- Could be used for entrapment, that is to say, could send over potentially criminal information and argue that the user did in fact "receive" it since it was read.
- If you could inject your own tracker into someone else's email, you might also gleam when and potentially how they read that email.
- One funny thing that came to mind. In Australian contract law (likely similar to the UK from which the laws were adopted), if you email someone an your acceptance to a offer, that acceptance is deemed as received when the email is read (the person becomes aware of the acceptance). Where as with regular postal mail, the offer is accepted when posted (the "postal rule", a nice headache). If you had a tracking code, it would be harder to to argue you weren't aware of the acceptance by email. That is unless your email client pre-fetches images before the email itself is opened...
I don't really see why you'd care about tracking pixels 99% of the time. If you purchase something from us and we email you, it's super useful for both of us to know if you have read the email (purchase receipt or booking confirmation.)
I personally don't see much spam and what I do see I just delete, so tracking pixels in those aren't an issue for me.
Why? If I'm interested in the email, I'll request it (i.e. if I'm purchasing something from you, me receiving confirmation emails from you should be opt-in, either in my user settings on your site or on a per-purchase basis). If I'm not interested in the email, I'll click the "unsubscribe" link in the email (you do include unsubscribe links, right?) or otherwise specify such in - again - my user settings.
In other words, that's not your call to make. That's my call to make, and your explanation is sounding like a very weak excuse to pin my privacy to a table and give it a night it'll never forget.
I could imagine that geolocating my IP might be undesirable at times. I wonder what are other potential security (not privacy) implications.
I too don't understand what's to be gained from a tool like this. If the party collecting the data abuses it to spam you then you simply unsubscribe/block the emails altogether. And of course they know you know you can do this, which gives them incentive to not do that.
I mean, one can legitimately want that they do not receive the tracking information. But are there any real security implications, like siphoning off any unauthorized data, facilitating spam, etc?