News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Energy by colinsidoti on Friday May 01, 2015 @12:57AM (#9469548)
One thing that might go overlooked: Load shifting could, in theory, lower electric bills such that there's ROI without solar panels.

---

Edit for why: On-demand power is expensive. "Spinning up" additional power during the day is more expensive than having certain types of power generation running all the time. In theory, pumping power into a battery at night during non-peak hours will cost less than consuming directly off the grid during the day.

I'm forgetting all the details of energy economics, but IIRC there would also be far less emissions by having consistent load on the grid all day long. Something about the ones we "spin up" also being the worst for the environment.

Re:Tesla Energy by URSpider94 on Friday May 01, 2015 @02:01AM (#9469757)
I could do this today. With my current time-of-use electric rate, I pay an average of $0.25/kWh more for peak power than I do for off-peak [the differential is larger in the summer, smaller in the winter]. If I shift 8kWh per day, then I would generate positive ROI in less than five years.

Your edit is spot-on. Utilities typically use natural gas "peaker" plants to meet mid-day spikes in demand, while nuclear plants are better suited to running at a steady state.

Re:Tesla Energy by mrfusion on Friday May 01, 2015 @08:01AM (#9470747)
And you'd get a free backup power system too. That's worth something.
Re:Tesla Energy by bryondowd on Friday May 01, 2015 @10:05AM (#9471313)
Is 8kWh/day realistic? I'm curious, honestly wouldn't know.

Seems like that would be charging and discharging 80% of the 10kWh battery's capacity every day. Would that affect lifespan? Also, it would seem to render the device less useful as a battery backup system during most of the day, since it would be mostly depleted.

Re:Tesla Energy by URSpider94 on Friday May 01, 2015 @08:01PM (#9475268)
My home uses about 1000 kWh per month, so shifting 8kWh per day of my in-house demand is feasible. However, there's really no correlation with my usage, since I can just push and pull that power from the grid, as if I had a solar or wind generator.

Lithium batteries are fairly tolerant of deep discharge, but yes, I would expect that the pack would be worn out after max 7-10 years if used like this.

Yes, using the pack like this would make it much less useful for battery back-up, but where I live (SF Bay Area), I haven't had an outage that lasted longer than 2 hours since we moved into our house, and this would cover the basics (probably everything but A/C) for that time. You could always split the difference, for example using 4 kWh per day -- this would pay still give you 6kWh+ of backup power and let you get the battery at half off or better.

Re:Tesla Energy by hackerboos on Friday May 01, 2015 @03:26AM (#9469975)
Economy 7 power is significantly cheaper in the UK than peak power. Charging overnight in the E7 period could save money long term depending on the lifetime of the battery.
Re:Tesla Energy by IanCal on Friday May 01, 2015 @04:38AM (#9470162)
I did a quick bit of calculation on this. Assuming you use 10KWh per day and a perfect battery:

Economy 7 KWh cost : 8.4p (Best deal I saw was 9.4 for me, but this was a figure on MSE)

Standard tariff KWh cost : 14.5p (Best deal I saw was ~12 for me, but this was a figure on MSE)

That'd be a £306/year cost on economy 7 and £530 on a standard, taking some more extreme figures.

A $3500 (~£2300) battery would then have a payoff time of about 10 years.

Using the other figures (9.4 and 12) gives a £95/year saving or a ~25 year payoff.

That's also assuming the batter is perfect, no extra costs in installation and you use exactly 10KWh per day. Economy 7 tariffs are about 22p/unit during the day so any overrun would quickly eat into savings.

I do think this is all very interesting, but with current offers in the UK it doesn't look too beneficial. However, if someone were to offer cheaper rates on a more granular level (rather than always midnight-7am) then this could work out better. Perhaps an energy company owned battery would be a good idea, they offer a flat rate back to you knowing they can smooth things out.

Re:Tesla Energy by danielweber on Friday May 01, 2015 @11:27AM (#9472044)
You are planning to charge the thing overnight and use it exclusively during the day, nearly exhausting it each time?

