News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Retire This Idea: Scientific Knowledge Structured as “Lit... by Retric on Monday May 04, 2015 @04:57PM (#9489149)
You don't really understand a field without digging deep. A great example is how much students are willing to trust surveys before and after they do a large one. Another is mice running mazes, the numbers may look nice in theory, but they can hide a lot of problems.
Re:Retire This Idea: Scientific Knowledge Structured as “Lit... by ThomPete on Monday May 04, 2015 @05:10PM (#9489210)
I totally agree but the question is what constitutes a field.

I once read about a whole series of areas where solutions to issues in one field happened from understanding from understanding another field. Unfortunately ver few people span over multiple fields and can call themselves experts.

So the questions is whether we could spread out the expertise to more in between studies and letting go of literature as the only way to collect knowledge might be a great first step.

Re:Retire This Idea: Scientific Knowledge Structured as “Lit... by Retric on Monday May 04, 2015 @05:23PM (#9489300)
Honestly, University's or other places where people in diverse fields collaborate seem like the solution to this problem. Because, there are a lot of fields out there and 2^N sucks, but conversations take less effort than a deep dive. Bell labs comes to mind as a private sector version of this.
Re:Retire This Idea: Scientific Knowledge Structured as “Lit... by ThomPete on Monday May 04, 2015 @05:31PM (#9489347)
The problem is that this collaboration does not happen because people are mostly "trapped" within their own field. My point is simply to remove the idea of literature as the container of knowledge as if knowledge is like literature (i.e. once written saved as a piece of knowledge)

Or put another way.

Instead of modeling knowledge after the way our brain best deal with structure we should leave the structuring to the machines and start approaching it more like an organism that can be explored. I think we are bound to see something along those lines soon.