News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by NateDad on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:19AM (#9432766)
Why do people single out drones? It's not like it would be different if there were a pilot in the thing. I guess it's just good old FUD.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by lostcolony on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:47AM (#9432927)
Because they're concerned that the lack of a pilot, and thus, pilot risk, means the US is more willing to order attacks, since there is no political risk to themselves should something be shot down?

Because they're concerned with the change in warfare this heralds, that we're moving to using technologies that explicitly and autonomously target civilian areas, and deciding who 'enemy combatants' are based on presidential mandate, rather than military engagements, thus setting a terrible precedent for future wars (i.e., if we ever were to find ourselves at war with another country, or even not at war, just that one of our citizens did something against a country, and that country decided to use drones to attack civilian sites, claiming they were attacking enemy combatants, what recourse would we have on the international stage)?

Because they're concerned not so much with drones, but with the precedent set by presidentially ordered assassination, and through means known to cause collateral damage (unlike most alleged assassination attempts prior)?

Because the entire policy has led to intense fear in the areas we're flying drones over; not only are we now inspiring terror in our attempt to find and kill terrorists (...), but we're hurting our chances at winning over 'hearts and minds' and such, and likely raising up a generation in these countries that hates and fears us.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by NateDad on Saturday April 25, 2015 @08:07AM (#9438077)
They're not autonomous. They're piloted by a person. There's very little difference between looking at the screen in the cockpit to know when to drop the bomb, and looking at the screen in the control room.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by lostcolony on Saturday April 25, 2015 @09:31PM (#9440171)
Sorry, I should have been clearer. Yes, it is not truly autonomous, but the mindset of many of those interviewed in the areas we are conducting attacks is basically "death can come down from on high at any moment from clear blue skies". They're not viewing it as "soldiers sometimes come into our village and shoot at suspected terrorists and there are sometimes civilian casualties".

And the tendency is to keep moving to that; even now it's only 'soldier vs civilian' by technicality; as soon as we can replace the soldier at the viewscreen with an algorithm, we likely will.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by tomjen3 on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:10AM (#9433845)
>what recourse would we have on the international stage

An army bigger than the rest of the world, combined?

Winners to what winners want, losers suffers as they must.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by mauricemir on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:46AM (#9433671)
what risk does the average pilot in the USAF face - its not like they are facing any! air assets and any ground assets will have been obliterated.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by poof131 on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:04AM (#9433805)
There is definitely some risk.[1][2] Aviation is inherently a risky endeavor. Operations in war zones make it even more so.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aviation_shootdowns_and... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aviation_accidents_and_...

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by CHY872 on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:25AM (#9433969)
Yes, but it does work out as maybe 20 offensive planes crashing over 10 years and presumably hundreds of thousands of flight hours; and with only a few fatalities at that.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by mc32 on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:53AM (#9433713)
You bring up great points, but I don't think the nyt actually cares. They bring this up because it will resonate and people will read it and that brings them money and it gives them 'Intellectual credibility'. If they actually cared they'd lobby against they'd donate their profits, etc.

They pretend to care about this change in warfare. And, realistically, even if they could affect US policy, there is absolutely no possibility they'd be able to affect how China Russia or Iran decide to use drones. Yes, the US is the one with drones in the news but not the only nation which will ever use them. The cat's out of the bag. It's not like we're going to go back to having people complain about the undue risk we put pilots under when we have less risky alternatives. It's also more costly to put pilots up there, they tire, make mistakes, etc. Drones can keep flying without need for rest.

I'm being cynical, but that's just how it is.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by eli on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:03AM (#9433800)
I think you're just plain wrong. The story is about drones because that is the story. If manned jets had dropped the bomb or paratroopers shot hostages by mistake, there would certainly be a story about that.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by mc32 on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:15AM (#9433891)
Tell me, what's a viable alternative the US or world constituency will accept as viable? I'd like to know what you think might work better, given where we are today.

don't seek out enemies (let bag guys and gals do as they will)

support a network of ground troops and supporting intelligence with consequent monetary and cost in lives and perhaps effectiveness

a multi-decade effort to socially engineer people (address their grievances, if possible, not clear it is, but lets suppose it

good old fashioned carpet bombing

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by anon1385 on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:45AM (#9433652)
You do realise that people were criticising US bombing campaigns and assassinations long long before the use of drones?

