Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency
by mikeash on Wednesday May 06, 2015 @01:28PM
(#9500303)
Where's "testify" coming from? The only comments in the thread I see that mention testimony are from you. The question is about what's sufficient cause for a search, and why. And the reason an officer should be allowed to perform a search based on hearing gunfire but not based on smelling weed is because the latter isn't life-threatening. Testimony in any subsequent court case is a completely different matter.
Re:Ways to manage conflicts with cops in a medical emergency
by maxerickson on Thursday May 07, 2015 @08:38PM
(#9509372)
What other potential for abuse does allowing the smell as probable cause introduce? As far as I see, a cop can be a bastard with or without it, but with it he can later say he based a search on the smell (whether it was present or not).
I see what you are saying about limits on power and trust being mixed together, if someone is literally 100% trustworthy there is no need to limit their power. I still think it is reasonable to consider whether police can reliably testify that they smelled something (this should at least be a goal for a just system) separately from the question of whether they should be allowed to act upon smelling something.