be so, but...".

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by krschultz on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:40PM (#952840)
It is extremely easy to see how politics got injected into the debate.

There was a move from "these are our findings" to "lets try and stop global warming". The second step requires government action. Hence, politics. If the climate change scientists had stayed in the "lets refine our findings" area then it would never be political. As soon as you say "lets get the government to do something about this", it is political.

There will always be people who question why you should expand government. And it is up to the people trying to expand the government to clearly show WHY we need to.

What are you expecting? Some people show up with their computer models and say LOOK, WE NEED TO DO SOMETHING, and no one would object? No one would look at it critically? If the science was so indisputable then the bill would be passed, just like the Clean Air and Clean Water acts were when they showed real science on pollutants.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:28PM (#953145)
You have a lot more faith than I do in the scientific literacy of our political system. Before climate change became such a current issue, there was serious controversy about whether or not we should teach schoolchildren about evolution.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by fnid on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:24PM (#952794)
Politics got injected because a lot of money is being spent on climate change research, clean energy, carbon credits, etc. Kyoto was all politics. A lot of money stands to be made or lost on climate change issues. You think Al Gore is doing what he is doing for free?
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by randallsquared on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:44PM (#952846)
What I don't understand is that why politics got so injected so fiercely into the debate.

Because it was perceived as an unassailable reason for more lawmaking and regulation, which is what politicians do, even (hypothetically) politicians with the purest motives.

Are the skeptics listening to this new evidence objectively? All I hear from them is "Ah yes, that may be so, but...".

I think most skeptics have moved from "what global warming?" to the more defensible "there's been global warming, but less than at other times in the historical and (especially) geological past, and starting well before the 20th century CO2 output increases, so the cause is unlikely to be primarily human industry".

This is a position, however, which is hard to generate soundbites for, so they've taken a massive hit in the public perception department, as it's hard to argue their position at less than essay length, and book length is better.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by youngian on Friday November 20, 2009 @01:12PM (#952908)
I think you've made the mistake of only spending time with the intelligent skeptics. I regretfully inform you they are far from the majority.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by InclinedPlane on Friday November 20, 2009 @08:47PM (#953965)
I don't see how you can make the claim that the "climate change case actually got better". Are you familiar with the busting of the hockey stick, for example? A lot of AGW models are utterly dependent on that piece of fiction. Yet despite it being revealed to be a fabrication based on a tiny subset of cherry picked data, nobody in the AGW community seems to care, nor have they spent the time to reformulate their models that were dependent on that data.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by duncanj on Saturday November 21, 2009 @10:26AM (#954599)
I think you've cherry-picked that belief. The discussion I have seen has convinced me that the "hockey-stick busted" thing is a red herring.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:26PM (#953137)
You're right: science should restrict itself to saying things like "the continued release of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere is likely to cause an aggregate increase in global temperatures, which will cause a host of largely unpredictable consequences, probably including rising sea levels and changes in ocean currents. Reducing the release of greenhouse gases will reduce these consequences." And so forth.

Politics only come in when people don't want the climate to change. Which is another way of saying that science only gets politicized when it discovers something with the potential of requiring political action.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by jswinghammer on Friday November 20, 2009 @11:54AM (#952720)
Wait you're accusing the skeptics of politicizing the debate? It's the climate change promoters (many of whom are scientists) who have been saying that the sky is falling and that we need to cut our emissions now through massive government intervention. I don't know how that isn't politicizing the debate.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:40PM (#953187)
This kind of strikes me as absurd:

A: It seems like releasing greenhouse gases has detrimental effects on the climate. We should find a way of releasing fewer greenhouse gases.

B: Nothing you say is true, and you're politicizing the debate. It will require massive government intervention to release fewer greenhouse gases!

A: Okay. But if we don't reduce greenhouse gases, these things are going to happen.

B: You're politicizing the debate!

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by InclinedPlane on Friday November 20, 2009 @08:39PM (#953947)
You're missing the point and co-mingling different parts of the debate. There is a scientific debate about whether or not AGW is happening and the degree to which it may be happening. There are secondary debates about the degree to which the effects of AGW may be harmful to Earth's ecosystem and to human civilization and whether or not and to what degree we should take steps toward avoidance or remediation of those effects.

It is critically important that the 1st debate not be influenced by the others, yet today that's not the case at all.

