Re:Anders Hejlsberg – What brought about the birth of the CL...
by frik on Sunday May 03, 2015 @05:11PM
(#9483062)
Who killed VB6 and thought VB.Net would be a good idea? I remember a long gone Channel 9 video where the VB guys had arguments for .Net and showed a demo of the third part transition tool, that ship as Lite-version with Visual Studio 2002/3.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Anders Hejlsberg – What brought about the birth of the CL...
by shawnb576 on Sunday May 03, 2015 @05:31PM
(#9483158)
The idea was that a converged, single, multi-language runtime and framework was the way to go. This is the way the culture works in Redmond - that's considered "strategic thinking", which is only exists in that bubble. It wasn't that the plan was bad, it's that it was unrealistic to think that the users of a very mature, very scenario-focused product would be happy with a V1 generalized product that was sorta-kinda the same thing. This was obviously false, and I actually fought against the porting tool because I didn't think it would work (it didn't), and just piss people off (it did). To keep VB6 alive until VB.net matured is anthetical to the way the place runs. Newer is _always_ better, even if it's not, and there lacked any incentive in the comp system for people to take care of the existing userbase. So, that's what happened.
Re:Anders Hejlsberg – What brought about the birth of the CL...
by pron on Monday May 04, 2015 @03:13AM
(#9484746)
> there lacked any incentive in the comp system for people to take care of the existing userbase
Can you explain that? Are there incentives to do other stuff?
Re:Anders Hejlsberg – What brought about the birth of the CL...
by shawnb576 on Monday May 04, 2015 @06:23PM
(#9489637)
The basic system - no. As of 2012 when I left, comp was about what your management was interested in. Maybe "take care of existing users" is on your review commitments, but what's really on there if you want to get ahead is: ship features, drive future business, etc. As such people wanted to work on the next new thing, it was relatively bad for careers to be on existing old things. Massive variations between groups, but basically that was the culture.
Re:Anders Hejlsberg – What brought about the birth of the CL...
by frik on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @12:44AM
(#9490878)
Thanks for sharing your experience, it helps to understand some of the business decisions.
Re:Anders Hejlsberg – What brought about the birth of the CL...
by sukilot on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:42PM
(#9484034)
This really puts into focus the meaning of "strategic thinking": abandoning current customers in favor of potential future customers.
Re:Anders Hejlsberg – What brought about the birth of the CL...
by cm2187 on Sunday May 03, 2015 @07:11PM
(#9483449)
Honestly there were a lot of bad design decisions in VB6 that needed breaking backward compatibility. Requiring to use "SET" to assign objects, parameters being BYREF by default, inconsistent base (1 or 0) for various collections. VB.net isn't that difficult to migrate to and when one gets used to it, it's hard to have much nostalgia for VB6.