News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Engineer’s Lament by scarmig on Monday April 27, 2015 @04:06PM (#9448762)
The article suggests, though, that other compact cars had a similar bumper and fuel tank design, including sharp objects near the tank. The issue wasn't unique or exceptional. The one cherry-picked metric that came out of it was that the Pinto experienced puncture for rear end collisions at a marginally lower speed than other cars, and, after regulations were put in place to increase that minimum, fatality rates were not affected at all.

Any fatality effect is noise compared to the other causal factors in fatal accidents: highway design, speed, weight of the objects of collision, level of alcohol intoxication. And even factors within Ford's control trumped the Pinto gas tank design in importance. It's just that one particularly grisly and tragic death makes for some really bad PR.

Disclaimer: I've got no knowledge of the Pinto case besides hearsay and what's in this article.

Re:The Engineer’s Lament by sitkack on Monday April 27, 2015 @07:04PM (#9449666)
Shouldn't you have put the disclaimer first? Gladwell has cherry picked reality to weave the narrative he wants.
Re:The Engineer’s Lament by hnnewguy on Monday April 27, 2015 @11:49PM (#9450461)
I trust Gladwell and his research and interview access more than I trust your blanket, ad hominem dismissal of his work.
Re:The Engineer’s Lament by thaumasiotes on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @05:05AM (#9451111)
Unfortunately, this attitude is unjustified. Gladwell does research, but he'd be basically as reliable if he didn't bother. He doesn't use or understand the research he does.
Re:The Engineer’s Lament by jesushn on Monday April 27, 2015 @06:11PM (#9449413)
> Disclaimer: I've got no knowledge of the Pinto case besides hearsay and what's in this article.

In that case, please don't post. Sharing what you know to be unreliable information makes everyone dumber.

That's not meant as a personal attack. Lots of folks do it, and you're at least good enough to admit it. But instead of admitting that you're making noise, why not just... not make noise?