News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by fuzzmeister on Sunday November 15, 2009 @09:39PM (#943815)
While I've heard many people dismiss such personality tests, I found that the description of my role variant (INTJ, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastermind_(Role_Variant)) described me extraordinarily well. I'd be interested to hear whether other people think the same thing about their respective personality type descriptions.
Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by jpeterson on Sunday November 15, 2009 @09:58PM (#943835)
Not to belabor the point here, but I think you're falling for the old horoscope trick. These categories are so broad, and the concept of personality so amorphous, that you would probably find that most of them describe you "extraordinarily well".
Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by branden on Sunday November 15, 2009 @10:11PM (#943856)
Have you actually read the descriptions? They are concrete and specific. They don't leave much room for overlap. For example, compare http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ENTP#ENTP_characteristics and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ENTJ#ENTJ_characteristics
Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by jpeterson on Sunday November 15, 2009 @10:28PM (#943868)
Yes, I have read on this particular test in the past. And I see a lot of room for people of many different personality types to believe that they fall into a large number of the categories, especially if they have been presented with their category membership following a seemingly scientific test.
Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by orangecat on Monday November 16, 2009 @12:01AM (#943962)
And I see a lot of room for people of many different personality types to believe that they fall into a large number of the categories

That's not my experience. The INTP description fits me almost exactly. Change one of the indicators and the description is partially accurate but with clear discrepancies; change two or more and it's not even close.

Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by unperson on Monday November 16, 2009 @11:44PM (#945975)
Sure, if you're only reading a paragraph or two about a given personality type, it might seem like the words would apply to anyone. In my experience (and most others it seems), if you take the test honestly and actually read several page reports explaining intricate details of the personality type, you would be very suprised how accurate it is. If you're expecting to learn what your favorite ice cream flavor or movie should be, then of course you will end up disappointed about how 'broad' it is and that it didn't describe you in that manner of detail.
Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by richardw on Sunday November 15, 2009 @11:47PM (#943949)
So then the same people that 'fall' for this test should be the ones who fall for horoscope tests?

With such a lot of intellectual suspicion, I'd guess you're an INTP or similar ;)

Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by DenisM on Monday November 16, 2009 @12:53AM (#944008)
As an example:

  If you're pretty add 1, otherwise add 0.
  If you're smart add 10, otherwise add 0
  If you're kind add 100, otherwise add 0

  Result of the test: if you have accumulated 111, 
  you're known among your friends as a beautiful,
  big-hearted genius.
Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by branden on Sunday November 15, 2009 @09:42PM (#943820)
Reading the description of my type for the first time after eye-rolling my way through a test was a bizarre experience. Its accuracy made me suspect that there was something to it.
Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by celoyd on Sunday November 15, 2009 @09:48PM (#943825)
I think they’re mainly dismissing their big-picture usefulness, not whether they describe you well.

You could also group people according to eye color, and tell people with blue eyes that they probably have light-colored hair, but it wouldn’t necessarily be helping them understand themselves better.

(I’m undecided about how useful these tests are. Just trying to clarify why people might dismiss them.)

Re:Poll: What are the Meyers-Briggs personality types of HN? by metra on Sunday November 15, 2009 @10:10PM (#943855)
Of course it describes you extraordinarily well you Mastermind, you!