People talk about drones because the vast majority of "blowing people up" that the US does these days is done with drones. Before drones people complained about conventional bombers or cluster bombs or land mines or carpet bombing or agent orange. In most of these cases the issue wasn't the technology itself, it was the fact that the technology was being used for mass killing of random civilians. If the US was flying drones about just to take pictures of things people would talk about them far less.

I hope that addresses your concerns.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by CapitalistCartr on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:23AM (#9432788)
If there were a pilot in a plane flying over Yemen or Pakistan bombing people, the outrage would be far worse. I don't see a difference, but many people seem to. Either way, we shouldn't be doing it.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by higherpurpose on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:53AM (#9433716)
For the same reason "mass surveillance" is different than "targeted surveillance". The US government is performing "air strikes" orders of magnitude more often than actual jet-based air strikes, to the point where it now kills people based on surveillance algorithms rather than a proper investigation of the target.

It's going to be yet orders of magnitude worse when autonomous drones arrive (they are probably already in testing now) - and make no mistake, autonomous drones is an idea about as irresistible to the government as mass surveillance. Moore's Law will make autonomous drones too hard to resist.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by CHY872 on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:29AM (#9433997)
> it now kills people based on surveillance algorithms rather than a proper investigation of the target.

False. Algorithms should form part of a proper investigation of the target. Proper use of computers allows you to rule out innocents and provide intelligence in order to pick better targets. They can perform the grunt tasks, collecting and presenting reports and allowing the humans to focus on all the data available in order to more accurately make the decision.

The algorithms should and do not dispatch the drones and do not make any type of decision like this.

If information derived using computers didn't play a role in the modern militaries of the world, they wouldn't be modern militaries.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by bane on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:07AM (#9433350)
I dunno, I guess it's because people don't understand that drones aren't autonomous, and think Skynet or robot overlords fly them and pull the trigger.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by jjoonathan on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:39AM (#9433598)
No need to guess, the reason why people are uncomfortable with drone strikes is in the title:

"U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes"

If you're a soldier on the ground you have useful heuristics for determining who is an enemy combatant ("are they shooting at me?") that drone operators don't. You also have mechanisms for limiting collateral damage that drone operators don't. Which isn't to say that these tools are employed all the time, but at least they exist, whereas with drones the official strategy for limiting collateral damage is "re-define 'enemy combatant' to mean anyone of military age killed by the drone."

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by tomjen3 on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:19AM (#9433924)
Soldiers in Iraq mostly died from IEDS, car bombs and ambushes where you have no way to identify the enemy before he attacks you.

Heck we levelled Hamburg and Dresden, burned Tokyo to the ground and nuked two Japanese cities. Why even talk about drones?

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by bane on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:40AM (#9433609)
how is that different from any air strike?
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by skywhopper on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:58AM (#9433751)
It's not. But drone strikes are far more common currently, and are killing far more people than any traditional air strikes being used lately. If we were currently carpet-bombing Tehran and killing thousands of civilians, I would be more upset about that. But right now, drone attacks are one of the least defensible things our government is doing.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by bane on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:23AM (#9433953)
> But drone strikes are far more common currently

I here this from time to time, but I wonder how true this actually is. My guess is that most military actions are not publicly reported, so we don't have number to compare.