Climatology is an incredibly young science. It is still struggling with problems of collecting data and its theories are still immature. There is no consensus in climate modelling, there is a cacophony of competing climate models, each with their own assumptions and fudge factors, none of which have proven reliable in predicting past climate with any degree of accuracy. But this is fine, this is how science works, theories and models are tested by data, reformulated, and retested until ultimately a theory that can make predictions which prove to be backed up by data wins the day.

And yet, despite this lack of consensus in climate modelling, there is remarkable consensus among the climatology community regarding AGW. Yet neither the quality of the data nor the models backs up such a consensus. And people who express skepticism about AGW (to any degree) are frequently compared to holocaust deniers or anti-evolutionists (those exact comparisons have been made in this very comment thread).

This is what is meant by "politicizing the debate". When one cannot engage in the legitimate scientific debate without being shouted down as an unbeliever who hates the Earth or the human race.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @09:57PM (#954060)
The reason people who express skepticism about AGW are compared to creationists is because they make the exact same kinds of arguments creationists make--unquantified claims about "there isn't enough evidence" mixed with misrepresenting whatever evidence does exist and loudly complaining that they're being shut out of the scientific discussion. Hell, they're even represented by the same political party in the United States.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by InclinedPlane on Saturday November 21, 2009 @05:25AM (#954403)
There is currently no sound scientific argument against the theory of natural selection that is backed up by even a shred of data. However, there are sound scientific arguments against the theory of anthropogenic global warming, and there are many scientists in the field who have put forward alternate theories.

With evolution the "there isn't enough evidence" argument is a side-show by creationists to pretend that the mountain of really very good evidence is somehow less than perfect (hint, no amount of evidence would be enough). With climatology the "there isn't enough evidence" argument is really a very solid scientific critique. We have very little data on historical climate, especially at high CO2 levels. Even the best modern data we have (from satellites and weather stations) covers only a small time frame and still requires a lot of fiddly processing to ensure its accuracy (there are still legitimate debates on what the global average temperature of the Earth was in, say, 1995, for example). The remainder of the data comes via proxy sources and tends to be incomplete or spotty. And the climate models we have today are very immature, all of them contain one or several semi-arbitrary "fudge factors" that must be determined empirically in order for them to have any accuracy. Considering that the input and output data used to calibrate these models and determine these fudge factors is in an entirely different regime than the projected climate for the remainder of the 21st century, criticisms of these models is entirely justified.

When a creationist makes an argument against the validity of evolution (even if it's "there isn't enough evidence") the correct response is "no, there's enough evidence, here's the evidence we have, and here's how it fits the theory, and here's why we have extremely high confidence in this theory". When a "global warming skeptic" says "there isn't enough evidence" the correct response is "there's more than enough evidence, let me show you the evidence and why the evidence backs a particular climate model that predicts AGW".

It is NOT "you don't know what you're talking about, we don't need to show you anything, now shut up and go away" nor is it to compare them to a young-Earth creationist. Those are ways of shutting down honest debate and they are poisonous to science.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by pierrefar on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:14PM (#952773)
So when doctors say "we need to vaccinate all our kids through massive government intervention", that's OK?
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by yummyfajitas on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:25PM (#952796)
Regarding politicizing the debate, riddle me this: which side usually asks to see more data and more transparency?

And which side accuses the others of being greedy corporate shills while comparing them to creationists and holocaust deniers?

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:55PM (#953240)
Creationists and holocaust deniers, incidentally, usually hide behind "asking to see more data and more transparency". You're mischaracterizing. Skepticism is fine on its own, but the thing about the skeptic's game is that you can keep playing it forever no matter how much evidence is on the other side. At some point it's not about skepticism anymore, it's about obstruction and obfuscation.

Here's my concession to the skeptic: let's pin a 25% credence on the risk of severe changes in sea level. I'm willing to give the skeptic 3/4 odds that I'm wrong. Now let's look at a map of human population distribution by elevation and calculate the cost of displacing all of those people. And let's look at the other long term costs and benefits from leaving our energy usage unchanged, and build our policies from there.

Incidentally, while it's marginally true that climate researchers have certain incentives and motivations of their own, it's also very, very true that there is a lot of established money which has a lot to lose if we do anything about the climate.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by yummyfajitas on Friday November 20, 2009 @06:08PM (#953694)
I've never once heard a creationist demand that the human genome project release their data onto the internet, or that they release species taxonomic data. (I can't comment on holocaust deniers since I've never encountered any.)