The battery is going to wear out well before 10 years. If you oversize your battery so you are only pulling out half the charge in the battery[1], you can probably get 1500 cycles out of it[2]. That's still less than 5 years.

(This is a common pattern if you are trying to price-compare an electric car to a gas car. For the electric car, the electricity cost is a rounding error compared to the capital cost of the battery, so you can just about assume electricity is free, and worry instead about how long the battery will last.)

You will get a much bigger bang-for-the-buck by demand-shifting: if the biggest load is cooling your building in the heat of the day, run the A/C overnight to superchill a heat sink that can be accessed during the day. No battery installation needed.

[1] Toyota did this with the Prius. They purposefully did not use the full range of the battery because they wanted the battery to last 7+ years.

[2] http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/how_to_prolong_li...

Re:Tesla Energy by kbenson on Friday May 01, 2015 @02:15PM (#9473434)
It comes standard with a 10 year warranty, with an optional 10 year extension. If they don't have different numbers than you, I don't see why they would even attempt that.
Re:Tesla Energy by danielweber on Friday May 01, 2015 @04:22PM (#9474254)
Warrantied to what, though. That you can still get 20% capacity levels in year 10, or that it will still turn on? This might be considered "normal wear and tear."

3000 deep cycles is really pushing what the industry knows to be state of the art.

Maybe they are just taking the economic chance that most people won't be deeply cycling these batteries, and planning to do replacements for those who actually put it through its paces.

Re:Tesla Energy by kbenson on Friday May 01, 2015 @06:01PM (#9474799)
> Warrantied to what, though.

That's a good question, and it makes a big difference.

> That you can still get 20% capacity levels in year 10, or that it will still turn on? This might be considered "normal wear and tear."

Given that you can optionally warranty it for an additional 10 years, I doubt it's nearly that bad. If people are confused as to how they how they hope achieve 10 years reliability, and they are willing to warranty 20 years, they must have something up their sleeves.

> 3000 deep cycles is really pushing what the industry knows to be state of the art

I suspect that the powerwall's true capacity is higher than it's rating, and it uses that reserve so it's not doing deep cycles, similar to another commenter's assertion to how the Prius gets it's 7+ year rating,

> Maybe they are just taking the economic chance that most people won't be deeply cycling these batteries, and planning to do replacements for those who actually put it through its paces.

I think a combination of most users not fully cycling every day, extra reserve capacity to keep it from deep cycling, and some subset of people not using failing warranty conditions may all contribute.

Re:Tesla Energy by aidos on Friday May 01, 2015 @06:27AM (#9470473)
Oh interesting, I hadn't considered the aspect of charging overnight while it's cheaper. Of course, the moment it starts to get popular the energy companies will be eating that particular cake too, I'm sure. Sounds like right now there's not a huge margin anyway.

I guess the energy companies have a financial incentive to run a more consistent supply if it could reduce the peak load.

Just reminded me of a brilliant BBC documentary from a while back - The Secret Life of the National Grid. I think you probably have to piece it together from clips on youtube these days.

Re:Tesla Energy by CHY872 on Friday May 01, 2015 @08:41AM (#9470877)
If you get 90% charge/discharge efficiency, you're multiplying the economy 7 tariff by 1/0.81 = 1.23456790 (so close) so it's more like 12.5 years, and a bit less compelling.
Re:Tesla Energy by lsaferite on Friday May 01, 2015 @09:09AM (#9471001)
That is of course ignoring the other aspects, like battery backup for the house, better for the environment (?), the ability to do solar tie in, and any possible government incentives.
Re:Tesla Energy by CHY872 on Saturday May 02, 2015 @08:14AM (#9476781)
In the UK power cuts are very rare in most places (and generators are cheap), so it's not a huge advantage. The enviroment factor is at best tenuous due to 20% of energy stored lost as heat and high energy requirements for producing the batteries; and in any case unilateral green action makes no difference.

