News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by thret on Friday May 08, 2015 @07:44AM (#9510997)
This makes no sense to me.

Ulster Unionist Party had 114,935 votes and got two seats. UKIP had 3,841,346 votes and got one seat. Conservative had 11,207,547 votes and received 326 seats.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by th0br0 on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:16AM (#9511116)
That's the 'first-past-the-post' system at work here. Sadly it's unlikely to change anytime soon :(
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by M8 on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:33AM (#9511201)
Well, at least there won't be too much overspending. So it worked out well this time.

Any democratic system is flawed - e.g. letting both tax-generators and tax-consumers vote.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by luxpir on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:03AM (#9511056)
It's broked. The party in power rarely see it as broked. Ergo, no proportional representation.
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by jgrahamc on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:23AM (#9511150)
We had a referendum on changing the voting system in 2011: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Alternative_Vot...

The change was rejected 68% to 32%.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by Already__Taken on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:36AM (#9511212)
The media tried very hard to make this sound complicated and scary. Ignoring its how the major parties elect their own leaders. [needs source]

Frankly changing the voting system would require everyone that votes to understand the implications of the system itself. From what I remember talking about the AV people would think of one thing that's different, call it a problem and no amount of explaining would matter.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:38AM (#9511231)
An obscure note, parties do use AV to select their leaders, and for that purpose it's actually pretty good since there's only one position to fill. In a parliamentary election, adding some PR like in the devolved Scottish and Welsh assemblies makes more sense, and means AV was only a tiny improvement.

http://www.electoral-reform.org.uk/additional-member-system

http://www.electoral-reform.org.uk/alternative-vote

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:30AM (#9511187)
Some context though:

* the alternative was a bit rubbish, only a minor improvement to the status quo, compared with the systems already successfully in use in Scotland and Wales which combine local representation with PR.

* both main parties and their tame press convinced people that it would basically lead to a combination of anarchy, communism and fascism in order to maintain their hold on power at the expense of democracy.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by jgrahamc on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:31AM (#9511192)
The "tame press". Seriously?
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:35AM (#9511208)
Yes, seriously.

If you don't believe me, what about David Axelrod:

"POLITICO: But what about the press? You say it has disproportionate power here. Do you think Britain’s conservative print media is more powerful than Fox News?

DA: Yeah, I do. I do think the parties approach media as partisan players. So you see parties disseminating messages through the print media in a way that is unusual.

DA: Fox is certainly very conservative, skews to the Republican side, but there isn’t a kind of lockstep between them and the Republicans. Fox tries to drive the Republican agenda more than reflecting it.

Here there are relationships between the parties and media outlets that are deeper so you see a lot of themes being previewed in the media in a way that you don’t see in the states.

POLITICO: Did you know what you were getting into?

DA: We discussed this when I signed on … I’ve worked in aggressive media environments before but not this partisan."

http://www.politico.eu/article/the-axelrod-exit-interview/

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by PJDK on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:48AM (#9511283)
"Partisan" is very different from "Tame".
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:54AM (#9511319)
In certain usages "tame" and "partisan" are basically synonyms meaning "on your side" or "part of your team". "Tame" is particularly used when the assumption is that they wouldn't be partisan but in fact are.
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by JimmyM on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:40AM (#9511629)
Yes - "Tame" implies that you are not biddable by merely one special interest group, but by anyone willing to throw their weight around. A rather stronger accusation.

https://www.opendemocracy.net/ourkingdom/peter-oborne/why-i-...

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by mechazawa on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:12AM (#9511096)
It still does not make any sense though. How is it possible that the amount of seats a party get seem so pseudo random?
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by QuantumCookie on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:21AM (#9511133)
In short: The First Past the Post Voting system.

The Ulster Unionists will get that many votes but in a small number of seats in Northern Ireland. The Conservatives might just win by a small amount but in a large number of seats, each of which translates directly to an MP in Parliament.

