News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by kijin on Monday April 20, 2015 @09:42PM (#9411856)
Stop rules are fine, we'd probably go insane if we didn't use them. But as soon as somebody questions the validity of a stop rule, it should cease to be a stop rule and become subject to rational examination. Once you are satisfied that it is indeed valid, it becomes a stop rule again... until next time.

In other words, we should be comfortable with switching between two modes: a "production" mode where we rely on our stop rules to get things done efficiently, and a "debugging" mode where we can step back to examine our source code. Failure to switch modes like this leads to assholery as exemplified by the various examples mentioned in the article.

The most dangerous stop rules are the ones you don't understand. Most non-IT business executives have no understanding of how encryption works. It's magic to them. Therefore, they are incapable of stepping back and examining it. They segfault as soon as they try to switch modes, so after a while, they don't even try. Most DRM schemes are the same. It's a mantra that they chant without understanding. And from the point of view of consumers who suffer from the consequences, sufficiently serious incompetence is indistinguishable from malice.

Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by edent on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @02:29AM (#9412551)
The irony of someone talking about facts and then referencing the Myers Briggs scam!

An absolutely discredited pseudoscience which exists solely to make money for the corporation which peddles it.

An excellent example of a stop rule there - "I am this MBTI therefore..."

https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2012/12/astrology-for-businesses/

Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by e12e on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @02:41AM (#9412581)
Some good points, except for the point about passwords: passwords are rarely encrypted. While you could say that a salted hash might obfuscate the plaintext of the password - it's not encrypted -- and it can't be de-crypted.

It is of course possible to store passwords encrypted, but that is rarely done.

Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by kijin on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @03:04AM (#9412627)
From the point of view of people who treat encryption as a black box and don't care about the details, the passwords are "encrypted" all right. The point of the article is to criticize these people, so the technically incorrect choice of word might be intentional.

Also, it often makes sense to treat hashing as a kind of encryption. It just happens to be a kind of encryption that cannot be (easily) reversed.

Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by e12e on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @04:14AM (#9412781)
I supppose you're right, apparently encryption is a relatively new term, derived as a synonym to encode from crypt (derived from cryptic) whose meaning is defined (among other things) as: "to change (information) from one form to another especially to hide its meaning".

So in the colloquial use, encryption does apparently not imply that decryption is possible.

I don't buy the argument that "lots of people use the term wrong, so lets just continue to do that". (As it turns out, I might have been the person to understand the term wrongly, and the word choice might not have been "technically incorrect" after all. Always challenge your assumptions :-)

Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by oxplot on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @11:53AM (#9414896)
It is however considered a good practice and recommended [1].

[1]: https://crackstation.net/hashing-security.htm

Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by e12e on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @02:45PM (#9416097)
See my other comment re: "encrypted".

In general terms, hashing a combination of a salt and the plaintext password is recommended. The problem with encrypting the password, is that typically an attack that exposes the encrypted password will also expose the encryption key -- allowing the recovery of the plaintext password by simply decrypting the ciphertext password that is stored.

[deleted]
Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by jessaustin on Monday April 20, 2015 @08:07PM (#9411594)
Haha, touché. Actually I suspect this writer has any number of rules like this, and he's happy to either use them or not as the situation seems to warrant. Perhaps it would be better to always try to help people think more rationally, but it might save time to just disengage from irrational discussion.
Re:RFIDs, Encryption, and Stop Rules by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @08:00AM (#9413410)
There's nothing I love more than articles that are full of 'look how much smarter I am than everybody else'.