If you read some of the hacked emails, you realize that's exactly what McIntyre (of climate audit) was doing, and that's what the people at the research center were fighting against.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @06:35PM (#953749)
Creationists are chronically unsatisfied with the evidence that exists, regularly demand to see evidence of more transitional species (even when transitional species are discovered), and take every mistaken conjecture about the specific shape of past evolution as damning evidence against the theory itself.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by InclinedPlane on Friday November 20, 2009 @09:13PM (#953997)
This is because creationists don't believe in evolution. So they try to get scientists to run around, and do a lot of work to come up with evidence that doesn't yet exist (though the existing evidence is more than adequate).

This is in stark contrast to the debate in climatology, where scientists would like data to be publicized so that they may verify the results. The first is Zeno's paradox in evolution ("here's a fossil of an intermediate species between the X and Y species", "that's nice, now show me a fossil intermediate between this one and Y", ad infinitum), the second is just plain science 101 ("we spotted a new supernova in Canopus last night", "oh really, can I see the data?").

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @09:47PM (#954048)
Climate skeptics used to say, "there's no evidence global warming is happening." Then they said, "there's no evidence global warming is caused by anthropogenic CO2". Then they said, "there's no evidence global warming is going to be a bad thing." Continuing to move the goalposts and trying to get scientists to run around is a tactic in both arenas.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by DanielBMarkham on Friday November 20, 2009 @09:56PM (#954058)
But aren't the goal posts already way over on the football field 40 miles away? I mean, it's not like any of these conditions are new or somehow they're being made up. There are a series of things -- each of which has to be necessary and sufficient -- in order for the argument to take drastic action to hold water. This has always been the case, and this will always be the case. This is the nature of convincing anybody that drastic action must be taken -- about anything.

We just choose to talk about one goalpost or the other. It's not like people are making up extra requirements of proof simply to make it harder on the other side. The only reason folks talk about each of these goalposts one at a time is just to make the conversation easier on everybody.

So yes, if you get through the "man can change the environment" hoop, which I believe, you have about a dozen other hoops to jump through, some of which I find much less plausible than others, before you get to the "we must do something now!" This is just the structure of the argument -- debating style or political trickery has little to do with it (in my mind)

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by InclinedPlane on Saturday November 21, 2009 @05:00AM (#954390)
Considering that taking drastic action in order to cut back CO2 production is only justified if all 3 things are true, each of those 3 goal posts are incredibly valid.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by krschultz on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:10PM (#952764)
Where are the skeptics trying to get the government to pass a bill stopping climate change research? Skeptics have no goals politically other than to STOP the legislation put forward by people politicizing climate change research.
Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by philwelch on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:59PM (#953260)
You're asking people to simultaneously:

-believe that continued emissions of greenhouse gases will cause rising sea levels, displacing hundreds of millions of people, as well as causing less predictable consequences we will be ill-prepared to respond to, but also

-not want to actually do anything to prevent it.

It's a self-contradictory argument. You're better off just convincing people that part 1 isn't true.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by dkarl on Friday November 20, 2009 @11:47AM (#952699)
thinking critically about the evidence and data interpretation

NOT trying to start a flame war, but I think there's a parallel here between science and Biblical criticism. In both cases, if you start with the preconception that the data has one simple and obvious message, then you will project your own biases onto it. Real analysis starts when you acknowledge that it's very difficult to tease meaning out of data that has very complex and partly unknowable context, which speaks directly to only a small number of situations, and which must be extrapolated to cover situations that have no direct analog in the data.

Yet popular science, like popular religion, must engage people by offering meaning and understanding that is accessible with much less effort. Popular science is therefore (unavoidably) guilty of encouraging blithe and simplistic interpretations of data, because that's the only way you can encourage people to think.

Re:Climate center's server hacked, revealing documents and e... by crystalis on Friday November 20, 2009 @12:23PM (#952791)
"Dear Phil and Gabi, I’ve attached a cleaned-up and commented version of the matlab code that I wrote for doing the Mann and Jones (2003) composites. I did this knowing that Phil and I are likely to have to respond to more crap criticisms from the idiots in the near future, so best to clean up the code and provide to some of my close colleagues in case they want to test it, etc. Please feel free to use this code for your own internal purposes, but don’t pass it along where it may get into the hands of the wrong people." [emphasis theirs]

A lot of the excerpted emails look like this- fairly understandable examples of scorn directed to people who produce "crap criticism". You wouldn't want anyone trying to square the circle to email you to dispute your work, would you?