News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Bot Bubble: Click Farms Have Inflated Social Media Cu... by jqm on Sunday April 26, 2015 @02:15PM (#9442697)
Heh, cool stats lesson. Always learn something new on HN.

The only thing I didn't catch was how they were to figure out which of the accounts in the sample were fake.

Re:The Bot Bubble: Click Farms Have Inflated Social Media Cu... by dredmorbius on Sunday April 26, 2015 @03:13PM (#9442905)
You might have missed: "scoring of accounts based on some sort of activity profile."

Fake accounts are almost certainly going to have characteristics which distinguish them from legitimate ones, and likely a quantitative, manual, or combined assessment might determine that. Points to consider:

⚫ Photo images. Search for duplicates or analyze for manipulation.

⚫ Correlation with other data sources. Real names, Social Security, marketing, and numerous databases exist which tend to point to more legitimate profiles.

⚫ Direct contact. Set up events, meet-ups, special purchase offers, etc., or otherwise try to elicit direct action. Even statistically differential response rates are useful.

⚫ Social graph. Real people _interact_ with other real people, and there's a web of trust or certification which can be imputed or determined.

⚫ Network profiles. Identifying large numbers of accounts with similar or suspicious profiles _and_ originating from the same or adjacent network addresses (CIDR/BGP block), or from known nonresidential space that's _not_ a generally-used proxy, would be a strong indicator. If proxy use continues to climb, that's going to be less useful (and I suspect this will be the case).

Tests along these or similar lines could be used to generate more general scoring algorithms for identifying suspect accounts.

Re:The Bot Bubble: Click Farms Have Inflated Social Media Cu... by troels on Sunday April 26, 2015 @03:24PM (#9442950)
With a small enough volume, you could do manual inspection. I'm guessing most fake accounts are easy to spot by an actual human, putting an effort into it.
Re:The Bot Bubble: Click Farms Have Inflated Social Media Cu... by dredmorbius on Sunday April 26, 2015 @04:27PM (#9443140)
Pretty much that. 100 accounts could be reviewed by one person pretty easily in a day or few, 1,000 by a small team, specifically trained and applying consistent standards, with cross-checks.

Once you've done the manual assessments, deriving heuristics for broader estimates are also possible. The key is having training data of known classified accounts.