The solar tie in is quite nice, but current feed-in tariffs are huge in the UK (30p per kWh perhaps), so you're getting more out of paying it back than you would for storing.

Government incentives obviously change the calculations, but there aren't any at the moment.

Re:Tesla Energy by tootie on Friday May 01, 2015 @09:26AM (#9471092)
Big cities are prone to brown outs on hot days in the summer due to air conditioners. The 2003 European heat wave killed thousands1. I could imagine mayors mandating use of this kind of technology in apartment buildings. Let them charge overnight to offset peak usage. You'd cover 100 or more people at a time.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2003_European_heat_wave

Re:Tesla Energy by TillE on Friday May 01, 2015 @11:17AM (#9471961)
Normal homes in Europe simply do not have air conditioners, not even in southern Europe. So the electricity is irrelevant.
Re:Tesla Energy by _delirium on Friday May 01, 2015 @03:53PM (#9474076)
That's no longer really true. A/C units are in the past 10 years getting quite common in the hot parts of Europe now. In the '90s fewer than 10% of households had them in Italy or Spain, but that has jumped to nearly 50% now. People do use it a lot less, though: they are typically individual units, not central A/C, and only used for short periods on very hot days, not run continuously with a thermostat setting.
Re:Tesla Energy by kmod on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:23AM (#9469644)
If what you say is true, then with better economies of scale and longer investment horizons, utilities would quickly erase any peak-vs-non-peak arbitrage opportunities.
Re:Tesla Energy by colinsidoti on Friday May 01, 2015 @02:23AM (#9469801)
It's hard to wrap your head around all the challenges in energy. If you're REALLY good at it you can find some incredible arbitrage opportunities...see Enron.

Consider the power output characteristics of some common energy sources:

Gas, Nuclear, Hydro, Wind, Solar

Our "sustainable" sources of power - hydro, wind, and solar - are also the ones with the most irregular and unpredictable power output. This creates a problem, because even if there was enough cumulative power output from sustainable sources today, it most likely wouldn't align with our usage schedule.

So there are two solutions: 1) find a way to map the sustainable power output to our usage 2) find a way to store energy

Today, our most readily available form of energy storage is gas. We just put it in a container and burn it when we need to. "Spin it up," if you will.

An alternative to gas is a crazy network of Powerwalls. The hope is that, eventually, instead of spinning up gas turbines during peak demand, we can just draw from our Powerwall.

There was another alternative on HN recently. Basically a super-deep hole in the ground with super heavy object falling into it, but suspended by a rope. You run a motor to lift the object during off-peak hours, then let it fall and spin a generator during peak hours. I can't find it right now but I remember thinking they had a great name.

---

That said, power output is only part of the problem. If you're looking to factor the potential disappearance of arbitrage opportunities into your buying decision, you also need to consider the time until regulatory changes allow for perfect pricing, and the time until these Powerwalls have precise enough information to decide exactly when to draw from the grid versus the battery.

tl;dr: "quickly" is probably optimistic. We're a long ways away from economies of scale.

Re:Tesla Energy by danmaz74 on Friday May 01, 2015 @03:48AM (#9470039)
Actually, hydro with reservoirs is not just very predictable, it's the least expensive source to turn on-off-half on demand, or even to run in reverse as a storage mechanism with some upgrades.
Re:Tesla Energy by jimmcslim on Friday May 01, 2015 @07:53AM (#9470713)
> There was another alternative on HN recently. Basically a super-deep hole in the ground with super heavy object falling into it, but suspended by a rope.

Or a train going up and down a hill...

http://www.aresnorthamerica.com/

Both are basically the same concept as pumped hydro which has been in use for a long time... pump water up a hill when energy is cheap, let it fall down and turn a turbine when energy is expensive. And hey, if it rains, free energy!

The rail/hole in the ground approach have the advantage of taking up less land I suppose, but I suspect are less efficient.

Re:Tesla Energy by TheLoneWolfling on Friday May 01, 2015 @08:02AM (#9470750)
Gravity batteries have really low power densities, in general.

