News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Energy by vanadium on Friday May 01, 2015 @12:38AM (#9469467)
$3,500. That's crazy good for your average household, on par with natural gas backup generators with half the logistics. I might just be ordering sooner rather than later given some of the grid instabilities in my area over the past year, and through the mid-term in preparation for a solar switch here in Chicago.

While Elon might not be the best orator, you can easily derive his authenticity and belief in the product by virtue of his delivery. You can't do that with accuracy in the canned and carefully rehearsed.

Re:Tesla Energy by tlb on Friday May 01, 2015 @12:58AM (#9469551)
$3500 doesn't include the inverter or transfer switch. Transfer switch is maybe $200, and it's not clear what the inverter might cost. It's a nontrivial part, since it would be responsible for daily cycle estimation and cost optimization.

For $3300 you can get a 17 kW generator with inverter and transfer switch [0], which will run for days on a house-sized propane tank. At my house in the woods, we do sometimes get multi-day power outages after storms. Though, to be fair, you need a concrete pad and 30 square feet to install the generator.

It doesn't seem like a competitive backup system, but load shifting is still appealing.

[0] http://www.costco.com/Honeywell-17-kW-Automatic-Standby-Gene...

Re:Tesla Energy by TaylorAlexander on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:05AM (#9469577)
Some people (like me) are simply unwilling to keep using carbon-based sources of energy. At some point it just feels awful to be contributing to such a terrible problem. I'm counting the days till I can sell my worn out petrol car and get an electric car. If I had a home and dollars, I'd want one of these batteries.
Re:Tesla Energy by SCAQTony on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:17AM (#9469625)
Batteries are not clean; lithium mines are one ugly slight and recycling is difficult: http://whenonearth.net/awe-inspiring-aerial-images-worlds-me...

In my clueless opinion these batteries should be used strategically in places where solar, wind, and hydro power are unavailable.

Re:Tesla Energy by zachalexander on Friday May 01, 2015 @08:42AM (#9470888)
> Batteries are not clean; lithium mines are one ugly slight and recycling is difficult:

You are conflating two senses of "clean" that are radically different in meaning and importance.

-- Fossil fuels are !clean in that they may destroy all life on earth via catastrophic climate change.

-- Lithium mines are !clean in that they present waste disposal challenges and some people find them "ugly".

It's like saying "your non–blood diamond is still a blood diamond because the jeweler got a papercut while handling the documentation".

Re:Tesla Energy by TaylorAlexander on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:34AM (#9469677)
Whether or not batteries are "clean" seems to be a matter of opinion. My understanding is that lithium mines aren't inherently unclean, but many current lithium mines are unclean. The idea is that it is good to support bad tech, since public pressure could ensure it is clean. That's unlike fossil fuels, which can never be clean. All that is just hearsay though, I can't confirm its accuracy.

Still, some might say that carbon pollution and groundwater pollution are different problems. One may decide the trade off between one and the other is worthwhile.

Re:Tesla Energy by Zombieball on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:30AM (#9469662)
Yes the real breakthrough tech needed is a new battery! Which hopefully Tesla is on track to develop,because as is, electric cars are just not scalable.
Re:Tesla Energy by TaylorAlexander on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:38AM (#9469695)
People say that, but from what I've heard there is plenty of lithium in the world to increase use 20% every year for 30 years before we need to get more creative in how we mine it. That's a huge total increase and means that electric cars totally are scalable.

Do you have information supporting the idea that electric cars aren't scalable? My understanding is that they definitely are scalable.

Re:Tesla Energy by crystal_crook on Friday May 01, 2015 @04:39PM (#9474366)
There is definitely enough lithium in the world to increase the production of lithium-ion EVs. From how I understand it it though, it is unlikely that lithium-ion EV could replace every car currently running in the world. http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2010/ph240/eason2/
Re:Tesla Energy by CamperBob2 on Friday May 01, 2015 @03:05AM (#9469920)
Charging is where the scaling problems come in. If everybody in your neighborhood plugs in their Tesla at their home at night and/or at their office during the day, it will likely cause brownouts and blackouts in areas with grid service that's already marginal for current demand. Hence Musks's interest in load-shifting technology.
Re:Tesla Energy by will_hughes on Friday May 01, 2015 @03:38AM (#9470007)
Utilities have existing techniques for distributing that load. They already work with smelters and other large power users to coordinate their power demands.

In some places utilities are offering discounted electricity prices if the car charging infrastructure is hooked up to their smart metering/control system. This allows the company to signal when cars should start/stop charging.

There's no reason they can't work with car makers to introduce two way signalling between the charging infrastructure and the grid - the car can tell the grid that it needs to use X kW by Y time, and the grid can communicate the current permitted load.

Potentially with some option for the customer to pay a premium to charge immediately at a higher rate.

Re:Tesla Energy by Shivetya on Friday May 01, 2015 @07:02AM (#9470558)
it isn't so much how many people charging, its the ability of people to charge where they live and the lack of ability to truly quick charge the battery.

