News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do you understand this first-grade child's homework? by rdtsc on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:00AM (#952062)
> You'll be crippled trying to learn things like decimals, fractions, exponents or god forbid algebra or calculus if whenever you have to add you have to be "making ten" in your head. It needs to be memorized.

/joke: they should just start with category theory -- it will produce a fine new generation of HN readers ;-)

> Thus we have convoluted methods of teaching addition like this that in some way do make sense, but are mostly just another layer of confusion.

I think everyone conceptualizes and encodes basic arithmetic stuff in their own way. Some memorize it symbolically, some visualize, some think of number lines, graphs and so on.

Trying to "help" by providing tables, coins and all kind of "aides" just confuses some students who started to encode it differently.

Re:Do you understand this first-grade child's homework? by RevRal on Friday November 20, 2009 @02:03AM (#952066)
I think everyone conceptualizes and encodes basic arithmetic stuff in their own way. Some memorize it symbolically, some visualize, some think of number lines, graphs and so on.

I've always had a tetris thing going on in my head.

Re:Do you understand this first-grade child's homework? by xiaoma on Friday November 20, 2009 @03:35AM (#952132)
Ha. Real mathematicians start from axiomatic set theory.