With the wait-to-buzz-in rule, the audience gets an chance to understand and maybe think of the answer before the contestants speak.
Which is lots of fun and very competitive, but a little bit less tele-savvy.
Q: What is the capital of L-(BUZZ)-ithu-- [stops reading].
A. Vilnius.
But if they had had really good reaction time and stopped on L--, I'd have been hosed. Latvia, Lithuania, Liechtenstein, Libya, Liberia, etc...
Q: What is the capital of (BUZZ) Lithuania?
A: Vilnius.
One solution would be to display the text of the question slightly beforehand to the audience, but not the contestants.
I think one of the reasons Jeopardy! is so popular is that it makes the audience feel smart. I'm not amazing at trivia, but I know most of the Jeopardy! answers and having the contestants wait to buzz in creates the illusion that I'm doing as well / better than they are. Even though I'm intellectual aware of the importance of buzzer timing, it still feels good to watch and give the answers before the contestants have a chance to demonstrate they know. Compare that to a trivia show like University Challenge in the UK, where not only are the questions remarkably hard, the contestants buzz in before I've had a chance to parse, let alone answer, the questions.
I think allowing contestants to buzz in early, even if Alex finished reading the question before they could answer, would make Jeopardy! a better trivia game but a worse TV show.
Being first to buzz is a huge part of the game, and no matter when you turn the buzzers on, there will be people trying to buzz at that moment.
My wife, and my neighbor's husband, feel like it's the height of rudeness.
This is kind of the canonical example people can understand for the platinum vs the golden rule, as it happens.
There's another side, too, which is if folks could signal early, reading fast would become an even stronger optimization. It already is, but at least everybody gets an equal chance the way it is (even if they got the answer fairly quickly from reading the clue while ignoring Trebek).
On the other hand, I wouldn't be surprised if the target demographic of Jeopardy is often doing something else and listening without actually watching.
Other game shows work that way as well, and it has its own degree of fun for the audience. For instance, the contestant buzzes in and answers after a few words of the question, gets the answer wrong, the host is grinning like a possum, and after they read the next part of the question, it makes the contestant's answer even more hilariously wrong in context.
[1]: This has always struck me as an idiotic gimmick, especially since the wording rarely makes sense. No one would ever respond to the question "Who was George Washington?" with the answer "This man served as the first President of the United States."
[2]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeopardy!#CITEREFTrebekBarso...
I played on a trivia team at the high school level, and most questions were structured like:
"This American architect, born in 1867, is known for works such as the Robie House, the Guggenheim Museum, and Fallingwater."
So they typically feed you information from least to most well known, and you can buzz in at any time. This rewards players who know the most trivia. Everyone who played knows Frank Lloyd Wright did Fallingwater, but a very good player would know his approximate date of birth and would buzz in immediately on hearing 1867.
I understand that this might make Jeopardy less fun for the audience, but I feel it would be a better test of trivia instead of buzzer timing.