News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by fastball on Sunday May 10, 2015 @05:38PM (#9521430)
Is Greek / Roman / Norse mythology (basically everything Western that isn't Christianity) not considered religion? Because maybe I'm just blind but I can't seem to find those anywhere in the tree.
Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by lqndlwq on Sunday May 10, 2015 @05:45PM (#9521464)
It seems to be incomplete and inaccurate in a lot of ways.

For example, Christianity borrows elements of Zoroastrianism and Judaism is actually derived from ancient Babylonian polytheism. Maybe I just didn't see it, but Confucianism seems to be missing too.

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by ars on Sunday May 10, 2015 @05:55PM (#9521508)
> Judaism is actually derived from ancient Babylonian polytheism.

That isn't true. At best, and even this is debated, there are some traces, but it's not in the slightest "derived from".

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by lqndlwq on Sunday May 10, 2015 @06:11PM (#9521572)
Maybe not derived from, but certainly descended from.

Yahweh was the national god of the Israelites, who were part of the Canaanite polytheistic system. In the context of Yahweh being a warrior deity in a polytheistic system, the phrase "there are no other gods like our god," and also the crusades against neighboring settlements seem to take on more meaning.

Interesting reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yahweh

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by burgreblast on Monday May 11, 2015 @01:55PM (#9526556)
>Certainly descended from

Also no.

Yahweh is clearly at a level "above all gods", i.e. on his own level as omnipotent creator of all things. Angels and fallen angels (aka demons/ heavenly hosts and other "gods") are on a second level of power/influence, and then earthly creations below that.

As such, Yahweh doesn't "compete" against other (lower-case) gods, because they're not omnipotent creators and he is.

Although the Israelites were pretty famous for rejecting him and worshiping lower-case gods, (and subsequently incurring Yahweh's wrath), there's never a question that he is the I AM and not any derivation.

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by lknwfdlknfd on Monday May 11, 2015 @03:53PM (#9527421)
I'm talking about the historical and anthropological record, not the Hebrew mythology. Of course the religion's modern texts would paint themselves in an infallible light.

So yes, Judaism is descended and evolved from Canaanite religion.

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by ars on Monday May 11, 2015 @04:43PM (#9527715)
Your own links don't support such a strong claim. At best the strongest claim you can make is that the name might have some correspondence with the name of Canaanite Gods, but you have zero information on the direction of the influence.

Your own links make no claim at all that the religion itself has any relationship with the Canaanite religions.

Regarding the direction, do not forget that Abraham was very active in the region, and proselytized extensively. It is hardly surprising if the Canaanites took some concepts from him.

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by lknwfdlknfd on Monday May 11, 2015 @11:35PM (#9529461)
That article has been restructured quite a bit after it was made part of the Judaism portal, compared to when I first found it and then looked into the subject a couple of years ago. Just because one wikipedia article is incomplete doesn't mean it's not an accepted fact.
Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by burgreblast on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:44AM (#9529923)
> Accepted fact

Whoah. Be careful slinging around the F-bomb, bro.

When talking about causation of events where there is no data, much less reproducible data, you certainly have room to disagree with some evidence and prefer others, but it goes too far to claim "Judaism is actually derived from ancient Babylonian polytheism" is unassailable fact.

That may your belief--and you may interpret some evidence to support your belief--but as you'll be quick to point out to others, having a belief doesn't mean it's true.

The bar for something being a fact is higher than that.

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by ars on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:42AM (#9529916)
No, it's not an accepted fact.

I understand that you are simply repeating what you learned, but you learned inaccurate information.

It's possible your mistake is because there are some that believe that the Canaanite religions and Judaism were practiced in parallel by the same peoples, but one is not descended from other.

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by the8472 on Sunday May 10, 2015 @07:16PM (#9521847)
Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by mgraczyk on Sunday May 10, 2015 @05:49PM (#9521484)
Confucianism can be found near the center. It's the thick brownish-green branch that goes left near 0 AD.
Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by anigbrowl on Sunday May 10, 2015 @06:12PM (#9521581)
Confucianism can be found around 9 o'clock on the outer circumference.
Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by krick on Sunday May 10, 2015 @06:35PM (#9521665)
Basically it lacks everything which is not a part of some "mainstream" religion today, for which it has, conversely, very impressive list of local (sometimes even hardly distinguishable) denominations. I cannot find any animistic religions, no shamanism, virtually no polytheistic religions outside of hinduism.

But it isn't really because the map isn't "complete enough", I'd say the whole taxonomy is a bit weird. It makes it look like there were several "major" religions like "Chinese folk Taoism" and "Japanese Mythology" which produced everything else, when if fact they are not "major" at all: it would be more accurate to start from general spiritual cults, where every concrete local religion would be thin line as well. Of course it wouldn't look like real tree, and it shouldn't.

Wikipedia, as always can provide somewhat decent insight: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_religion

Re:The World Religions Tree (huge visualization) by davyjones on Sunday May 10, 2015 @05:43PM (#9521454)
Similar for Africa(n) which leads me to believe that the periphery covers only what is extant and only the roots of those are traced back to their origins.