As in, damn the kids left the car unplugged and I have to work. even thirty minutes at a super charger is not a good solution.

So it comes down to a compromise, a good range extender technology and batteries for the majority of driving. That until truly faster charging can be achieved with house hold wiring.

Re:Tesla Energy by TeMPOraL on Friday May 01, 2015 @11:03AM (#9471835)
> As in, damn the kids left the car unplugged and I have to work. even thirty minutes at a super charger is not a good solution.

I don't see this as something to worry about - it's just a household habit problem. Pretty much every new device introduces some, and people quickly adapt to use the device properly.

Re:Tesla Energy by dpark on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:44PM (#9473181)
The argument is silly. The kids could also forget (or just not bother) to put gas in the car and leave it on empty. Yet strangely we manage to make do with gas-powered cars.
Re:Tesla Energy by spacefight on Friday May 01, 2015 @08:49AM (#9470916)
Solar power, local wind turbines, , etc. We need to get off the grid and start working on isolated energy systems.
Re:Tesla Energy by higherpurpose on Friday May 01, 2015 @06:02AM (#9470407)
You're assuming a world where 80% of the people already have an EV. You don't think most of those people will also have solar panels and battery backups at home (from which to charge the car at night).
Re:Tesla Energy by Vik1ng on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:18AM (#9469627)
I feel like a backup generator is the last place where I would make my decisions based on the environment. I mean how long is it actually going to be active? Also batteries aren't exactly environment friendly either.
Re:Tesla Energy by TaylorAlexander on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:36AM (#9469687)
That may well be how you feel, but lately I feel like any burning of petrol is just disgusting (though I still do it as I cannot afford alternatives at the moment). I want to completely divest from fossil fuels, even for intermittent use. That's as much for the social value of saying "yeah I don't use fossil fuels and it's great" as it is for the environmental impact. I want to try all this tech to be an early adopter and help people prove it out to the rest of the world.
Re:Tesla Energy by beachstartup on Friday May 01, 2015 @08:02AM (#9470748)
> that may well be how you feel, but lately I feel like any burning of petrol is just disgusting (though I still do it as I cannot afford alternatives at the moment).

LOL. that's some serious self-delusion. some of the best i've ever seen in the wild.

the alternative to fossil fuels is free -- just don't use them. your feet are free. bikes are almost free and subsidized in many cities.

the reason you use it is not because you "can't afford the alternative" but because you find the convenience and utility quite high, i.e. WORTH THE COST, compared to walking your ass around town and going cold in the winter, just like everyone else.

fundamentally this is a problem of economics, not of really really really wanting to do the right thing.

Re:Tesla Energy by pikachu_is_cool on Friday May 01, 2015 @05:03AM (#9470223)
That's ridiculous.... the only way to actually achieve that is to abstain from all plastic consumption, and abstain from all electricity consumption.
Re:Tesla Energy by colechristensen on Friday May 01, 2015 @03:14AM (#9469936)
Isn't that a bit of an overreaction?

You might want to reevaluate any moral position you have where a significant basis of your values is the ability to brag about them. I would be fairly disgusted if someone said a significant amount of the reason they're so devout in their religion was so they could boast about it with their peers.

Re:Tesla Energy by rosser on Friday May 01, 2015 @03:21AM (#9469958)
I didn't read the GP comment as "bragging" so much as wanting to be an existence proof that it's possible to live a modern life without (directly) burning any dinosaurs.
Re:Tesla Energy by TaylorAlexander on Friday May 01, 2015 @02:46PM (#9473650)
This. I want to be an early tester so I can relate to others the value of the tech.
Re:Tesla Energy by darkstar999 on Friday May 01, 2015 @10:19AM (#9471441)
How do you think every data center in the world is backed up for power? Diesel generators. You'd have to quit using the internet until a different power backup method is adopted.
Re:Tesla Energy by latch on Friday May 01, 2015 @02:54AM (#9469899)
Your comments vex me. I don't mean for this to be an attack, but clearly you ARE willing, so why would you say you aren't? We all want to do more.
Re:Tesla Energy by andygates on Friday May 01, 2015 @10:16AM (#9471401)
Fumes from backup generators are problematic without the environmental considerations: they're seldom-run and often minimally maintained, and there are exhaust-gas fatalities most winters.
Re:Tesla Energy by higherpurpose on Friday May 01, 2015 @05:58AM (#9470397)
> Also batteries aren't exactly environment friendly either.

Kind of a straw man argument. They are still far more environmentally friendly than gas or coal.

Re:Tesla Energy by lmm on Friday May 01, 2015 @09:59AM (#9471271)
If you're talking about cost/benefit that's a reasonable calculation to make.

If you're talking about being "disgusted" and wanting to completely avoid polluting at any cost, not so much. Sacred values and all that.