My understanding is that there are a few ways to reach out and kill people from far away:

- snipers

- artillery

- ground-to-ground missiles/rockets

- air-to-ground missiles/rockets

- ship-to-ground missiles

- aerial artillery/cannon (Spectre, A-10, Apache)

- air-to-ground bombs (for argument let's assume only "precision" munitions)

- drone strikes (which are a kind of air-to-ground missile, but we'll beak them out as distinct for fiscussion)

Before drones became common, all of the rest of the above were used frequently in both Iraq and Afghanistan (and in every previous modern conflict), yet there wasn't this kind of "let's have a problem with this specific method" and plenty of wedding parties and civilians were killed. Yet with the exception of snipers, none of these involve getting personal with the targets, and collateral damage is well known to happen with all of these methods.

In context, drones aren't really any different, yet they seem to be singles out because...?

My guess is that it's a fundamental lack of understanding of what drones are and how they work. My guess is that most people out there who specifically have a problem with drones, but don't comment on the rest of the methods, have a niggling suspicion that they work by showing a picture of a bad guy to a drone or letting it sniff a captured sock or something and sending it out on a kill mission and this cold computer killer terrifies them because of too many movies. But they effectively work the same as any of the other methods.

The same missiles, probably the same cameras/sensors and the same operators, ordered by the same command chain with the same legal oversight make the same decision to shoot-to-kill in the same way. Arguments about not wanting to put U.S. pilots in harms way also ring false since nobody the U.S. is shooting at has an effective airspace denial system in place.

The only thing the drones bring to the table is loiter time, and I'm not sure that "as loiter time approaches balloon or kite" crosses some kind of moral threshold that wasn't already crossed by any other listed method. There simply wasn't this kind of anti-AC-130H or anti-A-10 movement around when they were chewing up people. Nobody came down on Helicopter gunships, as a class of killing devices, even after Wikileaks' Collateral Murder came out.

It seems to me that the moral problem that should be addressed is killing people from far away, not the specific method you use to do it.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by jjoonathan on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:59AM (#9434201)
If we picture the political landscape of acceptable war tactics as a battlefield on which "war hawks" (seeking primarily to maximize military efficacy) and "peacenicks" (seeking primarily to minimize collateral damage) fight each other, then the items 1-7 on your list represent entrenched warhawk fortifications while the 8th represents a recent and relatively undefended warhawk raiding party. The peacenicks are attacking it.

In this analogy, your argument is "the peacenicks aren't effectively fighting the warhawks because they are only attacking the raiding party rather than the entrenched defenses." I have an alternative theory: they're attacking the raiding party because doing so gives the best expected ROI.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by bane on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:07PM (#9435022)
But it also seems hypocritical. Because they aren't being attacked, are the other methods okay? In terms of raw brutality, drones are hardly the worst thing on that list.

Points about cost-per-life taken also ring hollow, the U.S. military budget is virtually unlimited, it's not cost sensitive in that kind of way.

Drones offer marginally more safety for operators, but no theater the U.S. is engaged in or is likely to be engaged in is likely to offer resistance to any of the other methods. And other methods also offer similar safety margins for operators. Ship-to-ground missiles for example, offer virtually the same risk as drones.

I'm not saying fighting drones is a pointless argument to make. Each of the methods is open to criticism, but by only attacking one, it reeks of a kind of protest fadism - of losing the plot. Is the problem killing people, or is the problem killing people with drones?

Here's an alternative scenario for why drones are actually popular with hawks, and it's not safety or direct cost: they offer vastly longer loiter time and better real-time surveillance over an area compared to any other method or group of methods, which means they provide greater targeting and attack opportunity on the off-chance a difficult to find target presents itself.

To go with your analogy, by not attacking the entrenchments, it signals to the hawks that it's okay to keep sending raiding parties, because they'll eventually end up fortified.

I appreciate this discussion by the way.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by jjoonathan on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:49AM (#9433688)
It's not, but I doubt that the people complaining about drone strikes are perfectly OK with air strikes. Drones are the most visible and most rapidly expanding facet of the problem so it's not unreasonable to focus the discussion around them.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by bane on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:58AM (#9433757)
Right, so it seems like a distraction to me to focus on one facet of something not to agree with rather than the whole problem.

Turned around the problem with this argument is that it's solved by getting to know the people you are about to kill.

