The best reason to believe we're not in a bubble is that people are still talking about a bubble.
It'll take a few more years till we're really at a new peak of irrational exuberance, till everyone has forgotten the last bubble and the damage it caused, till huge valuations with no profits seem completely rational, and no one dares speak out for fear of looking a fool and missing out on the huge gains everyone else is making. At that point, when no-one is talking about bubbles any more (either pro or con), we've entered a new normal, and once again people are talking about the end of history, we'll be in a bubble.
What could pop this bubble when it comes to fruition? There are lots of possibilities, but a dip in profits at one of the big advertising companies might be enough to stop acquisitions and hiring and hit valuation badly. No acquisitions means no exits, no exits means no investment, no investment means no advertising. When contractions arrive, they're often unexpected and impossible to stop, because markets run on confidence.
Volatility over the last few decades is certainly very high, possibly caused by the huge dislocations of globalisation, robotics and computerisation - very similar to the industrial revolution. I see no reason why that volatility would end right now, we are still in a transition period between a collection of protectionist nation states and a global economy, and between an industrial and an information economy. That means more bubbles and more crashes.
I'm curious - what do you think the mechanisms are for unraveling private investment over exuberance?
Just for example, if we assumed that valuations are 100x above reality and things will continue getting worse for a few years. Is it effectively like sub-prime rather than 2000?
Sub-prime was pretty sudden with banks rushing to exit their positions. What could happen here? A couple of fire-sale IPOs and then all these investors have to admit their balance sheets are nonsense? Would this cause economic contagion or will it be the pension-funds that are left holding the bag?
Note how few hedge funds exploded in the 2008-9 crisis. Rather what we've seen from the hedge funds is several years of underwhelming returns. I wonder if part of that is slowly meting out the losses that they never declared back in '09.
Banks are hopefully doing less of the big private investments? (I don't actually know). In that case this might be the kind of bubble, like the Tokyo property bubble of the late '80s, that never actually pops, just slowly deflates.
Also, I love CB Insights.
The other reason was the Fed had interest rates at artificially low levels to try and boost the economy after the dotcom bubble burst (Rather than just let it work out and let interest rates be at the true cost of money.)
When you force people to buy things and you incentivize buying things by making the cost of them lower, you're going to get a lot of people buying that asset.
In 2001 that asset was houses.
By 2007, I had spent 5 years investing on this thesis and called the top. I as off by a year, and missed the actual top which happened in 2008, but I am not complaining.
The point being, people who understand economics is a science and were paying attention to what was going on knew there was a bubble, long before it burst, and in fact, before it startsed to inflate. I didn't figure it out myself, btw, I read an article in 2001 that clued me in.
I can't say whether there is a bubble in startup valuations. I'm not making that argument.
I will say there is a bubble in the US Dollar, because the strategy employed by the government to fight the dotcom bust is the same one they deployed to fight the housing bust, they just changed the targets.
As a result we're seeing the stock market in a bubble and a lot of froth in the economy, but it's widely distributed (rather than concentrated in houses).
This will likely allow the bubble to inflate much longer.... but it also means the bursting will be much more dramatic and damaging.
Hindsight Bias - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindsight_bias
If you are so sure that you could predict this, then is it safe to assume that you are worth millions now? I'm sure you can understand that if someone has full knowledge something will take place, that it'd be extremely easy to put money into the system that you could game.
> The point being, people who understand economics is a science and were paying attention to what was going on knew there was a bubble, long before it burst, and in fact, before it startsed to inflate. I didn't figure it out myself, btw, I read an article in 2001 that clued me in.
Economics is a science? I'd love to hear more.
If that were the case, you would expect to see CRA loans performing worse than private loans. But the opposite was true--loans to persons in CRA-eligible zip codes performed slightly better than loans to otherwise similar borrowers.[1]
[1] http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/20081203_ana...
Here are several in support of a bubble.
1. There were 9x as many $100 million private financing rounds as there were $100 million public offerings. People are starting to call these private IPOs which is a bit of an oxymoron but the point around private market money being plentiful and even providing some liquidity to founders and early investors is happening even in some private transactions.
2. In the first 3.5 months of this year, there were 16 new companies that raised money at a billion dollar valuation or higher. There were 15 in all of 2013.
3. All sorts of new money is flowing into the market, i.e. private equity, hedge funds, mutual funds, corporations and sovereign wealth funds.
Why we are NOT in a bubble.
1. All of the US unicorns combined are worth less than Facebook
2. They collectively are worth 3.5% of the Nasdaq 100. Of course, notable tech companies like Twitter are also on NYSE so the % is overstated.
3. The public markets have not lost their mind. In fact, they're fairly hostile to new issuances which despite VC bellyaching is a good thing for VCs and in maintaing the current climate. When retail investors get burned on tech, the bubble will quickly pop. But right now, that's not the case as just calling yourself tech doesn't guarantee a high valuation. The market, while still far from perfect, treats companies with crappy or suspect fundamentals with skepticism (see Box).
4. There is no mechanism that will force a quick contraction. A bubble is typified by rapid expansion and contraction of asset values. The expansion part is happening for sure.
5. But there is not scorecard to provide the contraction. When companies are publicly traded, you have that daily scorecard to force it, but right now, it's private money going in and the beauty of the private markets is you can bury your dead very quietly. In essence, the opacity of the private markets enables investors to point to any failing investment or investor and just say "they were dumb money, we are different". And so there is no event that will pop it.
Notes:
A. I'm the CEO of CB Insights. We track private company financings and exits.
B. A crazy exogenous factor like a disease pandemic, terrorism, a China meltdown, war, etc are not considered in the above. If I could predict those with any certainty, I'd be doing that.
C. I gave a presentation at the Quebec Venture Capital and Private Equity conference this past week on this topic "Bubbles, Unicorn and Our Crazy Private Markets". It may be of interest if you're interested in the data behind some of the above bullets.
https://www.cbinsights.com/reports/tech-bubble-unicorns.pdf