For anyone who hasn't watched them , I can wholeheartedly recommend CGP Grey's "Politics in the Animal Kingdom"[0] videos for an brief overview of why FPTP voting is as bad as it seems.

[0] http://www.cgpgrey.com/politics-in-the-animal-kingdom/

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by coldpie on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:27AM (#9511161)
Suppose you have 20 districts, each electing its own MP, and each with exactly four citizens. One citizen in each votes UKIP, one votes Labour, and two vote Conservative. Conservatives will win 20 seats, despite getting only 50% of the national vote, and the other parties will have none despite getting 25% each.
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by petercooper on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:19AM (#9511124)
Because it depends on geography as voting in the UK is based on who you vote for your local MP.

If UKIP's four million votes were entirely within 20 or 30 constituencies, they'd have won them all. But because their votes are spread out across the entire country, other parties pick up those seats instead.

The parties that do best are either those that get a ton of votes everywhere, or those that dig in and solely focus on specific locations where they can get a majority (the Lib Dems used to be good at this).

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by mseebach on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:41AM (#9511243)
It's not random at all, it's just that the national vote doesn't factor at all (only the vote in each seat does).

It has the (often overlooked, IMO) benefit of a strong 1:1 connection between constituent and MP: even if you didn't vote for the MP, a majority of your neighbours did, and the MP is still your representative in parliament. Organising locally to boot out your MP is much, much simpler than organising nationally to shift balances of power. That has got to be a factor in keeping MPs (more) honest.

In PR, you can be in the deeply problematic situation that you like candidate A and dislike candidate B from party X, but you vote for A actually ends up going to B - in effect, you can only really vote for a party, not a particular candidate. This is a significant shift of power to the parties as they generally control (or heavily influences) who runs where and how the ranking that controls "spill-over" votes will end up. Parties are often run opaquely, through back-room deals and patronage, not terribly democratically.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:11AM (#9511442)
The existence of "safe seats" in the current FPTP system, into which parties can (and do) parachute their key players makes your take on FPTP too optimistic. See my comments elsewhere for links about voting systems, already in use in the UK, that seek to balance local representation and proportionality. PR (and FPTP for that matter) can encompass a variety of actual voting systems with important differences between them.
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by mseebach on Friday May 08, 2015 @10:24AM (#9511865)
I did not mean to imply that FPTP is flawless, it certainly is not - merely that it has some benefits and PR has some drawbacks that often get overlooked in the pursuit of "numerical fairness".
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by kmfrk on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:38AM (#9511233)
You've got 650 marginal elections where people can only pick one party - and not a coalition through prioritized votes. Compare this to the US where each congressional election is usually between two or three candidates/parties.

This makes forecasts primed for surprises due to margins of error alone, not including other factors.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by protomyth on Friday May 08, 2015 @11:19AM (#9512162)
Its a matter of what exactly you want to represent in your government.

If you want to represent political parties then First Past the Post is horrible and seats by percentage is what you want. That would mean that their is really no reason to represent local needs since you really need to run a full country campaign and will probably pick dense packed areas to spend advertising.

If you want the geographic region (however you define it) to have a representative then the opposite is true. First Past the Post means they have to campaign locally if they want to get in. Percentage of seats by party means local campaigning is just a bit of nostalgia and a waste of campaign money.

It comes down to what do you value and what relationship you want between the voter and national government.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by petercooper on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:21AM (#9511138)
Unionists are in the majority in the geographical areas of those two seats (the Northern Irish population is still a little segregated). UKIPpers are not in the majority anywhere (except Clacton, maybe!) but are spread across the entire country.
Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by Sherlock on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:38AM (#9511228)
What's interesting from a game theory point of view is to have so many different parties with a FPTP electoral system.

You would expect a two party system.

Re:David Cameron Wins a Slim Majority in UK General Election by DanBC on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:47AM (#9511673)
It was, until this election, essentially a two and a half party system, with some other parties in Northern Ireland.