Re:Tesla Energy by Yaggo on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:19AM (#9469629)
That's crazy cheap. The closest competitor which comes into my mind is probably SMA Sunny Boy Smart inverter with lithium battery, costing more than double while offering only 2 kWh of energy (but includes a solar inverter).
Re:Tesla Energy by fredkbloggs on Friday May 01, 2015 @10:14AM (#9471380)
It's not crazy cheap at all. The incumbent technology here is flooded lead-acid, a proven solution used everywhere from telco COs to forklifts to off-grid cabins for over a century. Industrial FLA batteries (the top grade, longest-lasting, etc.) retail for somewhere around $250 per kWh, and typically have warranties ranging from 7 to 10 years. We don't know exactly what the differences are between Tesla's two offerings, but even if we assume that the 10 kWh model is rated for continuous deep cycling for 10 years (their language suggests it may not be), we would still have to justify the $350 per kWh price tag. The other model comes in at $428. So this is somewhere around 50% more costly than existing solutions with a similar expected life span. The limitation of 2 kW continuous power is also a major drawback relative to FLA solutions, which can typically provide at least 200 A (around 10 kW at 48V, much more at the higher voltages the Tesla unit operates at). Since the Li-ion battery is maintenance-free, a better comparison might be AGM or other VRLA technologies, which are slightly more expensive than FLA, but still less expensive than the Tesla units.

Since no inverter, grid-tie transfer relay, or charge controllers are included in this unit, those will all be additional costs just as they would with any other batteries. And it appears you will be limited to a few inverters and probably a micro-inverter PV design; this is purely a grid-tie-only design. Existing battery technologies can do all of that, but they also give you much broader flexibility for other applications and system designs.

I'm not sure why I would want this. I'd be paying above the odds for some serious design constraints and limitations I wouldn't otherwise have. Tesla seem to be taking a very different approach from their launch of the Roadster, which was a super-premium offering at a super-premium price. This is a modest offering at a premium price in relative terms, but low enough in absolute terms to appeal to people who aren't well-versed in the field. Their success will probably depend on installers deciding it's easier to just take people's money and sell them the Tesla than to educate their customers and give them the best value available. Not a bad gamble, for Tesla.

Re:Tesla Energy by Yaggo on Saturday May 09, 2015 @12:41PM (#9516859)
I meant "crazy cheap" as lithium-based product, i.e. compared to other lithium chemistry storages. Sure, lead-acid technology still offers better capacity/price ratio, but lithium chemistry has many advantages especially when used as domestic energy buffer for sun: longer lifespan (more cycles) in daily use, more peak power, wall mountable / lighter, etc.
Re:Tesla Energy by greedo on Friday May 01, 2015 @10:58AM (#9471788)
I don't think most households (in the US at least) could run off a single unit. You would need three units, and they would only give you 1 days capacity, compared to a natural gas generator which could keep running indefinitely.

http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=97&t=3

[deleted]
Re:Tesla Energy by vanadium on Friday May 01, 2015 @12:49AM (#9469526)
Playing the margins in my home would probably save $25/mo against a $100/mo charge, I'm spitballing.

Our local utility here in Chicago, ComEd, is starting to roll out to the population what flux in energy usage actually means on a granular basis (hourly, daily, monthly, seasonally) while offering incentives to change their consumption patterns.

Re:Tesla Energy by toomuchtodo on Friday May 01, 2015 @01:21AM (#9469637)
I too have ComED (Schaumburg). From midnight to 5am daily, I can get power for 1 cent/kwh. If I were to shift all of my consumption to that time period, its effectively free.
Re:Tesla Energy by joezydeco on Friday May 01, 2015 @08:56AM (#9470946)
I've been on ComEd RRTP for 6 years now and I've been wanting a nicer way to shift load or arbitrage price drops.

The Telsa device, as others have mentioned, seems like a rebranded solar storage device. I suppose the intelligence would be in the inverter/grid cutout mechanism anyway.

This system would run my home for about 8 hours in the winter and 4 in the summer before emptying, so I would need a lot more smarts in the box to try and anticipate price spikes without running out.

Re:Tesla Energy by toomuchtodo on Friday May 01, 2015 @10:45AM (#9471674)
> This system would run my home for about 8 hours in the winter and 4 in the summer before emptying, so I would need a lot more smarts in the box to try and anticipate price spikes without running out.

Most new grid-tie inverters can be controlled from a computer either over IP or a serial interface; you could fairly trivially control the flow of power by polling your electric provider's website (I scrape the RRTP API for current and future pricing data every 60 seconds) and commanding your inverter based on that.

Re:Tesla Energy by joezydeco on Friday May 01, 2015 @11:10AM (#9471899)
I don't have a lot of experience with those inverters. How many cycles do you drop when switching over?

My first idea was to create a system that watched the immediate price as well as the day ahead AND the weather forecast to try and predict the best time to stay off the grid, but that's a little too ambitious.

My current idea is to grab my 5-minute history over the last year or two and model it against a simple buy-low-sell-high threshold. It should at least tell me how much the system would save each month.

(BTW about your earlier post, even if supply is 1c/kWh, there's still the delivery charge and taxes. I think supply needs to drop to something like -3.5c/kWh before the juice is "free". It's happened only once or twice in my history with the system.).