Which sounds rather silly if the point is to protest killing people at all.

Or if we stay focused on drones, just kill them with one of the other dozen remote methods we have at our disposal.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by jjoonathan on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:47AM (#9434117)
Drones make indiscriminate killing more economical (in terms of U.S. lives and $). Politically attacking drones is a pragmatic, reasonable strategy with which to oppose indiscriminate killing.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by brosefstalin on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:37AM (#9432855)
Maybe because it's so impersonal to pilot a remote-controlled toy on a screen thousands of miles away that when you see little black and white pixels moving on your TV, you have less moral qualms about pushing the little red button on your joystick?

Maybe because you're so far away from that reality -- literally and figuratively -- that you're not experiencing your conscience and the fear of consequences quite the same way, making it easier to take reckless actions that you would otherwise think twice about had it been coming directly from the barrel of your gun, so to speak?

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by Mithaldu on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:45AM (#9432904)
Good question, but seriously, no.

You can actually test that hypothesis yourself very easily. Go look at some of the more gory scenes from Saw, or the Aliens movies. If you're like many typical internet people they won't even phase you. Now go and find some of the typical rotten.com / liveleak content and see how much you can stomach of that. Likely not a lot and not easily at all.

Knowing that something is real makes a MASSIVE difference.

Further, being on the ground with a gun, facing armed and active enemies² makes you more likely and less inhibited to recklessly kill people, because while there may be consequences to killing, the consequence to being killed is FAR greater.

Soldiers need to be trained to not go full auto with their rifles for a reason.

² Just a note to make clear that i edited that part in as clarification.

vvvv For one, that book doesn't seem to cover direct vs remote combat, which is the comparison i was making, and further: Read the reviews underneath.

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by Spearchucker on Friday April 24, 2015 @09:56AM (#9433272)
"...being on the ground with a gun makes you more likely and less inhibited..."

It's actually the exact opposite. Seeing the person you're about to kill makes it harder to pull the trigger (given a normal psychology, for whatever that's worth). If you're interested, the book linked to below goes into great detail about this.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/aw/d/0316040932/

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by CHY872 on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:27AM (#9433982)
Yes, but historically armies have proved more than adept at drilling those instincts out of people.
Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by afarrell on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:40AM (#9433611)
But a pilot of a manned aircraft has a limited, possibly zero time to observe the people in question. A pilot of an unmanned aircraft has a much longer time.

""" “Remotely piloted aircraft pilots may stare at the same piece of ground for days,” said Jean Lin Otto, an epidemiologist who was a co-author of the study. “They witness the carnage. Manned aircraft pilots don’t do that. They get out of there as soon as possible.” """ http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/23/us/drone-pilots-found-to-g...

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by bane on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:10AM (#9433372)
It's a good point, but it's also not clear if the experience is materially all that different from dropping a bomb from 30,000 ft.

The view from a Spectre gunship isn't materially all that different than from a drone operator's position. And there's quite a bit of evidence that drone operators do suffer similar psychological problems as in-theater operators.

http://www.salon.com/2015/03/06/a_chilling_new_post_traumati...

Re:U.S. Is Often Unsure About Who Will Die in Drone Strikes by mc32 on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:09AM (#9433840)
A drone pilot is apt to make fewer errors and more time to think before unloading. This removal from immediate reality is a double edged sword, there is less immediate harm to them but that also affords the remote pilot to consider things more coldly and calculatedly. There is more Tim to think before unloading, so that means fewer mistakes. When you have humanned aircraft, you get lots more collateral and unintended casualties.

People intrinsically have a problem with the clinicality of technological enhancement.

Imagine an algorithm which could tell a police force who is likely out to commit crimes given observed parameters (time, route, familiarity in area, vehicle, passengers, origin, destination, income, education, criminal history, etc) people would be freaked out. I'm sure some day well have this and people will wish for good old police walking the beat, mistakenly stopping the wrong person, but at least its not an impersonal algorithm targeting you.