News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by JoeAltmaier on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:13PM (#9409842)
The point was, they want to feed themselves. Profit is further down the road.
Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by ido on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:19PM (#9410229)
I think for the cost of moving 86m people halfway across the world you can probably develop Ethiopia instead (Israel produces 95% of its own food while being more arid than Ethiopia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture_in_Israel)
Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by JoeAltmaier on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:25PM (#9410660)
Just to speculate on that:

Talking about Tigray, with a population of 4.3 millions. I wonder if the equipment to farm to feed those people would actually weigh less than the people? A few thousand boat trips would serve to move them all. In fact, once a fraction had been moved, pressure would be reduce in Tigray to house and feed the remainder.

Remember America took in 65 Million people over its history. Most of those came by steam ship. Today it would be faster and cheaper by far.

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by ido on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @05:25AM (#9412971)

    I wonder if the equipment to farm to feed those people
    would actually weigh less than the people
I would certainly think so, considering how advanced modern farming tech is (or even 50 years old farming tech). 4.3m people plus food/water/other stuff they need to survive a couple weeks on a ship (plus then transporting them overland to wherever) weighs A LOT, fuel & vessels to transport them are also not trivial.

The farm equipment also doesn't have to come from America, there are far closer manufacturers (Israel is ~3000km by ship from Eilat, Europe or India ~1000-2000 more).

Anyway hauling millions of people over to America sounds like a pretty ridiculous solution to me. You think the US government would accept millions of refugees with open arms? Why did the majority of Iraqi war refugees had to come to Europe instead?

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @08:35AM (#9413571)
Remember the farm equipment needs support too. Like that food and water, you need fuel, tires, parts, lubricants, expert mechanics...so from a sustainability viewpoint, its likely easier to move people where the technology is, than to try to transplant the technology to where the people are.

And the idea is more a speculative engineering question. What kind of solutions would be more efficient, IF ONLY politics didn't get in the way?

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by ido on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @08:47AM (#9413628)
I don't know, but I would be really surprised if moving millions of people is more efficient than moving sufficient amount of agricultural equipment & some farmers to get them started on using them correctly (remember that a lot of these people are already farmers, just not using modern tools/fertilizers).

Not to mention it's at least slightly offensive & like treating people like cattle to move them around wholesale like that. Ultimately the problem is not the climate or soil it's the (mis)allocations of resources.

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @10:51AM (#9414401)
Ethiopia has periodic crippling drought. So it is the climate. Water is very precious there. That's the impetus behind the question which can be stated as "Move the people to water, or scavenge water where the people are".

Again, the 'offensive' argument is political. Trying to just compare outcomes, to know what to shoot for in the political realm. Remember, these are already refugees, there against their will.

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by ido on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @12:46PM (#9415295)
And yet Israel has less hospitable climate and it's doing just fine, due to resources invested in water reclamation/desalination and high(er) tech agriculture[1].

I think you really overestimate how harsh the climate in Ethiopia is - it's not like trying to colonize Mars or Arrakis. It's hardly the Sahara either. The climate is in fact less harsh than fairly extensive parts of the US (particularly the West).

[1] Israel was also doing quite well even when it was a fairly poor country in the 50s/60s (although it was never as dirt poor as Ethiopia).

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @03:16PM (#9416338)
Tigray is classed as 'hot, semi-arid'. So only semi-desert I guess. Israel is pretty much the poster child for western technological development of arid land, with high education and no cap on the budget. Not fair.

To look at it another way, consider a village of 200 refugees. Instead of importing a tractor, mechanic, fuel supply route, parts, seed, education, engineering know-how etc.

Consider moving those 200 people to where the parts store is not 10,000 miles away. Arguably cheaper.

Most of America is uninhabited for instance. I heard once that everybody in China could fit in Montana easily. There're 100M acres in Montana, so maybe that's a stretch - 20 people supported by 1 acres is unlikely.

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by ido on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @03:47PM (#9416562)
Yes, moving 200 people (and probably also 2,000 or even 20,000) is easier than building the required infrastructure to grow food for them. But after a certain point moving more people grows costs approximately linearly where as growing food via modern farming does not.

That's how modern rich countries like the USA can be net food exporters while employing less than 2% of the population (you will find similar figures in other developed countries). A village of 200 people in the middle of nowhere probably can't be fed by 4 farmers regardless of how much equipment they have.

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @03:51PM (#9416585)
Yet those people in Ethiopia were using hand labor and baskets to build dams. That doesn't look like scalable western farming. It looks a lot harder. So the argument "Move them to the West where modern farming techniques are available" now becomes very, very much more efficient that leaving them where they are.
Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by ido on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @04:01PM (#9416645)

    So the argument "Move them to the West where modern
    farming techniques are available" now becomes very, 
    very much more efficient that leaving them where they 
    are.
But the argument wasn't for "just leaving them where they are" - it was for bringing them modern farming techniques.

The reason that wasn't done has more to do with politics and economics (in the sense that there isn't as much money to be made by doing so - same reason why nobody is going to spend billions/trillions bringing them to Montana).

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday April 21, 2015 @04:12PM (#9416713)
Right, to be honest, nobody is going to bring them modern farm techniques either. It costs too much. They're going to remain in extreme poverty, building a few mud dams and raising corn with their muscles, for as long as they live.

But if you Were to spend money on improving their lot, then I'd much rather transport a culturally significant number of them to a convenient location where their efforts could leverage modern resources.

Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by ido on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:01AM (#9418733)
I guess we can agree to disagree about what would be more desirable/effective.
Re:Turning Ethiopia's desert green by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @08:50AM (#9419972)
Sure; but its not actually what WE think that matters. Ask them if they would LIKE to emigrate to America. What do you think? Would they want to stay in their semi-arid dust bowl? Or move to Northeast Iowa and farm with regular rain, fabulous soil and ready markets?