??
I frequently work in this area and have not heard these stories. Fraud is always covered on credit cards in the UK (for example), by law, and I'm pretty sure it is on debit as well.
To me, knowing how things usually work in the US - they'll claim it's an on your honor system, and then suddenly it will be "well we think you gave someone your pin so we aren't covering the charges". Conveniently a lawsuit will be more expensive for you, the consumer, than just paying off the fraudulent charges.
In the cases I've heard of it's something like a conman comes to the door, wants money "for a building job" or just "for charity", whatever. Says they'll get you the money from the bank, you give them the card and PIN, the bank then isn't obliged to cover the loss.
The measure in the Lending Code (a UK financial institution code of practice) is that provided you've taken "reasonable care" then they cover frauds; giving someone your PIN or writing it down with your card constitute not taking reasonable care.
That seems quite fair to me.
http://www.choose.net/money/guide/faqs/credit-card-fraud-vic... gives good detail. The Lending Code website doesn't but the full code is at http://www.theukcardsassociation.org.uk/individual/lending-c... with additional info, again the UKCA is an association of credit/debit card issuers in the UK.
But then my (chip) card was cloned to a mag-swipe card and someone attempted to use the clone in an ATM in Canada. I don't really know what happens if someone manages to get your original card and your PIN. AFAICT there's not a lot of fraud that happens this way.
See http://krebsonsecurity.com/all-about-skimmers/ for more on how that happens.
That's not giving it, it's having it taken. What constitutes giving your PIN is someone saying "give me your PIN" and you saying "it's XXXX"; similar provisions apply if you wrote the PIN on the card, or made the PIN available in an obvious place. Basically then you've subverted the potential protection of having a PIN.
In the UK being caught by a skimmer does _NOT_ mean you didn't take reasonable care, your maximum liability by law is £50. See eg http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/3256799.stm.
The only time I've been subject to fraud in recent years, incidentally, was when my card was skimmed in London and then the clone used to attempt an ATM withdrawal in Canada. So clearly the skimmer had seen me enter a PIN, skimmed the magnetic stripe and then sold the details to someone who could use it in a country where those two things were enough.
Needless to say, I got the money back pretty quickly.
I was thinking of the courier fraud but that seems to be covered. The other version of that where they make the victim make a BACS transfer doesn't seem to be covered in the same way.