News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency by maxerickson on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @04:00PM (#9494592)
I read the concern to be with the reliability of their testimony. I'm fine with the idea that simply smelling marijuana should not be probable cause. I'm not fine with the idea that it should not be probable cause because it creates an avenue for abuse of power.

The checks on abuse of power should happen at a higher level in the system than making rules about what an officer can reliably testify about.

Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @05:32PM (#9495084)
> The checks on abuse of power should happen at a higher level in the system than making rules about what an officer can reliably testify about.

Why should there even be such rules? An officer, like any witness, can testify about anything they observe that is relevant to the matter under consideration by the court, and not barred by any generally-applicable prohibition (e.g., hearsay, etc., to the extent that is barred.)

Whether such testimony is reliable is a matter for the court/jury receiving the testimony to consider, based on the statement, any evidence of bias of the witness, and any conflicting or corroborating evidence.

Treating cops as privileged witnesses in any domain makes no sense, and seems to be contrary to the whole thrust of the Constitutional constraints on the criminal justice system, which are to protect the individual from arbitrary action by the government or its agents.

Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency by maxerickson on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @05:43PM (#9495172)
Yes, I inferred the idea that there should be rules from the comment I replied to and replied in order to reject it.

I think I probably agree that police shouldn't base searches on smelling weed (I'd have to think about whether they should be able to stop a car and tell them to tone it down).

What I don't agree with is making that determination based on concerns about fabricated statements about smelling weed.

Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @05:55PM (#9495238)
> What I don't agree with is making that determination based on concerns about fabricated statements about smelling weed.

The concern about fabrication by the government underlies much of the Constitutional restriction on government power in the criminal domain. I'd say that restricting government based on that concern is generally legitimate, and has a strong tradition in the US.

Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency by mikeash on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @04:16PM (#9494685)
Isn't the whole idea of requiring probable cause to prevent abuse of power? If we fully trusted the police then we wouldn't bother with any of this stuff. We'd allow police to search people at any time for any reason. But we don't trust them that far, so we put limits on what they can do. They can't do some searches without probable cause. Others require a warrant.

The line shifts a bit in the case of imminent danger, because we prefer to take more of a risk with the cops than the criminals in that case. A smell of marijuana doesn't indicate a life-threatening situation so we're back to the whole abuse-of-power bit for why the police can't just search people entirely at will.

Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency by maxerickson on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @05:54PM (#9495234)
Probable cause just outlines a set of situations where use of power is authorized. It is the line between authorized and unauthorized use of power more than it is a check on abuse. If an officer pulls someone over just for the heck of it, their lack of probable cause isn't going to stop them from illegally searching the vehicle.

I see what you are saying about limits on power and trust being mixed together, if someone is literally 100% trustworthy there is no need to limit their power. I still think it is reasonable to consider whether police can reliably testify that they smelled something (this should at least be a goal for a just system) separately from the question of whether they should be allowed to act upon smelling something.

Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency by mikeash on Wednesday May 06, 2015 @01:28PM (#9500303)
Where's "testify" coming from? The only comments in the thread I see that mention testimony are from you. The question is about what's sufficient cause for a search, and why. And the reason an officer should be allowed to perform a search based on hearing gunfire but not based on smelling weed is because the latter isn't life-threatening. Testimony in any subsequent court case is a completely different matter.
Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency by maxerickson on Thursday May 07, 2015 @08:38PM (#9509372)
What other potential for abuse does allowing the smell as probable cause introduce? As far as I see, a cop can be a bastard with or without it, but with it he can later say he based a search on the smell (whether it was present or not).