News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by jjwiseman on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:38AM (#9402049)
I'm curious to see how 3D Robotics handles a similar situation. Their drone platform has been open source hardware plus open source software. There are Chinese companies cloning the hardware and selling it for much cheaper than 3D Robotics sells it for.

3D Robotics just raised $50M in a series C. It will be interesting to see how their commitment to openness holds up.

Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by erkkie on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:56AM (#9402079)
I'm curious about that as well, some people have bet it's gonna be a mix of open hardware and proprietary (even if just by code) "governors", something the newest launch, the solo (http://3drobotics.com/solo/), would be well-equipped to do (I haven't done the research to confirm/deny that yet).
Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by steve19 on Sunday April 19, 2015 @01:13AM (#9402112)
3D Robotics only open source the flight controller hardware and software and ground control software. delivering a safe drone platform requires a lot more hardware (the aircraft itself, camera and radio gear) and firmware (camera, gimbal, speed controller radio gear).
Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by jjwiseman on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:59PM (#9410126)
My guess, though, is that as the industry matures, low-level components like ESC & radio firmwares are not really going to be where most value gets added. Software is definitely going to eat the drone world, and it's going to be at the higher levels: First it will be flight software with amazing new features (VSLAM, sense and avoid, swarm control) and then once that's more mature, it will be the operations-level super-ground-control-system stuff.
Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by erkkie on Sunday April 19, 2015 @01:49AM (#9402168)
Technically the ground control software is a separate open source project, also the px4 project is looking to release a open hardware esc (electronic speed controller) soon as well (https://pixhawk.org/modules/pixhawk_esc).

Agreed though, the magic is in the total sum.

Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by jkestner on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:18AM (#9403203)
Agreed that it will be an interesting study. 3DR needs to cross the chasm into mass acceptance before their cost-conscious hobbyist base migrates. (Consider this in the light of Anderson's comparisons to the Apple II.) As others pointed out, MakerBot's tech couldn't make the leap, and 3D printing doesn't have a mass market on the horizon.

If 3DR drones are more expensive, it's not only because they're not made in China. Manufacturing in Mexico is cheap enough, and buys you lead time, which suits their extremely fast iteration. A good idea in this gold rush.

People will pay more for the brand, if it stands for great support and integration. China is traditionally poor at those. 3DR started with a community, and regular people diving into drones will appreciate this comfort level.

TL;DR: To fight cheaper, make it better.

Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by xenadu02 on Sunday April 19, 2015 @04:18AM (#9402393)
What does that say about the idea of doing open hardware in general? You do all the work, some other manufacturer in China greatly undercuts you. How is that a good idea?
Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by xorcist on Sunday April 19, 2015 @04:54AM (#9402458)
How's that any different from pretty much any easily-copied business? How do Nike or Levi's survive, when pretty much any basement shop in China can undercut them on shoes and jeans?

The answer is your brand must must mean something. Be the domain expert. Be the one people turn to with questions. When the clones arrive, you are already ahead. That's easier said than done, and execution is everything and so on and so on. But there's not a vast difference between the open hardware space and other manufacturing businesses.

Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by crimsonalucard on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:41AM (#9403292)
Nike and Levi's are bad examples. They use brands as illusions of superiority. Money in this case is not spent on R&D but spent on marketing.

Also how can you be the domain expert if you open source everything you know? The millions you spend on R&D are given away and allow others to arrive at the same knowledge for $0. How does that work out for a company from a competitive standpoint? You are basically shooting yourself in the foot in terms of staying ahead and being a domain expert.

Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by fit2rule on Sunday April 19, 2015 @05:58AM (#9402591)
This is a natural consequence of having contributed to a society where China does all the work, anyway.

Either beat China at the manufacturing game, or continually be side-swiped by Chinese manufacturers.

Alas, no amount of open source anything is going to assist with that challenge ..

Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:08AM (#9402988)
Don't try to beat China at manufacturing. That's a fool's errand for nearly everyone. Let them make most of the things. Concentrate on quality and whatever your core business is.
Re:What doomed MakerBot? The Osborne effect by fit2rule on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:36AM (#9406802)
I believe an emerging ethos indeed is that you must 'beat China' at its own game by simply, building local - i.e. do the global warming thing, and turn off the boats. The planes. &etc.

And instead build more robots. Local robots. Robots that build other robots, and .. things.

It is an emerging ethos, the local DIY-industrialist; actually a catch-up of the spirit that made China such cheap prowess in the first place, but when it happens as a Western phenomenon - i.e. local all the things. - it will indeed mean less cheap plastic crap floating around the ecosphere.

At least one can hope. An energy revolution and 3d-printing/transposing tech need not always start with a Fedex delivery. ("Solve global warming: stop using Fedex!")