Now, vanadium-redox flow batteries... That's always been my pet large-scale energy storage. That or hydro.

Re:Tesla Energy by tfinniga on Friday May 01, 2015 @04:56AM (#9470206)
was it a gravity battery?
Re:Tesla Energy by epistasis on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:28AM (#9469655)
Different entities have different risk profiles, and utilities are extremely conservative. It will probably be profitable to load shift for several years before utilities start to do it on their own. And even then, it may take quite some time before there's enough battery capacity for all the fluctuations to even out.
Re:Tesla Energy by gutnor on Friday May 01, 2015 @05:18AM (#9470277)
Utilities with electricity production are more conservative because they have technical limitation due to the infrastructure they run.

However, there is a bunch of companies that buy and sell electricity on the open market, so they have a direct financial interest to play with this arbitrage.

In the UK, another reader has calculated the best case scenario was profitability in about 10 years. (his numbers ring true to me, I calculated recently that there was no reason to take an economy 7 contract for my electricity usage using similar data) That's a lot of time even in the utility market. So if batteries not attached to solar panel are going to be profitable (in the UK), that would be a future generation.

Re:Tesla Energy by toomuchtodo on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:38AM (#9469696)
> utilities would quickly erase any peak-vs-non-peak arbitrage opportunities.

Probably right around the same time they're no longer necessary, as the cost of distribute solar continues to plummet. Its actually truly amazing how quickly the price continues to drop for panels each year.

Re:Tesla Energy by eru on Friday May 01, 2015 @04:30AM (#9470139)
Depends on country. I doubt you could ever run, say, Germany or Britain on locally produced solar power.
Re:Tesla Energy by matt4077 on Friday May 01, 2015 @05:14AM (#9470264)
There also wind... But solar already provides quite a substantial contribution in Germany. See this live chart: https://www.energy-charts.de/power.htm.

Considering the rate at which solar power is getting cheaper, I'd say a solar power based economy is within reach.

Re:Tesla Energy by kamikrazy on Friday May 01, 2015 @07:54AM (#9470718)
Great link. It's also amazing how Solar power generation falls significantly in the winter months. For instance, December output is less than 10% of June!

Chart here: Check out monthly/weekly energy production for 2014 https://www.energy-charts.de/energy.htm

Re:Tesla Energy by eru on Saturday May 02, 2015 @08:46PM (#9479249)
Sure, wind, geothermal, nuclear etc.
Re:Tesla Energy by maccam94 on Friday May 01, 2015 @05:07AM (#9470237)
Re:Tesla Energy by toomuchtodo on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:43PM (#9473175)
But you could run it on a combination of onshore wind, offshore wind, distributed solar, utility solar, and energy storage (ie Tesla's Utility Storage solution).
Re:Tesla Energy by eatmyshorts on Friday May 01, 2015 @03:46AM (#9470034)
Yep. This is targeted at ERCOT as much as it is targeted at the home consumer.

http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/Bring-on-the-ene...

Re:Tesla Energy by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 01, 2015 @05:36AM (#9470330)
Can grid arbitrage and time-shifting solar co-exist? Some clever software might be able to predict your energy demand (e.g. based on seasons and past usage patterns) and your likely solar output (this time based on seasons and weather forecasts) and make the maximum use out of the battery.

I'm also wondering if the same software is going to be rolled out to Tesla's cars so that they act like Tesla Energy when plugged in overnight.

Re:Tesla Energy by amass on Friday May 01, 2015 @04:47AM (#9470184)
Doesn't this ignore completely the efficiency of the batteries? These batteries aren't ideal, you won't get out 100% of the energy that is put in. I don't know the efficiency rating, and I haven't done the math, but I suspect that the losses will cut into the savings significantly.
Re:Tesla Energy by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 01, 2015 @05:06AM (#9470233)
The page says >92% round trip efficiency. Since they also claim that they're selling them to utilities for exactly this purpose I'd guess it's theoretically possible and probably comes down to the pricing structure offered to consumers in your local area to buy and sell to the grid.